Cooperative Governance of Complex Public-Private Partnership Program: Case Study of Characteristic Town Program

Table 1

CCN and SRN centrality degree.

Types of stakeholders	CNN					SRN
	DC	Weighted degree centrality (WDC)	CC	BC	EC	DC	Weighted degree centrality (WDC)	CC	BC	EC
Private partner	2	4	0.396694	0	0.097775	1	2	0.286713	0	0
Government operations management company	4	4	0.40678	22.333333	0.104307	2	3	0.286713	13.666667	0.007922
SPV	44	83	0.648649	744.466667	1	8	13	0.392157	280	0.110452
Local Bureau of Finance	4	4	0.40678	22.333333	0.104307	2	3	0.286713	13.666667	0.007922
Local Development and Reform Commission	4	4	0.40678	22.333333	0.104307	2	3	0.286713	13.666667	0.007922
Project leading group	4	6	0.393443	21	0.097242	1	1	0.386139	0	0
Project headquarters	32	73	0.6	191.466667	0.941944	16	26	0.612903	342	0.222899
Designing unit of project	20	27	0.484848	62.5	0.60856	1	2	0	0	0.280442
Project contractor	24	42	0.564706	74.433333	0.894066	3	5	1	0	0.541617
Project supervisor	22	35	0.521739	63	0.776457	3	6	1	0	0.280442
Bank	2	2	0.396694	0	0.097775	1	2	0.286713	0	0
Other enterprises’ financial company	2	2	0.396694	0	0.097775	1	1	0.286713	0	0
Project supplier	22	33	0.521739	63	0.776457	3	5	0	0	1
Management unit of facilities	2	2	0.396694	0	0.097775	1	1	0	0	0.214977
Sewage waste management organization	12	27	0.527473	44.133333	0.421171	5	8	1	40	0.280442
Solid waste management organization	12	27	0.527473	44.133333	0.421171	5	8	1	40	0.280442
Water supply organization	12	27	0.527473	44.133333	0.421171	5	8	1	40	0.280442
Heating organization	12	27	0.527473	44.133333	0.421171	5	8	1	40	0.280442
Gas supply organization	12	27	0.527473	44.133333	0.421171	5	8	1	40	0.280442
Utility tunnel management organization	12	27	0.527473	44.133333	0.421171	5	8	1	40	0.280442
Designer of sewage waste facilities	18	22	0.432432	27.933333	0.458922	1	2	0	0	0.261174
Contractor of sewage waste facilities	22	38	0.505263	53.533333	0.718478	3	5	1	0	0.466305
Supervisor of sewage waste facilities	20	31	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	6	1	0	0.261174
Supplier of sewage waste facilities	20	30	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	5	0	0	0.818012
Designer of solid waste facilities	18	22	0.432432	27.933333	0.458922	1	2	0	0	0.261174
Contractor of solid waste facilities	22	38	0.505263	53.533333	0.718478	3	5	1	0	0.466305
Supervisor of solid waste facilities	20	31	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	6	1	0	0.261174
Supplier of solid waste facilities	20	30	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	5	0	0	0.818012
Designer of water supply facilities	18	22	0.432432	27.933333	0.458922	1	2	0	0	0.261174
Contractor of water supply facilities	22	38	0.505263	53.533333	0.718478	2	3	1	0	0.261174
Supervisor of water supply facilities	20	31	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	6	1	0	0.261174
Supplier of water supply facilities	20	30	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	5	0	0	0.671436
Designer of heating systems	18	22	0.432432	27.933333	0.458922	1	2	0	0	0.261174
Contractor of heating systems	22	38	0.505263	53.533333	0.718478	4	7	1	0	0.671436
Supervisor of heating systems	20	31	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	6	1	0	0.261174
Supplier of heating systems	20	30	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	5	0	0	0.964588
Designer of gas supply facilities	18	22	0.432432	27.933333	0.458922	1	2	0	0	0.261174
Contractor of gas supply facilities	22	38	0.505263	53.533333	0.718478	3	5	1	0	0.466305
Supervisor of gas supply facilities	20	31	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	6	1	0	0.261174
Supplier of gas supply facilities	20	30	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	5	0	0	0.818012
Designer of utility tunnel	18	22	0.432432	27.933333	0.458922	1	2	0	0	0.261174
Contractor of utility tunnel	22	38	0.505263	53.533333	0.718478	3	5	1	0	0.466305
Supervisor of utility tunnel	20	31	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	6	1	0	0.261174
Supplier of utility tunnel	20	30	0.466019	30.133333	0.612794	3	5	0	0	0.818012
Government	8	9	0.303797	9	0.044883	3	3	0.235294	0	0
Designer of industrial park road	20	25	0.484848	62.5	0.60856	1	2	0	0	0.280442
Contractor of industrial park road	24	39	0.564706	74.433333	0.894066	3	5	1	0	0.541617
Supervisor of industrial park road	22	35	0.521739	63	0.776457	3	6	1	0	0.280442
Supplier of industrial park road	22	29	0.521739	63	0.776457	3	5	0	0	1