Research Article

[Retracted] Meta-Analysis of Tai Chi Chuan in Treating Lumbar Spondylosis and Back Pain

Table 1

Summary of the studies selected for meta-analysis.

AuthorYearCountrySample sizeAgeDiagnosisProgram of interventionTraining sessionsTai Chi styleReported outcomeAdverse event reported

He et al.2013China20/20Tai Chi: 58.56 ± 4.23
Control: 59.38 ± 4.78
3 m chronic lower back painTai Chi vs. unaltered lifestyle60 min/session
36 sessions
ChenDisabilityNot reported
Zhao et al.2013China15/15Tai Chi: 58.92 ± 3.65
Control: 57.35 ± 2.97
Chronic lower back painTai Chi vs. unaltered60 min/session. 3 sessions per week
36 sessions
ChenDisabilityNot reported
Muharram et al.2011China82/82Tai Chi: 43.6 ± 6.5
Control: 43.3 ± 7.2
3.04 ± 1.56 y
Chronic lower back pain
Tai Chi_health education vs. health education60 min/session, 72 sessionsChenPain (visual analogue scale, disability)Not reported
Song et al.2008China37/31Tai Chi: 42.69 ± 15.38
Control: 40.72 ± 13.10
13 ± 9 m
Lumbar disc herniation
Tai Chi + physiotherapy vs. physiotherapy60 min/session, 144 sessionsNot reportedPain (visual analogue scale, disability)Not reported
Hall et al.2011Australia80/80Tai Chi: 43.4 ± 13.5
Control: 44.3 ± 13.0
3 m
Nonspecific lower back pain
Tai Chi + unaltered lifestyle40 min/session, 10 weeks, 18 sessionsNot reportedPain (numerical rating scale), disabilityReported
Tong et al.2016China32/32Tai Chi: 32.6 ± 6.46
Control: 32.66 ± 6.53
3 m
Nonspecific lower back pain
Tai Chi + unaltered lifestyle7 sessions/week, 28 sessionsNot reportedPain (visual analogue scale, disability)Not reported
Lin et al.2015China30/3041.00 ± 9.22Not reported, chronic lower back painTai Chi + massage, massage6 sessions per week, 12 sessionsNot reportedPain (visual analogue scale)Not reported