Advances in Civil Engineering

Review Article

A Review of Employer-Caused Delay Factors in Traditional and Building Information Modeling (BIM)-Enabled Projects: Research Framework

Table 6

Mapping of delay factors for different types of projects in traditional projects.
AuthorsProject type
Residential buildingsCommercial buildingsIndustrial buildingsPrivatePublicAirportsOil and gasOther infrastructureModular structuresPower projectsWater/sewer/irrigationGeneral
Al-Hazim and Abu Salem [71]    √  √    
Emam et al. [72]       √    
Samarah and Bekr [14]    √       
Motaleb and kishk [73]           √
Muhwezi et al. [74] √  √       
Shah [75]           √
Khan [76]      √     
Rahimipour and Shahhosseini [77]            
Upadhyay et al. [78]           √
Tawil et al. [79]           √
Oshodi Olalekan and Rimaka [80]           √
Amoatey et al. [81]√   √       
Rauzana [82]           √
Shehu et al. [83]           √
Pai and Bharath [84]       √    
Gajare and Attarde [85]           √
Kamanga and Steyn [86]    √  √    
Bekr [87]    √       
Al-Emad and Nagapan [88]           √
Suksai et al. [89]√√          
Islam and Trigunarsyah [90]           √
Van et al. [91]    √      √
Zou et al. [92]           √
Addo [93]           √
Dontul et al. [94]    √       
Senouci et al. [95]    √       
Samarghandi et al. [96]           √
Assbeihat [97]   √        
Megha and Rajiv [98]√           
Alamri et al. [99]       √    
Khattri et al. [100]           √
Alhajri and Alshibani [101]      √     
Kim et al. [102] √          
Sohu et al. [103]       √    
Al Hadithi [104]       √    
Tumi et al. [11]           √
Akogbe et al. [105]           √
Alinaitwe et al. [106]    √       
Famiyeh et al. [107]Educational buildings           
Damoah and kumi [108]    √       
Olawale and Sun [109]           √
Zidane and Andersen [110]           √
Gunduz et al. [111]           √
Zidane and Andersen [112]           √
Maués et al. [113]√           
Ballesteros-Pérez et al. [114]           √
Tafazzoli and Shrestha [115]           √
Wang et al. [116]√√√         
Abbasi et al. [117]           √
Arantes and Ferreira [118]           √
Muneeswaran et al. [119]           √
Bajjou and Chafi [120]           √
Bagaya and Song [121]    √       
Prasad et al. [122]√√√      √√ 
Alaghbari et al. [70]           √
Oshungade and kruger [123]           √
Ansah [124]           √
Pall et al. [125]         √  
Ravisankar and Anandakumar [126]           √
Hiyassat et al. [127]    √