Research Article

Computational Model of Outer Circle and Inner Ellipse Shield Tunnel Lining Structure

Table 8

Comparative analysis of the results of ABAQUS and the theoretical analysis of the paper.

45°90°135°180°
Theoretical valueABAQUS valueTheoretical valueABAQUS valueTheoretical valueABAQUS valueTheoretical valueABAQUS valueTheoretical valueABAQUS value

Bending moment (kN·m)195.878195.544−44.243−45.446−263.69−262.953−33.608−36.882185.274185.168
Axial force (kN)341.653336.712515.913518.135683.161686.228540.915540.202402.558400.921
Shear force (kN)0.0005.160−162.51−156.6006.5911.626154.037153.5620.0000.392