Review Article

A Review of the Studies on the Effect of Different Additives on the Fatigue Behavior of Asphalt Mixtures

Table 4

Impact of nanomaterials on the fatigue performance of asphalt mixture.

NanomaterialDosagesType of asphalt binderOptimum content based on fatigue resultsFatigue
test
Test temperatureMode of loadingReferences

Nanoclay:
Cloisite 15-A and
Cloisite 30-B
2%, 4%, and 6% by wt. of mix.60–70 pen grade4PBT5, 25°CControlled stressAmeri et al. [79]
Nanoclays did not have a significant effect on fatigue performance at low temperatures
Cloisite 15-A was more impressive at both temperatures in terms of fatigue life

Nanoclay:
Cloisite-15A
Nanofill-15
0.7% by wt. of asphalt binder60–70 pen gradeITFT5, 25°CControlled stressJahromi [80]
Nanoclays had a negative effect on the fatigue performance of the asphalt mixture at low temperatures for all loading conditions

Nanoclay3% by wt. of asphalt binderPG 64-22DTCFT18°CControlled strainMiglietta et al. [81]
The use of binders containing nanoclays augmented the fatigue properties of asphalt mixtures

Nano-TiO21%, 3%, and 5% by wt. of asphalt binder60–70 pen grade5%ITFT5, 25, 40°CControlled stressShafabakhsh et al. [82]
Nano-TiO2 improved the fatigue performance of asphalt mixes by preventing crack generation and hindering the propagation of microcracks

Nano-TiO23% and 6% by wt. of asphalt binder85–100 pen grade6%ITFT5°CControlled stressAzarhoosh et al. [83]
The nano-modified asphalt mixture presented higher fatigue life than the control mixtures due to the improvement of cohesion energy and higher resistance to fatigue cracking in asphalt film

Nanocalcium carbonate (NCC)2% and 4% by wt. of asphalt binder85–100 pen grade4%ITFT15°CControlled stressNejad et al. [84]
The fatigue life improved 41.4% and 55.8% for 2% and 4% NCC, respectively

Nanozinc oxide (ZnO)1%, 3%, 5%, and 7% by wt. of asphalt binder85–100 pen grade7%ITFT5°CControlled stressAzarhoush et al. [85]
The asphalt mixtures containing ZnO had higher fatigue life than the control mixtures due to increased adhesion energy between the asphalt binder and aggregate

CNT0.3%, 0.6%, 0.9%, 1.2%, and 1.5% by wt. of asphalt binder60–70 pen grade1.5%4PBT25°CControlled strainZiari et al. [86]
CNT increased the fatigue life of the asphalt mixture. In other words, using CNT led to an increase in cumulative dissipated energy and a decrease in the average rate of damage propagation

CNT0.2%, 0.5%, 0.8%, 1.2%, and 1.5% by wt. of asphalt binder60–70 pen grade1.5%4PBT25°CControlled strainAmeri et al. [87]
By increasing the CNT content, the plateau value (PV) decreased considerably, implying that CNT has a beneficial effect on the fatigue resistance of asphalt mixtures

Graphene nanoplatelets
(GNPs)
0.5%
by wt. of asphalt binder
60–70 pen gradeITFT25°CControlled stressShamami et al. [88]
The fatigue life improved by 55% due to the high specific surface area of GNPs and the high adhesion between the bitumen and aggregates