Research Article
Multiscale Method for Seismic Response of Near-Source Sites
Table 3
Maximum node displacement and bending moments of 4 positions of structure at different depths (N·m).
| Depth(m) | Substructure type | Position | Node displacement (m) | Error (displacement) (%) | Section moment (N·m) | Error (moment) (%) | Source-site-structure calculation model | Method of this paper | Source-site-structure calculation model | Method of this paper |
| 50 | Open | A | 9.786 | 9.801 | 0.16 | −44844 | −45302 | 1.02 | B | 9.805 | 9.818 | 0.13 | −42397 | −41847 | −1.30 | C | 9.782 | 9.804 | 0.23 | −46152 | −45728 | −0.92 | D | 9.801 | 9.821 | 0.21 | −41177 | −41597 | 1.02 |
| 100 | Closed | A | 9.827 | 9.934 | 1.08 | −39796 | −41856 | 1.40 | B | 9.822 | 9.927 | 1.07 | −44640 | −46171 | 0.73 | C | 9.824 | 9.932 | 1.10 | −46400 | −47758 | 0.26 | D | 9.818 | 9.925 | 1.09 | −37440 | -38777 | 2.71 |
| 200 | Closed | A | 9.702 | 9.833 | 1.35 | −47532 | −49242 | 3.60 | B | 9.654 | 9.785 | 1.36 | −65236 | −66380 | 1.76 | C | 9.699 | 9.838 | 1.43 | −65344 | −69613 | 6.53 | D | 9.651 | 9.790 | 1.44 | −46495 | −47766 | 2.73 |
| 300 | Closed | A | 9.338 | 9.475 | 1.47 | 60056 | 60706 | 1.08 | B | 9.255 | 9.390 | 1.45 | −80187 | −82536 | 2.93 | C | 9.337 | 9.480 | 1.52 | −79990 | −82029 | 2.55 | D | 9.256 | 9.395 | 1.50 | 60629 | 61573 | 1.56 |
| 400 | Closed | A | 8.783 | 8.900 | 1.34 | 75814 | 76362 | 0.72 | B | 8.673 | 8.787 | 1.31 | −89635 | −92216 | 2.88 | C | 8.786 | 8.906 | 1.37 | −89308 | −91961 | 2.97 | D | 8.678 | 8.794 | 1.34 | 76405 | 77297 | 1.17 |
| 500 | Closed | A | 8.087 | 8.169 | 1.02 | 87633 | 95427 | 8.90 | B | 7.959 | 8.037 | 0.98 | −96458 | −96644 | 0.19 | C | 8.090 | 8.174 | 1.04 | −96151 | −106515 | 10.78 | D | 7.962 | 8.041 | 0.99 | 88115 | 84800 | 3.76 |
| 600 | Closed | A | 7.303 | 7.348 | 0.62 | 97320 | 106536 | 9.47 | B | 7.184 | 7.211 | 0.38 | −102589 | −103490 | 0.88 | C | 7.304 | 7.349 | 0.62 | −102144 | −112777 | 10.41 | D | 7.181 | 7.212 | 0.42 | 97801 | 94402 | 3.48 |
|
|