Review Article
Pulmonary Rehabilitation Can Improve the Functional Capacity and Quality of Life for Pneumoconiosis Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Table 3
Quality assessment: risk of bias.
| | Study | Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) | Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) | Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) | Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Other bias |
| | Yun X 2015 [37] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Complete | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Zhang ZH 2012 [38] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Wang F 2017 [39] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Qu WJ 2017 [40] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Pan W 2017 [41] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Liu QG 2009 [42] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Liu J 2015 [43] | Random number table | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Li XY 2014 [44] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Li F 2015 [45] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Jin YK 2014 [46] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Cao DF 2010 [47] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Dale 2014 [48] | Computer-generated randomization program | Uncertain risk | No | Assessor blind | Complete | No | No | | Ma LL 2014 [49] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Without the primary outcomes | Uncertain risk | | Liu CZ 2014 [50] | Lottery | Lottery | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | | Dong QA 2009 [51] | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Uncertain risk | Without the primary outcomes | Uncertain risk | | Xiao SY 2019 [52] | Random number table | Uncertain risk | No | Uncertain risk | Complete | No | No |
|
|
