Research Article
Calculation of Friction Force for Slurry Pipe Jacking considering Soil-Slurry-Pipe Interaction
Table 1
Comparison between the calculated frictions and the measured frictions.
| | Cases | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | | Montmor | Chatenay | Champigy | Neuilly 1 | Neuilly 2 | Bordeaux | Anthens 1 | Anthens 2 | F city | H city | Shenyang | Shanghai |
| | Measured friction (kN/m) | 6.79 | 5.13 | 6.69 | 9.55 | 10.37 | 0.79∼3.93 | 10.4 | 16.4 | 6.79 | 1.51 | 24.6∼50 | 10.59∼17.73 | | Calculation results | Terzaghi (Japan) | 2ε (°) | 4∼13 | 7∼21 | 128 | 1∼8 | 125∼130 | 2∼130 | 40∼87 | 40∼87 | 34∼57 | 15∼46 | 22∼73 | 16∼19 | | μ | 0.014∼0.019 | 0.017∼0.024 | 0.071∼0.072 | 0.011∼0.015 | 0.151∼0.099 | 0.011∼0.122 | 0.037∼0.065 | 0.037∼0.065 | 0.046∼0.049 | 0.016∼0.027 | 0.029∼0.077 | 0.023∼0.025 | | Ff | 0.64∼2.33 | 0.59∼1.73 | 2.68∼3.42 | 0.15∼0.58 | 2.25∼3.95 | 0.19∼1.78 | 2.57∼9.86 | 2.57∼9.86 | 2.33∼3.94 | 0.92∼2.27 | 20.64∼58.09 | 7.84∼19.73 | | Ratio | 9%∼34% | 12%∼34% | 40%∼51% | 2%∼6% | 22%∼38% | 24%∼45% | 25%∼93% | 16%∼59% | 34%∼58% | 61%∼150% | 84%∼116% | 74%∼111% | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | PJA (UK) | 2ε (°) | 15∼22 | 21∼33 | 128 | 3∼14 | 125∼130 | 4∼130 | 47∼99 | 47∼99 | 56∼66 | 15∼46 | 37∼89 | 17∼27 | | μ | 0.019∼0.033 | 0.024∼0.045 | 0.071∼0.104 | 0.012∼0.026 | 0.094∼0.158 | 0.013∼0.122 | 0.04∼0.078 | 0.04∼0.078 | 0.048∼0.08 | 0.017∼0.026 | 0.09∼0.091 | 0.023∼0.031 | | Ff | 2.83∼7.40 | 2.77∼5.42 | 3.15∼5.16 | 0.69∼1.77 | 5.68∼11.29 | 0.49∼5.10 | 3.27∼17.63 | 3.27∼17.63 | 4.69∼8.28 | 0.92∼2.22 | 43.77∼109.62 | 7.84∼38.64 | | Ratio | 42%∼109% | 54%∼106% | 47%∼77% | 7%∼19% | 55%∼109% | 62%∼130% | 31%∼170% | 20%∼108% | 69%∼122% | 61%∼147% | 178%∼219% | 83%∼203% | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | ATVA (Germany) | 2ε (°) | 14∼26 | 26∼34 | 128 | 4∼14 | 125∼130 | 5∼130 | 50∼105 | 50∼105 | 59∼66 | 16∼49 | 34∼90 | 18∼29 | | μ | 0.024∼0.029 | 0.027∼0.045 | 0.071∼0.104 | 0.012∼0.026 | 0.094∼0.158 | 0.014∼0.122 | 0.041∼0.082 | 0.041∼0.082 | 0.05∼0.08 | 0.017∼0.027 | 0.04∼0.092 | 0.024∼0.033 | | Ff | 3.53∼7.72 | 3.72∼5.65 | 3.69∼6.17 | 0.89∼1.70 | 7.05∼10.99 | 0.7∼8.76 | 3.63∼22.91 | 3.63∼22.91 | 5.28∼8.41 | 1∼2.52 | 46.83∼115.23 | 9.78∼40.57 | | Ratio | 52%∼114% | 72%∼110% | 55%∼92% | 9%∼18% | 68%∼106% | 88%∼223% | 35%∼220% | 22%∼140% | 78%∼124% | 66%∼167% | 190%∼230% | 92%∼229% | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
|
|
