Safety Assessment of Ship Collision with Piers under the Protection of Anti-Collision Floating Box Based on BIM Technology

Table 6

Comparison table for calculating example.

Conditions	Literature [22]		This study		Deviation between the literature and this study
	Maximum impact force (MN)	Time of occurrence (s)	Maximum impact force (MN)	Time of occurrence (s)	Deviation of maximum impact force (%)	Deviation of time (%)
1	4.072	0.901	4.252	0.931	4.42	3.33
2	7.234	0.899	7.462	0.909	3.15	1.11
3	9.888	0.868	10.289	0.866	4.06	−0.23
4	7.453	0.875	7.667	0.899	2.87	2.74
5	13.112	0.648	13.667	0.652	4.23	0.62
6	15.813	0.589	16.559	0.561	4.72	−4.75