Advances in Civil Engineering

Review Article

A Review of Smart Contracts Applications in Various Industries: A Procurement Perspective

Table 2

Research papers included in the systematic review and their characteristics.
No.Author (year)Source typeApplication domainsBlockchain platformLevel of application
1Bogner et al. (2016) [27]ConferenceSharing economyEthereumSystem architecture
2Christidis and Devetsikiotis. (2016) [28]JournalIoTN/ATheoretical description
3Nugent et al. (2016) [29]JournalHealthcareEthereumPrototype
4Yasin and Liu (2016) [30]ConferenceOnline identityN/ASystem architecture
5McCorry et al. (2017) [31]ConferenceVotingEthereumImplementation
6Thomas et al. (2017) [32]ConferenceEnergyEthereumPrototype
7Hans et al. (2017) [33]ConferenceFinanceEthereumTheoretical description
8Kounelis et al. (2017) [34]ConferenceEnergyEthereumPrototype
9Gazali et al. (2017) [35]ConferenceEducationEthereumPrototype
10Hahn et al. (2017) [36]ConferenceEnergyEthereumPrototype
11Álvarez-Díaz et al. (2017) [37]ConferenceLogistics managementEthereumProposed method
12Saravanan et al. (2017) [38]ConferenceICTEthereumProposed method
13Sreehari et al. (2017) [39]ConferencePublic managementEthereumProposed method
14Shermin (2017) [40]JournalGovernanceBitcoin, EthereumTheoretical description
15Mason (2017) [41]JournalConstructionN/ATheoretical description
16Kirkman (2018) [42]ConferenceCloudEthereumProposed framework
17Wang et al. (2018) [43]ConferencePrediction marketEthereumImplementation
18Hou et al. (2017) [44]ConferenceElectric vehiclesNAProposed method
19Yeh et al. (2018) [45]JournalMobile paymentEthereumProposed method
20Desai et al. (2018) [46]ConferenceData sharingEthereumProposed framework
21Mahmoud et al. (2018) [47]ConferenceFinanceEthereumPrototype
22Rozario and Vasarhelyi. (2018) [48]JournalFinanceNATheoretical description
23Chen et al. (2018) [49]ConferenceE-commerceEthereumSystem architecture
24Zhao and O’Mahony (2018) [50]ConferenceEntertainmentEthereumPrototype
25Zhong et al. (2018) [51]ConferenceElectric vehicleEthereumProposed method
26Gupta and Bedi (2018) [52]ConferencePublic managementEthereumPrototype
27Griggs et al. (2018) [53]JournalHealthcareEthereumPrototype
28Zhou et al. (2018) [54]ConferenceIoTEthereumSystem architecture
29Arumugam et al. (2018) [55]ConferenceSupply chainEthereumPrototype
30Stefanović et al. (2018) [56]ConferencePublic managementEthereum, HyperledgerProposed method
31Islam and Kundu (2018) [57]ConferenceE-commerceN/AProposed method
32Hasan and Salah (2018) [58]JournalICTEthereumPrototype
33Cruz et al. (2018) [59]JournalICTEthereumPrototype
34Niya et al. (2018) [60]ConferenceE-commerceEthereumSystem architecture
35Fedosov et al. (2018) [61]ConferenceE-commerceEthereumSystem architecture
36Pãnescu and Manta (2018) [62]JournalResearch data rights managementEthereumPrototype
37Fotiou and Polyzos (2018) [63]ConferenceIoTN/AProposed method
38de Souza et al. (2018) [64]ConferencePublic managementN/ATheoretical description
39Norta et al. (2018) [65]ConferenceCommercial propertyEthereum, Hyperledger, QtumSystem architecture
40Gu et al. (2018) [66]ConferenceBusinessEthereumProposed framework
41Xu et al. (2018) [67]JournalIoTEthereumPrototype
42Cheng et al. (2018) [68]ConferenceEducationEthereumSystem architecture
43Gatteschi et al. (2018) [69]JournalInsuranceBitcoinTheoretical description
44Król et al. (2018) [70]ConferenceICTEthereumSystem architecture
45Kim et al. (2018) [71]ConferenceICTEthereumProposed framework
46Bedi et al. (2020) [72]ConferenceEducationEthereumImplementation
47Lamberti et al. (2018) [73]JournalInsuranceEthereumPrototype
48Omar and Basir (2018) [74]ConferenceIoTEthereumImplementation
49Nayak et al. (2018) [75]ConferenceCloudEthereumSystem architecture
50Novikov et al. (2018) [76]ConferenceHealthcareEthereumTheoretical description
51Uriarte et al. (2018) [77]ConferenceCloudEthereumPrototype
52Zhou et al. (2018) [78]ConferenceCloudEthereumPrototype
53Yu et al. (2018) [79]ConferenceEnergyEthereumProposed framework
54Papadodimas et al. (2018) [80]ConferenceIoTEthereumImplementation
55Jangir et al. (2019) [24]ConferenceSupply chainEthereumProposed framework
56Lyu et al. (2019) [81]ConferenceVotingEthereumSystem architecture
57Pham et al. (2018) [82]ConferenceHealthcareEthereumPrototype
58Augusto et al. (2019) [83]ConferenceSupply chainEthereumPrototype
59Aleksieva et al. (2019) [84]ConferenceFinanceEthereumPrototype
60Le et al. (2019) [85]JournalE-commerceEthereumProposed framework
61Li et al. (2019) [86]ConferencePublic managementEthereumProposed method
62Pittl et al. (2019) [87]ConferenceBusinessEthereumImplementation
63Philipp et al. (2019) [88]JournalSupply chainNATheoretical description
64Palma et al. (2019) [89]JournalEducationEthereumPrototype
65Kiran et al. (2019) [90]ConferenceICTEthereumPrototype
66Manimaran and Dhanalakshmi (2019) [91]ConferenceE-commerceEthereumSystem architecture
67Pee et al. (2019) [92]ConferenceEnergyEthereumPrototype
68Wang et al. (2019) [93]JournalE-commerceN/AProposed framework
69Luo et al. (2019) [94]ConferenceConstructionHyperledgerProposed framework
70Wu et al. (2019) [95]JournalE-commerceEthereumImplementation
71Singla et al. (2019) [96]ConferenceEducationEthereumSystem architecture
72Nguyen et al. (2019) [97]ConferencePublic managementEthereumSystem architecture
73Liu et al. (2019) [98]JournalElectric vehicleEthereumProposed method
74Liu et al. (2019) [99]ConferencePublic managementEthereumSystem architecture
75Asfia et al. (2019) [100]ConferenceElectric vehicleEthereumProposed framework
76Pham et al. (2019) [101]ConferenceIoTEthereumPrototype
77Neiheiser et al. (2019) [102]ConferencePublic managementEthereumPrototype
78dos Santos et al. (2019) [103]JournalFood manufacturingEthereumPrototype
79Malan and Steyn (2019) [104]JournalFinanceN/ATheoretical description
80Baharmand and Comes (2019) [105]JournalSupply chainN/ATheoretical description
81Wang et al. (2019) [7]JournalFinanceHyperledger fabricSystem architecture
82Nguyen et al. (2019) [106]ConferenceFinanceNEOProposed framework
83Yang et al. (2019) [107]ConferenceFinanceEthereumSystem architecture
84Duan et al. (2019) [108]JournalElectric vehiclesN/AProposed method
85Giordanengo (2019) [109]JournalHealthcareN/ATheoretical description
86Zaghloul et al. (2019) [110]ConferenceHealthcareEthereumProposed method
87Voutos et al. (2019) [111]ConferenceAgricultureEthereumTheoretical description
88Zhang et al. (2019) [112]JournalRide-hailing serviceEthereumPrototype
89Hasan et al. (2019) [6]JournalSupply chainEthereumPrototype
90Bader et al. (2018) [113]ConferenceFinanceEthereumPrototype
91Qu et al. (2019) [114]ConferenceSupply chainEthereumPrototype
92Hanada et al. (2018) [115]ConferenceIoTEthereumPrototype
93Prause and Boevsky (2019) [116]JournalSupply chainN/ATheoretical description
94Prause (2019) [117]JournalSupply chainN/ATheoretical description
95Asgaonkar and Krishnamachari. (2019) [118]ConferenceE-commerceN/ATheoretical description
96Chang et al. (2019) [119]JournalSupply chainN/AProposed framework
97Koirala et al. (2019) [120]ConferenceSupply chainEthereumPrototype
98Terzi et al. (2019) [121]ConferenceSupply chainN/AImplementation
99Mohanta et al. (2019) [122]JournalIoTEthereumProposed framework
100Zhao et al. (2019) [123]JournalEntertainmentN/ASystem architecture
101Lin et al. (2019) [124]ConferencePublic managementEthereumImplementation
102Gong et al. (2019) [125]ConferenceHealthcareEthereumPrototype
103Vidhyalakshmi et al. (2019) [126]JournalReal estateEthereumPrototype
104Hasan and Salah (2019) [127]JournalICTEthereumPrototype
105Wang et al. (2019) [128]JournalSupply chainEthereumImplementation
106Chang et al. (2019) [21]JournalInternational tradeEthereumImplementation
107Jaiswal et al. (2019) [129]ConferenceAgricultureEthereumProposed framework
108You et al. (2019) [130]ConferenceEnergyEthereumProposed framework
109Yang et al. (2019) [131]ConferenceHealthcareEthereumSystem architecture
110Batista and Weingaertner (2019) [132]ConferenceICTN/AProposed method
110Sheth and Subramanian (2019) [133]JournalInsuranceEthereumTheoretical description
112Putra et al. (2019) [134]ConferenceIoTEthereumImplementation
113Kumar and Raja Kumar (2019) [135]JournalE-auctionEthereumPrototype
114Zhao and Wu (2019) [136]ConferenceElectric vehiclesN/ASystem architecture
115Jintapitak et al. (2019) [137]ConferenceInsect industryN/AProposed framework
116Wang et al. (2019) [138]JournalEnergyEthereumImplementation
117Poptawski and Szczypiorski (2019) [139]ConferenceEnergyN/AProposed method
118Bracciali et al. (2019) [140]ConferencePublic managementEthereumPrototype
119Mihelj et al. (2019) [141]JournalPublic managementEthereumPrototype
120Ekici et al. (2019) [142]ConferenceICTHyperledger fabricImplementation
121Vinayak et al. (2019) [143]ConferenceFinancialHyperledger fabricImplementation
122Li and Liu (2019) [144]ConferenceBusinessEthereumSystem architecture
123Li et al. (2019) [145]JournalEnergyEthereumImplementation
124Poorni et al. (2019) [146]ConferenceEducationEthereum, Hyperledger fabricSystem architecture
125Qian et al. (2019) [147]ConferenceDigital resource copyrightsHyperledger fabricSystem architecture
126De Giovanni (2019) [148]JournalSupply chainN/AProposed method
127Chen et al. (2019) [149]JournalPublic managementN/ASystem architecture
128Bagozi et al. (2019) [150]ConferenceICTEthereum, Hyperledger fabricProposed method
129Moudoud et al. (2019) [151]ConferenceIoTEthereumSystem architecture
130Kovalenko et al. (2019) [152]ConferenceFinancialEthereumSystem architecture
131Dai et al. (2019) [153]JournalPublic managementEthereumProposed framework
132Lin et al. (2019) [154]ConferenceBusinessEOSIOSystem architecture
133Nugraha et al. (2019) [155]ConferencePublic managementHyperledger fabricSystem architecture
134Montes et al. (2019) [156]ConferenceSupply chainHyperledger fabricProposed framework
135Omar et al. (2019) [157]ConferenceHealthcareEthereumProposed method
136Avizheh et al. (2019) [158]ConferenceICTEthereumImplementation
137Le and Mutka (2019) [159]ConferenceIoTEthereumPrototype
138Khatoon (2020) [8]JournalHealthcareEthereumImplementation
139Kumar et al. (2020) [160]ConferenceLand transactionEthereumSystem architecture
140Wang et al. (2020) [161]JournalICTN/ASystem architecture
141Dorsala et al. (2020) [162]JournalICTEthereumImplementation
142Yu et al. (2020) [163]JournalFood manufacturingEthereumPrototype
143Neiheiser et al. (2020) [164]JournalPublic managementEthereumPrototype
144Chong and Diamantopoulos (2020) [23]JournalConstructionHyperledgerSystem architecture
145Chen et al. (2020) [165]JournalICTN/AProposed method
146Wang et al. (2020) [166]JournalElectric vehiclesMultiple platformsImplementation
147Patel and Das (2020) [167]ConferenceEducationHyperledgerPrototype
148Nakamura et al. (2020) [168]JournalIoTEthereumPrototype
149Shahab and Allam (2019) [169]JournalPublic managementN/ATheoretical description
150Sultana et al. (2020) [170]JournalIoTEthereum, SpyderPrototype
151Debe et al. (2020) [171]JournalICTEthereumImplementation
152Elghaish et al. (2020) [11]JournalConstructionHyperledgerImplementation
153Han et al. (2020) [172]JournalEnergyEthereumSystem architecture
154Xuan et al. (2020) [173]JournalData sharingN/AProposed method
155Fu et al. (2020) [174]JournalElectric vehicleEthereumImplementation
156Matai et al. (2020) [175]JournalReal estateEthereumPrototype
157Vyas et al. (2020) [176]ConferenceHealthcareEthereumImplementation
158Jamil et al. (2020) [177]JournalHealthcareHyperledger fabricImplementation
159Prashar et al. (2020) [178]JournalSupply chainEthereumPrototype
160Reniers et al. (2020) [179]ConferenceData sharingEthereumImplementation
161Kurnia et al. (2020) [180]ConferenceSupply chainN/ASystem architecture
162Habib et al. (2020) [181]ConferenceSupply chainN/AProposed framework
163Neysen (2020) [182]JournalRecording industryN/ATheoretical description
164Zghaibeh et al. (2020) [183]JournalHealthcareHyperledger fabricSystem architecture
165Luchoomun et al. (2020) [184]JournalAutomotive industryHyperledger fabricImplementation
166Chiacchio et al. (2020) [185]JournalPharma industryEthereumPrototype
167Makmur et al. (2020) [186]JournalEnergyEthereum, bitcoinSystem architecture
168Gong et al. (2020) [187]ConferenceIoTEthereumImplementation
169Pertiwi et al. (2020) [188]JournalEntertainmentEthereumTheoretical description
170Adrian et al. (2020) [189]JournalE-logisticsN/AProposed framework
171Gürsoy et al. (2020) [190]JournalHealthcareEthereumPrototype
172Shurman et al. (2020) [191]ConferenceIoTEthereumProposed framework
173Gupta et al. (2020) [192]ConferenceFinancialN/ATheoretical description
174Panja et al. (2020) [193]JournalE-votingEthereumImplementation