Crack Resistance Properties of HPFRC Beam-Column Joints under Cyclic Load

Table 4

Comparison of HPFRC joint cracking strength between calculated values and experimental values.

Specimen	Loading direction	Experiment values ( (kN))	Calculated values ( (kN))		Specimen	Loading direction	Experiment values ( (kN))	Calculated values ( (kN))
EJ-1	Positive	139.13	144.17	0.965	J-1	Positive	156.52	162.11	0.966
	Negative	156.52	144.17	1.086		Negative	175.31	162.11	1.081
EJ-2	Positive	156.52	117.08	1.337	J-2	Positive	187.83	162.11	1.159
	Negative	113.04	117.08	0.966		Negative	156.52	162.11	0.966
EJ-3	Positive	125.22	129.75	0.965	J-3	Positive	187.83	194.54	0.965
	Negative	173.91	129.75	1.340		Negative	187.83	194.54	0.965
EJ-4	Positive	173.91	180.21	0.965	J-4	Positive	219.13	194.54	1.126
	Negative	191.30	180.21	1.062		Negative	187.83	194.54	0.965
EJ-5	Positive	121.74	126.15	0.965	LJ-1	Positive	338.79	350.89	0.966
	Negative	139.13	126.15	1.103		Negative	338.79	350.89	0.966
EJ-6	Positive	156.52	162.19	0.965	LJ-2	Positive	254.09	296.07	0.858
	Negative	173.91	162.19	1.072		Negative	296.44	296.07	1.001
EJ-7	Positive	139.13	144.17	0.965	LJ-3	Positive	296.44	307.03	0.966
	Negative	156.52	144.17	1.086		Negative	338.79	307.03	1.103
EJ-8	Positive	142.61	147.70	0.966	LJ-4	Positive	337.66	349.72	0.966
	Negative	149.57	147.70	1.013		Negative	337.66	349.72	0.966
EJ-9	Positive	121.74	126.09	0.966	LJ-5	Positive	337.66	349.72	0.966
	Negative	173.91	126.09	1.379		Negative	337.66	349.72	0.966
EJ-10	Positive	191.30	180.12	1.062	LJ-6	Positive	296.44	307.03	0.966
	Negative	173.91	180.12	0.966		Negative	338.79	307.03	1.103
EJ-H1	Positive	121.74	126.09	0.966	LJ-7	Positive	338.79	348.54	0.972
	Negative	139.13	126.09	1.103		Negative	381.14	348.54	1.094
EJ-H2	Positive	149.57	148.71	1.006	LJ-8	Positive	295.45	306.00	0.966
	Negative	156.52	148.71	1.053		Negative	337.66	306.00	1.103