Nonlinear Effects of Governmental and Civil Environmental Regulation on Green Total Factor Productivity in China

Table 2

Green total factor productivity growth ratio in 2007–2016.

Zone	Province	07/08	08/09	09/10	10/11	11/12	12/13	13/14	14/15	15/16
East region	Beijing	0.9943	0.9998	1.0019	1.0014	1.0032	1.0017	1.0037	1.0004	1.0012
	Tianjin	1.0000	0.9958	0.9940	1.0103	0.9952	1.0004	1.0043	1.0000	1.0000
	Hebei	0.9968	0.9966	0.9998	0.9943	0.9954	1.0060	1.0112	1.0000	1.0000
	Liaoning	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000	0.9947	0.9956	0.9979	1.0118	1.0000	1.0000
	Shanghai	0.9968	1.0033	1.0000	1.0000	0.9973	1.0027	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000
	Jiangsu	1.0000	0.9987	0.9967	1.0000	0.9976	1.0026	1.0043	1.0000	1.0000
	Zhejiang	0.9981	1.0004	0.9995	1.0015	0.9987	1.0057	1.0049	1.0005	0.9996
	Fujian	0.9928	0.9964	1.0018	1.0011	1.0014	1.0021	0.9994	1.0015	1.0007
	Shandong	1.0000	1.0000	0.9949	0.9990	0.9959	1.0024	1.0078	1.0000	1.0000
	Guangdong	1.0000	0.9978	1.0022	1.0000	0.9970	1.0030	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000
	Hainan	0.9946	0.9984	0.9983	1.0088	0.9921	1.0080	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000
	Average	0.9976	0.9988	0.9990	1.0010	0.9972	1.0030	1.0043	1.0002	1.0001
Middle region	Shanxi	1.0000	0.9942	0.9983	0.9994	0.9925	1.0052	1.0105	1.0000	1.0000
	Jilin	0.9819	0.9958	0.9996	0.9996	0.9995	1.0066	1.0103	1.0010	1.0003
	Heilongjiang	0.9816	0.9889	0.9973	1.0014	0.9938	1.0021	1.0088	0.9984	0.9954
	Anhui	0.9856	0.9960	1.0002	1.0038	0.9978	1.0030	1.0146	1.0009	0.9997
	Jiangxi	1.0000	1.0000	0.9985	1.0015	0.9926	1.0013	1.0061	1.0000	1.0000
	Henan	1.0106	0.9938	0.9989	0.9972	0.9957	1.0009	1.0059	1.0003	1.0000
	Hubei	0.9897	0.9969	1.0015	1.0037	0.9992	1.0055	1.0063	0.9985	1.0005
	Hunan	0.9807	0.9980	1.0027	1.0012	0.9986	1.0026	1.0084	0.9989	0.9981
	Average	0.9913	0.9955	0.9996	1.0010	0.9962	1.0034	1.0089	0.9998	0.9993
West region	Inner Mongolia	1.0000	1.0000	0.9984	1.0016	0.9966	1.0035	1.0000	1.0000	0.9964
	Guangxi	1.0000	0.9960	1.0041	1.0000	0.9946	1.0054	0.9828	1.0040	0.9941
	Chongqing	0.9917	0.9957	0.9946	1.0020	0.9974	0.9994	0.9969	0.9997	1.0002
	Sichuan	0.9888	0.9936	0.9986	0.9987	0.9961	1.0045	0.9984	1.0011	1.0007
	Guizhou	1.0000	1.0000	0.9938	0.9936	1.0000	0.9997	0.9930	0.9972	0.9996
	Yunnan	0.9750	0.9992	1.0032	1.0035	0.9959	1.0019	1.0408	0.9865	0.9965
	Shanxi	1.0008	0.9995	0.9999	1.0039	0.9933	1.0034	1.0118	0.9991	1.0009
	Gansu	0.9692	0.9936	0.9967	1.0001	0.9970	1.0075	1.0150	0.9959	0.9962
	Qinghai	1.0000	0.9949	0.9988	1.0064	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000
	Ningxia	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000	0.9955	1.0045	1.0000	1.0000	1.0000
	Xinjiang	0.9913	0.9967	1.0031	1.0018	0.9972	1.0037	1.0072	0.9980	0.9984
	Average	0.9924	0.9972	0.9992	1.0011	0.9967	1.0030	1.0042	0.9983	0.9985