Research Article

Nonlinear Effects of Governmental and Civil Environmental Regulation on Green Total Factor Productivity in China

Table 4

Regression results of nonlinear effect model (threshold variable: FUB and REL).

ModelGER-M1GER-M2GER-M3PER-M4PER-M5PER-M6
VariableYear fixed effectSpace fixed effectSpace and year fixed effectYear fixed effectSpace fixed effectSpace and year fixed effect

L. LnMML0.0268(2.20)0.0375(1.77)0.1010(5.46)0.0475(2.24)0.0113 (0.55)0.0620(3.22)
LnGER−0.0226(−1.76)−0.0251 (−0.09)−0.0241(−3.82)−0.0150(−2.06)−0.0156(−2.31)−0.0152(−4.73)
LnPER0.0075 (1.56)−0.0046(−2.09)0.0006 (0.28)−0.1468(−1.69)−0.1539(−1.89)−0.1699(−1.86)
LnGER × LnFUB0.0054(3.66)0.0051(2.79)0.0052(2.33)
LnPER × LnREL0.0137(5.78)0.0136(7.70)0.0139(5.53)
LnQYJ−0.0019 (−1.06)0.0031 (0.02)−0.0023 (−1.17)−0.0289 (−0.76)−0.0112 (−0.97)−0.0338(−1.66)
LnRKM0.0024(3.57)−0.0022 (−1.05)0.0018(4.78)0.0074(4.31)−0.0235 (−1.03)0.0087(4.97)
LnRD0.0037(4.77)0.0044(4.65)0.0048(5.09)0.0022(2.74)0.0028(2.64)0.0046(5.29)
LnCRD0.0017 (1.07)0.0035(2.88)0.0013 (0.98)0.0011(1.84)0.0031 (1.48)0.0029(2.10)
LnFDI−0.0078 (−0.59)0.0407 (1.18)−0.0129 (−0.78)−0.0148 (−0.17)0.0346 (1.29)−0.0173 (−0.70)
CONS0.7146(32.08)0.7090(31.24)0.7080(34.87)0.6504(26.35)0.6470(24.85)0.6800(33.33)
AR (2)0.11820.19010.13600.19200.18010.2050
Sargan0.09370.15480.10240.11740.20120.1412

Note. , , and represent significance levels of 1%, 5%, and 10%; t values are shown in parentheses.