Research Article

Building Information Modeling Application Maturity Model (BIM-AMM) from the Viewpoint of Construction Project

Table 2

Evaluation criteria of BIM-AMM.

Technology
StageTE-1TE-2TE-3

1Just a few BIM tools have been used and cannot satisfy participants’ slightly difficult needs.Hardware is outdated and there is no restoration system.Limited network.
2Many strong BIM tools for different disciplines have been applied, but interoperation is poor.Hardware can meet the generic needs of BIM tools, and there is no restoration system.The network can meet the basic needs of BIM tools but cannot transfer huge data.
3Integrated BIM tools can satisfy most of participants’ needs and support most collaboration of different disciplines.Hardware can meet most needs of BIM tools and there is a better restoration system.Network is stable and has enough capacity for collaboration and communication, but the connect style provided is limited.
4BIM tools can satisfy any participant’s need and support full collaboration between different disciplines.Hardware can perfectly meet all the needs of BIM tools, has quick running speed, huge storage, and an excellent restoration system.Network can meet all the needs of BIM tools for collaboration and real-time communication, and diversification of connection style is provided.

Society
StageSO-1SO-2SO-3
1Hardly any BIM-related laws and codes have been promulgated.Almost no standards can be used in practice.There are hardly any policies to encourage the application of BIM.
2Just some key BIM-related laws and codes have been promulgated.Although there are some standards for BIM application, most have shortcomings.Some positive policies have been issued to encourage participants to use BIM.
3A sizeable amount of BIM-related laws and codes have been issued.Most important standards have been created and are used in practice.Much more benefits stipulated by policies could be gained if the project applies BIM.
4All the laws and codes for BIM application are perfect.All kinds of standards for BIM application have been established perfectly.It is required that all construction projects must apply BIM in policies.

Participant
StagePA-1PA-2PA-3PA-4
1There is almost no one who can use BIM tools.Project manager has no experience in the application of BIM to the construction project.Owner does not require the application of BIM and has made no investments.Bad delivery method for BIM application.
2A few persons have used BIM tools in practice.Project manager has experience in BIM use, but not in the role of project manager.Owner has some interest or provides some investments in BIM usage.Good delivery method for BIM application.
3Many persons have used BIM tools.Project manager has experience of using BIM in one or two construction projects.Owner encourages participants to apply BIM and provides great investment.Great delivery method for BIM application.
4All the participants can use and collaborate with BIM tools perfectly.Project manager has abundant experience in using BIM in construction project management.Owner requires participants to use BIM and supports all funding.Perfect delivery method for BIM application.

TE-1 denotes software; TE-2 denotes hardware; TE-3 denotes network; SO-1 denotes laws and codes; SO-2 denotes standards; SO-3 denotes policy; PA-1 denotes a person with ability; PA-2 denotes project manager’s experience; PA-3 denotes owner’s requirement and investments; PA-4 denotes project delivery method.