Review Article

A Systematic Review of Factors Associated with Under-Five Child Mortality

Table 1

Characteristics of included studies ().

First authorYearStudy designMethod(s)Study areaObjective(s)Data source and sample sizeFactors associated with under-five child mortality

Abir [38]2015Cross-sectionalMultilevel modelsCountry-wide (Bangladesh)To identify factors associated with mortality in children under 5 years of ageBangladesh DHS 2004, 2007, and 2011 (combine) ( live births)Working status of mother; working (, , value < 0.001), maternal highest level of education; secondary or more with Ref to no education (, ; value < 0.001), previous death of siblings; yes (, ; value < 0.001), no. of children under age 5 at home; 3 and above (, , value < 0.001), TT vaccination at pregnancy; one TT with Ref to never (, , 0.96; value = 0.023), 2 and more TT (, , value < 0.001), delivery complications; any complications with Ref to none (, , value = 0.001), contraceptive use; yes (, , value < 0.001), Mother’s age at child birth; 30-39 with Ref to <20 (, , value = 0.046), birth rank and birth interval; 2nd/3rd birth rank, years interval with Ref to 2nd/3rd birth rank, years interval (, , value < 0.001), 4th birth rank, years interval (, , value < 0.001), birth place and mode of delivery; home with Ref to health facilities without caesarean (, , value = 0.002)

Andegiorgish [32]2022Cross-sectionalMultilevel regression modelCountry-wide (Zambia)To describe the burden, trend, and associated factors of under-five mortality rateZambia DHS 2007, 2013-14, and 2018 (combine) ( live births)Maternal age; 20-24 with Ref to 15-19 years (, value < 0.05), 25-29 years (, value < 0.01), 30-34 years (, value < 0.05), wealth index; poorer with Ref to richest (, value < 0.05), place of residence; rural with Ref to urban (, value < 0.001), ANC visits; no ANC as compared to had at least one ANC visits (, value < 0.001), birth type; multiple birth with Ref single (, value < 0.001), size of child at birth; below average with Ref to average (, value < 0.001), child sex; male with Ref to female (, value < 0.001), regions; eastern with Ref to central (, value < 0.01) Luapula (, value < 0.01) Muchinga (, value < 0.01)

Arku [28]2016Cross-sectionalIndirect demographic method and Bayesian spatial modelCountry-wide (Ghana)To estimate the under-five child mortality and its social and environmental risk factors110 districts (10% random sample of Ghana’s 2000 and 2010 National Population and Housing Census), and indirect demographic methods and Bayesian spatial model was used to estimate under-five mortalityUse of LPG in household for cooking (, ) associated with lower under-five mortality.

Ayele [22]2015Cross-sectionalStructured additive logistic regression modelCountry-wide (Ethiopia)To estimate the under-five mortality risk factorsEthiopian DHS 2011 ( live births)Distance to fetch water; 31-60 min. with Ref to on the premises (, ) more than 60 min. (, ), source of drinking water; tap water with Ref to unprotected water (, ), cooking fuel; electricity/gas with Ref to straw/animal dung (, ), type of toilet; no toilet facility with Ref to toilet with flush/pit latrine (, ), other toilet type (, ), type of floor; cement with Ref to wood (, ), earth/sand/dung (, ), type of roof; corrugated iron/metal with Ref to thatch/leaf/mud (, ), mat/plastic sheet/wood (, ), type of wall; cane/trunk/bamboo with Ref to wood planks/shingles (, ), smoking habit; no (, ), region, place of residence; rural (, ), working status of mother; no (, ), sex of child; female (, ).

Becher [19]2009Cross-sectionalPenalized splines and Cox regression modelCountry-wide (rural Burkina Faso)To investigate the effect of multiple risk factors for childhood mortalityNouna DSS, (children born alive between Jan 1, 1998, and Dec 31, 2001, and mortality follow-up to five years)
(n =8,986 live births)
Sex of child; male (, value = 0.04), ethnic group; Peulh with Ref to Bwaba (, value = 0.03), religion; natural/other with Ref to Muslim (, value = 0.02), type of birth; twin with Ref to single (, value < 0.01), age of mother at birth; young (<18 years) with Ref to middle (18-34) (, value < 0.01), distance to next health center; >10 km (, value < 0.01).

Conombo [20]2017Cross-sectionalLogistic regressionCountry-wide (Burkina Faso)To examine the effects of risk factors on under-five mortalityBurkina Faso DHS-2010 ( live births)Preceding birth interval; 18-23 with Ref to <18 months (, , value = 0.011), 24-29 (, , value < 0.001), 30-35 (, , value < 0.001), 36-41 (, , value < 0.001), 42-47 (, , value < 0.001), 48-53 (, , value < 0.001), breastfeeding; never breastfeed with Ref to ever (, , value < 0.001), type of birth; twin with Ref to single (, , value < 0.001), birth order; 2 with Ref to 1 (, , value = 0.009), 3 with Ref to 1 (, , value = 0.026), size at birth; (, , value = 0.001); region ( values < 0.05)

Ettarh [33]2012Cross-sectionalMultivariate analysis (hazard ratio)Country-wide (Kenya)To compare the influence of geographical location and key maternal factors on under-five deathsKenya DHS 2008-2009 ( live births)Place of residence; rural (, , value < 0.05), age of mother; 32 with Ref to 15-20 years (, , value < 0.01), birth order; 2-3 with Ref to 1 (, , value < 0.05), 4 (, , value < 0.05), wealth index; middle with Ref to low (, , value < 0.05), highest (, , value < 0.05), province/region ( value for ), duration of breastfeeding; >12 months with Ref to <6 months (, , value < 0.05)

Ezeh [25]2015Cross-sectionalCox proportional hazard regression modelCountry-wide (Nigeria)To identify the factors associated with under-five mortalityNigeria DHS 2003, 2008 and 2013 ( live births, combined sample)Birth order and birth interval; 1st child with Ref to 2nd or 3rd child, (, value < 0.001), 2nd or 3rd child, (, value < 0.001), 4th or higher, (, value < 0.001), household wealth index; middle with Ref to rich (, value = 0.001), poor (, value = 0.001), mother’s education; no education with Ref to secondary or higher (, value = 0.032), place of residence; rural (, value = 0.001), sex of child; male (, value < 0.001), mode of delivery; caesarean with Ref to noncaesarean (, value = 0.001), size of child at birth; small or very small with Ref to average or large (, value < 0.001), mother’s age; less than 20 with Ref to 30-39 (, value = 0.004), 40-49 (, value < 0.001)

Fenta [23]2020Cross-sectionalTwo-part random-effects regression model (negative binomial hurdle model)Country-wide (Ethiopia)To identify the potential risk factors for child mortalityEthiopian DHS 2016 ( live births)Child vaccination; yes (, ), family size; (, ), age of mother; (, ), ANC visit; 1-3 with Ref to no (, ), 4 or above (, ), previous birth interval; 25-36 months with Ref to 4 months (, ), 37 and above (, ), use of contraceptive; yes (, ), father’s education; secondary and above with Ref to no education (, ), mother’s education; primary with Ref to no education (, ), father’s occupation; had working with Ref to no (, ), place of delivery; private sector with Ref to home (, ), type of births; multiple with Ref to single (, ), age of mother at first birth; 17 and above with Ref to 16 (, ), birth order; 1-3 with Ref to first (, ), 4 and above (, ), religion; Muslim with Ref to orthodox (, ), between enumeration area (level 2) (, )

Ghimire [37]2019Cross-sectionalSurvey-based Cox proportional hazard modelCountry-wide (Nepal)To identify the factors associated with under-five child mortalityNepal DHS (2001-2016) ( live births)Previous dead child; yes (, , value < 0.001), tetanus toxoids (TT) vaccination during pregnancy; one TT with Ref to two or more TT (, , value 0.013), no TT (, , value < 0.001), contraceptives use; no (, , value < 0.001), ethnicity; Madhesi with Ref to Brahmin/Chhetri (, , value < 0.001), mother’s literacy level; cannot read with Ref to can read (, , value = 0.031), mother’s occupation; agriculture with Ref to not working (, , value = 0.018), skilled/professional (, , value < 0.001), mother’s age; 20-29 with Ref to 40-49 years (, , p value = 0.003), < 20 (, , value < 0.001), birth rank and birth interval; 1st child with Ref to 2nd/3rd birth rank, >2 years (, , value < 0.001), 4th/higher birth rank, (, , value < 0.001), 4th/higher birth rank, (, , value = 0.015)

Gutema [24]2022Open cohort population-based longitudinal surveillance designMultilevel logistic regressionKHDSS, eastern EthiopiaTo assess under-five mortality focusing on the trends and associated factors based on 2008-2016 data in KHDSSKHDSS in Kersa district, East Hararghe Zone, Oromia region, Ethiopia ( live births)ANC visits; yes (, ), education of mother; elementary with Ref to no-education (, ), birth weight; normal with Ref to low (, ), big (, ), window presence in the house; yes (, ), occupation of mother; employed (, ), family size; two and/or less with Ref to more than 5 (, ), 3-4 (, )

Hammer [21]2006Cross-sectional/cohortCox proportional hazards regressionSub-Saharan Africa (Burkina Faso)To identify the effect of risk factors for childhood mortalityDSS and DHS (1998-1999) of Burkina Faso ( for DSS, for DHS live births)Birth order; first with Ref to 2-4 (, , value = 0.02), multiple birth (, , value < 0.01), family size; 7-10 with Ref to 6 (, , value < 0.01), >11 (, , value < 0.01), religion; Catholic with Ref to Muslim (, , value = 0.03), traditional (, , value < 0.01)

Iddrisu [29]2020Cross-sectionalLogistic regression model using frequentist and Bayesian frameworkCountry-wide (Ghana)To identify the risk factors of child mortalityGhana DHS 2014 ( live births)Mode of delivery; caesarean section with Ref to not caesarean section (, , value < 0.05), size of child at birth; average with Ref to small (, , value < 0.05), large (, , value < 0.05), mother’s education; formal education with Ref to no formal education (, , value < 0.05)

Kandala [34]2014Cross-sectionalLogistic regression and multivariate Bayesian geo-additive survival analysisCountry-wide (DR of Congo)To examine province-level geographic variation in under-five mortality and accounting risk factors of under-five mortalityCongo DHS 2007 ( live births)Preceding birth interval; <24 months with Ref to 24 months (, ), place of delivery; home with Ref to hospital (, ), marital status of mother; single with Ref to married (, )

Kayode [26]2012Cross-sectionalMultiple logistic regressionCountry-wide (Nigeria)To determine risk factors of under-five mortalityNigeria DHS 2008 ( live births)Maternal age; 26-30 with Ref to 0 years (, , value 0.001), 31-35 (, , value = 0.001), >35 (, , value = 0.001), maternal age at first marriage; 20-24 with Ref to <15 years (, , value = 0.001), 25 (, , value = 0.001), use of contraception; traditional with Ref to no method (, , value = 0.017), health seeking behavior; average with Ref to low (, , value = 0.001), preceding birth interval; 18-36 with Ref to <18 months (, , value = 0.001), >36 (, , value = 0.001), breastfeeding; >18 with Ref to <6 months (, , value = 0.001), birth order; 2, 3, or 4 with Ref to 1 (, , value = 0.001), birth weight; small with Ref to normal (, , value = 0.004), family size; >5 with Ref to 1-5 (, , value = 0.001), type of toilet; bad toilet with Ref to good toilet (, , value = 0.001), fuel source; kerosene with Ref to gas (, , value = 0.001), others (, , value = 0.001), no. of wives; more wives with Ref to one (, , value = 0.001), type of residence; rural (, , value = 0.002)

Motsima [30]2016Cross-sectionalMultiple logistic regressionCountry-wide (Lesotho)To determine the factors associated with under-five child mortalityLesotho DHS -2009 ( live births)Sex of child; female (, , value = 0.016), type of births; multiple (, , value = 0.046), breastfeeding duration; 13-18 with Ref to 0-12 months (, , value < 0.001), 19 and above (, , value < 0.001), source of energy; other with Ref to electricity; (, , value = 0.005), marital status; formerly married with Ref to married (, , value < 0.001)

Naz [39]2021Cross-sectionalCox proportional hazards regressionCountry-wide (Pakistan)To examine the effect of socioeconomic status and type of residence on under-five mortalityPakistan DHS 2017/18 ( live births)Mother’s education; educated (, , value < 0.001), mother’s employment; working (, , value < 0.10), birth spacing; 2-3 with Ref to <2 years (, , value < 0.001), >3 years (, , value < 0.001), mother’s age at first birth; 18 years (, , value < 0.001), birth size; average with Ref to small (, , value < 0.001)

Naz [35]2020Cross-sectionalCox proportional hazards modelCountry-wide (Sierra Leone)To point out crucial risk factors of under-five mortalitySierra Leone DHS 2013 ( live births)Age of mother at first birth; >18 with Ref to 18 years (, , value < 0.001), sex of child; female (, , value < 0.001), number of children in the house; 3-4 child with Ref to 1-2 child (, , value < 0.001), 5 and above (, , value < 0.001), birth interval; >3 years with Ref to <2 years (, , value < 0.05), size of child at birth; smaller than average with Ref to very small (, , value < 0.001), average or larger (, , value < 0.001)

Ogbo [36]2019Cross-sectionalCox proportional hazards modelCountry-wide (Tanzania)To investigate the trends and determinants of neonatal, postneonatal, infant, child, and under-five mortalities in Tanzania from 2004 to 2016Tanzanian DHS 2004-2005, 2010, 2015-2016 ( live births, combine of three Tanzanian DHS)Type of residence; rural (, ), mother’s education; primary with Ref to secondary or higher (, ), birth rank and birth interval; first child with Ref to 2 or 3 child, (, ), 2 or 3 child, (, ), 4 or more child, (, ), sex of child; male (, ), size of child at birth; small or very small with Ref to average or larger (, )

Rhoda [27]2019Cross-sectional descriptive studyBinary logistic regressionFederal capital territory of NigeriaTo examine the effect of demographic and socioeconomic characteristics of women to under-five child mortalityPrimary data ( live births)Education of mother (, value = 0.019), main occupation of mother (, value = 0.005), ethnic group (, value = 0.091), average monthly income of mother (, value = 0.064)

Vanthy [40]2019Cross-sectionalWeibull hazards regressionCountry-wide (Cambodia)To define persistent and emerging factors associated with under-five mortality in CambodiaCambodian DHS 2010 and 2014 ( Cambodian DHS 2010, Cambodian DHS 2014)Type of birth; twin (CDHS 2010: , ), birth interval; 2-3 years with Ref to <2 years (CDHS 2010: , ; CDHS 2014: , ), more than 3 years (CDHS 2010: , ; CDHS 2014: , ), age of mother at child birth; more than 40 years with Ref to <20 years (CDHS 2010: , ; CDHS 2014: , ), mother’s education; primary with Ref to no education (CDHS 2010: , ), secondary or higher (CDHS 2010: , ; CDHS 2014: , ), place of residence; rural CDHS 2014: , ), region; plain with Ref to Phnom Penh (CDHS 2010: , ), ANC visit; have ANC (CDHS 2010: , ; CDHS 2014: , ), TT vaccination; received >2 dose with Ref to not received at last birth (CDHS 2010: , ), child vaccination status; not fully immunized with Ref to fully immunized (CDHS 2010: , ; CDHS 2014: , )

Yaya [31]2018Cross-sectionalMultivariable Cox proportional hazards regressionMulticountry analysis (five sub-Saharan African countries-Chad, Demographic Republic (DR) of Congo, Mali, Niger, and Zimbabwe)To examine the maternal factors associated with under-five mortalityDHS data from five sub-Saharan Africa countries ( live births)Age of mother at first birth; (Mali: , , value < 0.05; Zimbabwe: , , value < 0.05), place of residence; rural (Chad: , ; DR Congo: , ; Mali: , ; Niger: , ; Zimbabwe: , , value < 0.05), education of mother; secondary with Ref to no formal (Zimbabwe: , , value < 0.05; higher: , , value < 0.05), wealth index; richer with Ref to poorest (DR Congo: , , value < 0.05), richest (DR Congo: , ; Niger: , , value < 0.05), marital status; not currently married with Ref to currently married/in union (DR Congo: , ; Mali: 2.43, ; Niger: , ; Zimbabwe: , , value < 0.05), type of birth; multiple (Niger: , ; Zimbabwe: , , value < 0.05), mode of delivery; caesarean section (Chad: , ; DR Congo: , ; Mali: , ; Niger: , ; Zimbabwe: , ; value < 0.05), size of child; small with Ref to large (DR Congo: , ; Niger: , , value < 0.05), birth order; 5 and above (Chad: , ; DR Congo: 0.44, , value < 0.05), birth interval; 18-24 with Ref to <18 (DR Congo: , ), >24 (Chad: , ; DR Congo: , , value < 0.05)

OR: odds ratio; RR: risk ratio; AOR: adjusted odds ratio; CI: confidence interval; HR: hazard ratio; AHR: adjusted hazard ratio; IRR: incidence rate ratio; Ref: reference category; DHS: demographic and health survey; DSS: demographic surveillance system; KHDSS: Kersa health and demographic surveillance site.