Review Article

The Interplay of Varicoceles, Sperm Epigenetics, and Male Infertility: A Focused, Contemporary Review

Table 1

Studies included.

StudyAuthorYearDesignNNotable findings

Sperm DNA methylation findings in men with varicocelesEffect of varicocelectomy on sperm functional characteristics and DNA methylationTavalaee et al. [29]2015Cohort52Sperm concentration, DNA fragmentation, protamine deficiency, and oxidative stress improved after surgery by 42.5%, 47.2%, 18.5%, respectively.
No significant differences in percentage of sperm motility, global DNA methylation, and intensity of DNA methylation following surgery.
DNA hypomethylation predisposes sperm to DNA damage in individuals with varicoceleBahreinian et al. [38]2015Case–control study44 cases,
15 controls
Men with varicoceles demonstrated lower sperm concentration (35.8 vs. 78.9 M/mL) and motility (43.1% vs. 57.3%).
Having a varicocele was associated with a higher abundance of ROS (assessed with 2, 7-dichlorodihydrofluorescein staining: 46.8% vs. 29.3%), more protamine deficiency (assessed with chromomycin A3 staining: 43.5% vs. 32.8%), and DNA fragmentation (assessed with TUNEL assay: 13.2% vs. 8.9%).
There was a negative correlation between DNA methylation and DNA fragmentation (r = −0.3).
The relationship among sperm global DNA methylation, telomere length, and DNA fragmentation in varicocele: A cross-sectional study of 20 casesSantana et al. [35]2019Case–control pilot study20 cases,
20 controls
DNA fragmentation and telomere length were not statistically different between the two groups.
Global sperm DNA methylation was lower in men with varicoceles compared to controls; however, this did not achieve statistical significance.
Differential DNA methylation pattern and sperm quality in men with varicoceleSantana et al. [39]2020Prospective, observational case–control study26 cases,
26 controls
The genomes of men with varicoceles were globally hypomethylated, when compared to the control group ().
1,695 statistically significant differentially methylated regions were identified in the varicocele group compared with the controls.

Men with grade II or III varicoceles demonstrated lower levels of global DNA methylation compared to those with grade I varicoceles, though this did not achieve statistical significance.

Molecular basis for varicocelesIs methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) gene A1298C polymorphism related
with varicocele risk?
Ucar et al.[40]2015Case–control study107 cases, 109 controlsThere was no significant difference in the frequency of C677T genotypes between patients with varicocele and healthy controls; the MTHFR-1298/A allele frequency in the varicocele group was statistically significantly higher in comparison to the control group. Men with a homozygous genotype (1298AA) for the polymorphic allele A1298C have a 2.3-fold higher risk of having varicocele compared with men who do not have this genotype (OR = 2.3, ).
Increased de novo DNA methylation enzymes in sperm of Individuals with varicoceleRashidi et al. [41]2021Case–control study35 cases,
26 controls
Similar percentage of DNMT1 positive sperm between the two groups; the percentage of DNMT3A and DNMT3B positive sperm were significantly higher in the varicocele group compared to the fertile control group (3A: 65.4% vs. 48.3%; 3B: 76.6% vs. 64.3%). Similar results at the RNA level were found.

Animal studiesEffects of varicocele on DNA methylation pattern of H19 and Snrpn gene in spermatozoa and behavioural characteristics of adult rat offspringZhang et al. [42]2017Animal study20 cases,
20 controls
There were no significant differences in DNA methylation levels of H19 and Snrpn genes in spermatozoa among the control group, sham operation group, or varicocele-induced group.
Aberrant expression of TET2 accounts for DNA hypomethylation in varicoceleDinani et al. [43]2023Animal studyEight controls, eight sham, eight casesRats in the varicocele group demonstrated decreased sperm concentration, motility, and morphology; chromatin maturity and DNA integrity (assessed by degree of DNA damage) compared to the other groups.