Research Article

Nonlinear Effects of Governmental and Civil Environmental Regulation on Green Total Factor Productivity in China

Table 5

Regression results of nonlinear effect model (threshold variable: REF).

VariableYear fixed effectSpace fixed effectSpace and year fixed effectYear fixed effectSpace fixed effectSpace and year fixed effect

ModelGER-M7GER-M8GER-M9PER-M10PER-M11PER-M12
L. LnMML0.0994(4.79)0.0224 (0.09)0.1070(5.66)0.1116(2.16)0.0469(2.15)0.1030(5.04)
LnGER−0.2100(−2.02)−0.2630(−2.22)−0.2380(2.21)−0.0150(−5.96)−0.0163(−4.26)−0.0234(−6.88)
LnPER−0.0022 (−0.10)−0.0773(−2.34)−0.0017 (−0.07)−0.0006 (−0.17)−0.0007 (−0.24)−0.0006 (−0.23)
LnGER × LnREF15.4715(1.90)17.1200(2.46)14.5580(1.80)
LnPER × LnREF0.0415 (0.96)0.0441 (1.14)0.0391(1.73)
LnQYJ−0.0020 (−0.63)0.0015 (0.85)−0.0012 (−0.52)−0.0015 (−0.76)−0.0017 (−0.75)−0.0016 (−0.77)
LnRKM0.0751(2.19)−0.0443 (−1.49)0.0959(4.92)0.0099(2.04)−0.0015 (−0.67)0.0103(4.11)
LnRD0.0371(3.80)0.0470(5.01)0.0445(3.75)0.0410(3.66)0.0433(4.92)0.0463(5.09)
LnCRD0.0253 (1.08)0.0474(2.85)0.0142 (0.91)0.0089 (1.10)0.0170 (1.11)0.0121 (0.78)
LnFDI−0.0364 (−0.27)−0.0896 (−0.28)−0.0473(−1.78)−0.0741 (−0.32)0.0192 (0.62)−0.0109 (−0.61)
CONS0.6918(46.78)0.7080(31.62)0.7220(44.54)0.6677(37.20)0.6830(20.85)0.7100(29.14)
AR (2)0.27080.33620.24810.22740.24510.2548
Sargan0.09550.10240.08740.07280.09540.0895

Note. , , and represent significance levels of 1%, 5%, and 10%; t values are shown in parentheses.