Abstract

The demand for cement, which is one of the key components of concrete, is high in Ethiopia, but it is the most expensive and environmentally unfriendly construction material. Due to the increasing concerns about the environment worldwide, researchers have started looking for other resources that can be used to reduce the pollution caused by the cement industry. One of the most effective ways to reduce the pollution caused by the cement industry is by using volcanic scoria powder as a partial replacement for cement in concrete production. Scoria is a locally available natural volcanic material in Ethiopia, especially around the rift valley regions. This natural resource can also be used to reduce energy consumption and the cost of production of cement. To investigate this study, nonprobability sampling techniques were adopted to collect samples from the study area. A differing proportion of scoria powder was considered as a partial replacement of cement after analyzing its characteristics, and its effect on the fresh and mechanical properties of hardened concrete was examined. The test results on the characteristics of scoria revealed that the material is suitable to be used as a supplementary cementitious material in concrete production; hence, its main constituents SiO2 + Al2O3 + Fe2O3 are higher than 70% as per ASTM C618. As the content of scoria powder replacement in cement is increased, it reduces the slump of freshly mixed concrete properties. The hardened concrete specimens made with 10%, 20%, and 30% partial replacement of cement with scoria achieved the specified minimum strength after 28 days of curing time. But concrete specimens made with 40% scoria content do not satisfy the minimum specified concrete strength even after 90 days. The significant strength achievement in scoria blended concrete specimens occurred when moving from 56 to 90 days of curing with 10% replacements. However, in reference specimens, this was observed during 28 days of curing times. The findings of this investigation revealed that scoria powder could replace cement by 30% for the production of normal concrete and it also has the potential to protect the environment from carbon dioxide emissions. These findings satisfy the basic strategy of green concrete production in worldwide.

1. Introduction

The ever-increasing populations, living standards, and economic development in developing countries like Ethiopia lead to an increasing demand for constructing infrastructure by using concrete materials. The demand for cement, which is one of the key components for concrete production, is high in such countries; cement is the most expensive and environmentally unfriendly material used in construction industry to build complex apartments, bridges, and concrete pavements [1]. Therefore, requirements for economical and more environmental-friendly cementing materials have extended interest in other cementing materials that can be used as alternatives to Portland cement which is available around constructing infrastructure. Historically, numerous kinds of volcanic scoria have been effectively utilized in dams and aqueducts, where the strength demand is not high but the durability and thermal cracking control are of major concern [2, 3].

The study by [4] reported that the compressive strength of concrete incorporating powdered scoria is affected by both the scoria rocks source and its replacement level. Because of the different volcanic lava fields, powdered scoria rock samples exhibit clear variations in morphology and mineralogical compositions. According to [5], the final setting time of the blended cement containing 15%, 25%, or 35% natural pozzolans (volcanic scoria) increased substantially when compared with the reference Portland cement. The binders of 30% micro-volcanic scoria showed higher durability, particularly after 28 days of curing, when compared with the ones of zero volcanic scoria content. As per this study, the optimum content of micro-volcanic scoria is recommended not to be more than 30% [6]. According to Celik et al. [7], the use of 30% natural pozzolans, 15% limestone, and 55% OPC mix produces a low-cost and ecofriendly concrete that does not bear calcining of natural pozzolans or limestone with OPC and would reduce CO2 emissions 48% compared with the 100% OPC control mix while providing higher ultimate strength and resistance to chloride penetration. Scoria can be used up to 12% as a partial substitute for Portland cement in the production of blended cement; this additional ratio could provide economic and environmental benefits due to reduced clinker consumption and lowered CO2 emissions from cement production [8]. In all, the incorporation of natural pozzolanic material in concrete has insignificant effects on the properties of fresh concrete, namely initial slump, setting times, and slump loss [9].

One of the strategies in green concrete production is the utilization of locally available and environmentally friendly materials [2, 10]. Ground granulated blast furnace slag, fly ash, silica fume, pumice, scoria, and other materials containing pozzolanic characteristics have been effectively utilized to reduce the negative environmental consequences of the cement industry [3, 1113]. Currently, the critical view of global warming efforts is to reduce the emission of CO2 to the environment. Cement industry was the major contributor to the emission of carbon dioxides to the environment as well as using up high levels of energy resources in the production of the cement industry. Therefore, by replacing cement with a material of pozzolanic characteristics, such as coal ash (fly ash), volcanic scoria, eggshell, marble dust, coconut shell, saw dust ash, rice husk ash, and sugar cane bagasse ash, the cement and the concrete industry together can meet the growing demand in the construction industry as well as help in reducing the environmental pollution investigated by researchers [1417]. There was a huge availability of volcanic scoria in lots of countries, but its low value and the pressure towards greater sustainable construction have ended in renewed interest in volcanic scoria as natural pozzolan for concrete. The use of locally available cementing alternatives to produce green concrete has the advantage of the cost of concrete production in construction [1723]. Natural volcanic scoria materials have been investigated in some parts of the world for their potential use as binding alternatives, fine aggregates, and coarse aggregates, and had been found to enhance some of the engineering properties of paste, mortar, and concrete. As reported by many authors, supplementary cementing material such as volcanic scoria has a beneficial influence on the compressive strength of concrete [24, 25]. In the case of environmental pollution, the incremental cost of cement, high amount of energy, and raw materials consumption, some researchers tried to find alternative resources which are available in the local environment to reduce the problem. The use of binders containing volcanic scoria and other pozzolans as cement substitutes can lead to the effective use of natural resources, saving energy consumption, and reduction in CO2 emissions [8, 26, 27]. So, to reduce environmental pollution, high amount of energy consumption, raw material consumption during the production of cement, and to reduce the incremental cost of cement, natural volcanic scoria would be a good alternative material as a partial replacement for cement [17].

The utilization of volcanic scoria and other alternative cementitious materials is gaining huge interest from various researchers, due to the promising results. The significance of this study is to encourage countries like Ethiopia having sample sources of volcanic scoria to investigate their implicit use as cement replacement and therefore make ecofriendly concrete. Still, studies on the potential utilization of volcanic scoria as a cementitious material for green concrete production have not been exorbitantly reported. Moreover, specialized information on the Ethiopian volcanic scoria as a cement replacement is scarce, and this paper might be particularly interesting for the regions where volcanic scoria is abundant. Thus, this study focuses on evaluating the fresh and mechanical properties of concrete made with volcanic scoria powder as a partial replacement for cement.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Materials

The raw materials that were utilized in this study include cement, river sand, coarse aggregate (crushed stone), volcanic scoria, and potable water. The cement utilized is ordinary Portland cement (OPC42.5R) fulfilling the requirements of ASTM C 150 [28] standard specifications. The crushed stone with a nominal maximum size of 20 mm was used in the study. The experimental test shows that the coarse aggregate has a water absorption capacity of 0.54% and a specific gravity of 2.73. Table1 shows the summarized physical properties of coarse aggregate used in this study. The particle size distribution curve for coarse aggregate and the limits as per ASTM C33 [29] is shown in Figure 1. The fine aggregate used was natural river sand which was obtained from the Gambella region (Dima source), Ethiopia. The sand used had a specific gravity of 2.62, a fineness modulus of 2.50, and a water absorption rate of 1.03%. The particle size distribution curve for the sand and the limits set in ASTM C 33 are also shown in Figure 1. The chemical, physical, and mechanical properties of the cement used are given in Table 2. The potable tape water was used for the preparation of all concrete specimens. Scoria used in this investigation was obtained from the quarry site around Adama town, which is located in the eastern part of Ethiopia at a distance of approximately 100 km from the Capital Addis Ababa. The grain size distribution of scoria obtained consists of various sizes mostly ranging from 0.15 mm to 38 mm.

2.1.1. Preparation of Scoria Powder

Hence, as shown in Figure 2(a), the aim of this study is to use scoria as a supplementary cementitious material; it was ground by an abrasion machine to have approximately 90% of particles passing through a 75-µm sieve, as shown in Figure 2(b). In order to make sure that a fineness level comparable to Portland cement is obtained, a trial procedure was conducted to reach a satisfactory level of fineness. After each trial, with a specified revolution, the specific surface area of the sample was determined using the air permeability method, specifically by using the Blain test apparatus.

2.2. Mixture Proportioning

In this study, the ACI 211.1 method of concrete mix design was used as a design guideline to prepare concrete mixtures [30]. A reference mixture was designed to achieve a minimum compressive strength of 25 MPa at 28 days. Scoria-based concrete mixtures were prepared with scoria contents of 10, 20, 30, and 40% by weight of cement. The water-to-cement ratio for all mixtures was kept constant (w/cm = 0.52) to see the effect of using scoria as a supplementary cementitious material on the properties of concrete. The proportions of concrete constituents used per cubic meter are presented in Table 3.

2.3. Sample Preparation

Concrete mixing procedures were prepared following the ASTM C 192 specification steps [31]. Five groups of concrete mixtures were prepared based on the partial replacement of scoria powder for cement. The specimens prepared include a total of 60 cubes of 150 mm dimensions. Twelve specimens were cast for each mix, and the mean compressive strength of three specimens was reported for each test age. Batching of cement, aggregates, and water became accomplished through the weighing method. A pan-kind mixer with the most output potential of 125 L was used to supply the concrete mixtures. The concrete mixtures were cast in cubic molds in three layers, and each layer was consolidated manually 25 times by means of a tamping rod of 16 mm in diameter and 600 mm long. The concrete specimens were removed from their moulds 24 hours after casting, and they were immersed in water until the moment of testing [31].

2.4. Test Methods
2.4.1. XRD and SEM Analysis

The chemical analysis of the volcanic scoria used in this investigation was studied in the Geological Survey of Ethiopia and is summarized in Table 4 based on the analytical method. The mineralogy and microstructure of scoria were analyzed using X-ray diffraction (XRD) equipment with Cu-radiation of (wavelength = 1.54 Å) at 40 K.V., 35 m.A., and a scanning speed of 0.02°/sec. The reflection peaks between 2θ = 2° and 60°, and corresponding spacing (dÅ) and relative intensities (peak areas) were obtained. In XRD analysis, around the sample scoria powder, the detector position is recorded as the angle 2theta (2θ)-. The detector records the number of X-rays observed at each angle 2θ. The X-ray intensity is usually recorded as “counts” or as “counts per second.” Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of scoria were analyzed at two magnification levels: at low magnification (Figure3(a)) and at high magnification (Figure 3(b)).

2.4.2. Workability

The slump cone test method was adopted for the determination of the workability of fresh concrete as per ASTM C143 [32]. As specified in ASTM C 143, the cone was filled in three layers of approximately equal volume, and each layer was consolidated by rodding 25 times with a smooth, straight steel tamping rod of diameter 16 mm. After the top layer has been rodded, the surface of the concrete was struck off by means of screeding and rolling motion of the tamping rod. The cone was immediately removed from the concrete by raising it carefully in a vertical direction. Then, the slump was measured by determining the vertical difference between the top of the cone and the displaced original center of the top surface of the specimen [32]. The slump values for each scoria replacement are indicated in Table 5.

2.4.3. Density (Unit Weight)

The unit weight of fresh concrete with various scoria replacement levels was determined according to ASTM C138 [33]. For the determination of the fresh density of concrete, the mass and volume of the measure have first been measured. Then, the mass of the measure with the specimen is measured. The net mass of the concrete was calculated by subtracting the mass of the measure from the mass of the measure filled with concrete. The density of concrete is calculated by dividing the net mass of concrete by the volume of the measure [33]. The results of the density of fresh concrete for each scoria replacement rate are presented in Table 5.

2.4.4. Compressive Strength

The compressive strength of specimens was carried out in accordance with ASTM C39. The compression machine used in this study was an automatic compression testing machine which has a loading capacity of 2000 kN. Loading of specimens was applied at a constant loading rate between 0.2 and 0.4 MPa/sec until the failure. The specimens were tested after the ages of 7, 28, 56, and 90 days.

2.5. Mix Designations

The following are the details of descriptions and designations of the concrete mixtures studied as shown in Table 6.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Chemical Composition of Scoria

The chemical composition carried out on scoria is shown in Table 4 and Figure 4. The results of the chemical analysis indicate that SiO2, Al2O3, CaO, and Fe2O3 constitute their major components. As it can be seen from Table 4, the major constituents of scoria are SiO2 + Al2O3 + Fe2O3 = 79.75% > 70%. Scoria can be considered as a suitable pozzolanic material for use as supplementary cementitious materials in green concrete production. Hence, it fulfilled the specification requirements for natural pozzolanic materials. According to ASTM C 618 specifications, the scoria powder is fulfilling the requirements of pozzolanic materials. In addition, the physical and mechanical properties of scoria are also fulfilling the requirements of ASTM C618 [34].

The XRD pattern of scoria is given in Figure 4. As expected, scoria is an amorphous rock. As indicated in XRD data (Figure 4), scoria consists mainly of volcanic materials of amorphous structure, with the basic composition of relatively high quartz (SiO2) and low Fe2O3 contents. The main oxide content of Portland cement is CaO (63.08%); however, scoria also has CaO (11.25%).

3.2. SEM Images of Scoria

The result obtained from SEM views of the used raw material in this investigation is shown in Figure 3. The scoria particles, as when observed with an SEM image, look like a square and diamond in nature and it is also similar to the particles of ordinary Portland cement (OPC). The OPC appears to have a box and stone-shaped particles as observed by the SEM instrument [20]. The scoria particles shown by SEM are close to spherical particles with a minor number of pedospheres and an irregular morphology or shaped porous a cellular-structure (amorphous structure). After grinding scoria, the porous structures were crushed and broken down into smaller fractions leading to an increase in surface area and it improved the fineness of the particles.

3.3. Setting Times of the Blended Paste

The setting time test was conducted on blended pastes containing scoria replacements of 0%, 10%, 20%, 30%, and 40% by weight of cement. The setting times of blended paste containing different replacements of scoria powder are shown in Table 7 and Figure 5. It can be seen from the table that the setting time of the blended paste increases as the percentage of scoria powder increases due to the slow hydration reaction of the scoria-based binder system. The results of this study indicated that the setting time of blended paste was delayed due to the partial replacement of cement with scoria; however, this retardation was within the limits specified by the Ethiopian standard, ASTM standard, and other related standards.

3.4. Density of Fresh Concrete

As it can be seen in Table 5, the unit weight of fresh concrete shows a slight reduction as the percentage of scoria increases. The unit weight of fresh concrete up to 3.6% reduction was observed when 30% of cement was replaced by scoria powder. Furthermore, 40% replacement of cement by scoria reduces the unit weight of fresh concrete by 4.3%. The slight reduction in the unit weight of fresh concrete is due to the lightweight nature of the scoria material.

3.5. Effect of Scoria Content on Workability

The trend of a slump for mixtures having different contents of scoria is presented in Table 5 and Figure 6. As the content of scoria powder increased, the slump values decreased with the w/c ratio kept constant. As indicated in Figure 7, the control mix shows a higher slump when compared with all other scoria-replaced mixes. When the content of scoria powder increases from 0 to 30%, the slump was decreased by 47% (14 mm). At a 30% replacement rate of scoria, there is a significant reduction of a slump by 59% (20 mm) due to the significant increment of water demand at this replacement level. Although the workability of concrete is decreased as the content of scoria is increased, up to the replacement level of 20%, the slump value is within the specified limit, which is 25––75 mm. In general, an increase in the content of scoria powder reduces the slump of freshly mixed concrete. A similar result was also observed by Chambua et al. [35], Mboya et al. [14], and [36]. The reason for this is that there is a high-water demand due to an increase in the contents of scoria powder. The reason behind this may also be the high concentration of SiO2 (in Scoria SiO2 = 53.84% and in cement SiO2 = 20.65%) in scoria powder increases the water requirement of the mixture. This argument is also revealed by some studies [3, 35, 37].

3.6. Compressive Strength of Concrete

Table 8 shows the compressive strength results after 7-, 28-, 56-, and 90-day curing time. The results of compressive strength development for all concrete mixes containing different amounts of scoria powder are given in Figure 8. As expected, all concrete mixes show an increase in compressive strength with curing time. Concrete specimens containing scoria powder have lower compressive strengths at any curing time compared to reference concrete specimens. However, the compressive strength results of 10% scoria blended concrete exceeded that of control specimens after 56- and 90-day curing. A similar trend was obtained in [35, 38, 39] where strength improved by using 10% of SCMs in concrete. This could be due to the progress of slow pozzolanic reaction with age in scoria-replaced concrete specimens [15]. Also, it is seen that the compressive strength of scoria powder replaced concrete specimens decreases as the scoria powder content increases for all replacements except 10%.

Concrete specimens made with 10%, 20%, and 30% partial replacement of cement with scoria achieved the specified minimum strength (>25 MPa) after 28 days of curing time. But concrete specimens made with 40% scoria content do not satisfy the minimum specified concrete strength even after 90 days (24 MPa < 25 MPa). This ascertainment is due to a continuation of slow pozzolanic reaction and the formation of secondary C-S-H; a greater degree of hydration was achieved resulting in strength improvements after 56 and 90 days [15, 27, 40]. Therefore, volcanic scoria can substitute Portland cement up to replacement levels of 30% by weight basis with a slight effect on workability and compressive strength. The best replacement level for a higher amount of compressive strength is at 10% and other replacement levels such as 20% and 30% are also possible but such contents require more curing time to achieve the specified strength (56 and 90) days. The optimum replacement level of volcanic scoria in the past agrees with the findings of this study for concrete [7]. Moreover, to easily understand the difference, the result is shown graphically in Figure 8.

3.7. Stress-Strain Relationships

The average engineering stress and strains are calculated for all mixes and shown in Figures 7, 911. The stress-strain curve is drawn by selecting a better graph from each mix and sample for comparison with the control. It can be seen that the strain values gradually decreased as the percentage of scoria powder increased. In this study, the peak strain of scoria-replaced concrete was found to be lower than that of conventional concrete. Hence, the replacement rate of scoria powder showed an obvious impact on the stress-strain relations of concrete. From the figure of stress-strain results, scoria powder replaced concrete varied due to scoria powder content. From the curve, for all mixes, the compressive stress and the corresponding strain are directly proportional to some extent. This shows the elastic range of concrete. Once the ultimate load is reached, the load-carrying capacity (ductile properties of concrete) is changed for each mix based on the percentage variation of scoria powder. The peak stress and slope of the ascending part of the curve declined with the increase of the replacement rate of scoria powder, which conformed to findings from other researchers [4143]. Furthermore, as the replacement rate increased, peak stress increased, and both the ascending and descending part of the stress–-strain curves became steeper to some extent. Therefore, it could be concluded that volcanic scoria has a similar behavior to that of Portland cement concrete under compression stress.

4. Conclusions

Based on the current experimental investigation, the findings can be concluded as follows:(i)The results of the chemical analysis indicate that SiO2, Al2O3, CaO, and Fe2O3 constitute their major components. The studied scoria can be used as a partial replacement for cement. Hence, the main oxide contents (SiO 2+ Al2O3 + Fe2O3 = 79.75 > 70%) are within the range prescribed by ASTM C618.(ii)The utilization of scoria powder in concrete has a significant effect on the fresh concrete properties such as setting time, slump value, and unit weight. As the content of scoria is increased, the slump values were decreased with the w/c ratio kept constant. At a 30% replacement rate of scoria, there is a significant reduction of a slump by 59% (20 mm) due to the significant increment of water demand at this replacement level.(iii)Concrete specimens containing scoria powder have lower compressive strengths at any curing time compared to reference concrete specimens. However, the incorporation of 10% scoria significantly increased the compressive strength of concrete specimens after 56 and 90 days (i.e., 44.37 MPa and 49.00 MPa, respectively).(iv)Based on the investigation, scoria powder is suitable for use in concrete as supplementary cementitious material and the use of this type of material in concrete helps the strategy of green concrete production.(v)Therefore, based on this investigation scoria is suitable to use to produce concrete as a partial replacement for cement. Its local availability is crucial to be used as an alternative construction material that helps to save cost and energy during production, as well as protects against the emission of carbon dioxides to the environment. Thus, this satisfies the basic strategy of green concrete production in worldwide.

Data Availability

All the data used to support the findings of the study are included in the article.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to thank those who participated in laboratory work and supported during the experimental stage to complete this research study.