Research Article

Low-Temperature Plasma Short Exposure to Decontaminate Peri-Implantitis-Related Multispecies Biofilms on Titanium Surfaces In Vitro

Table 5

Comparisons against LPT groups.

BacteriaBiofilmComparisonGroup 2 valueResult95% CI

A. naeslundii24 hNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0144.38 (3.12, 4.70)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0154.38 (2.23, 4.70)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0154.38 (3.06, 4.70)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0154.38 (2.47, 4.70)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0144.38 (2.75, 4.70)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0144.38 (3.58, 4.70)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.156Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.1.32 (0.00, 1.91)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.561Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.35 (-0.88, 1.91)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.217Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.0.95 (0.00, 1.91)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.507Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.0.38 (-0.83, 1.91)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.207Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.1.32 (0.00, 1.91)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.115Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.1.32 (0.00, 1.91)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0142.60 (2.30, 3.53)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0162.30 (0.40, 3.53)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0152.45 (1.28, 3.53)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.30 (0.45, 3.53)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.014Amoxicillin > plasma 5 min/3 mm2.60 (2.00, 3.53)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0142.60 (2.30, 3.53)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.277Metronidazole & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 2.08)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.794Metronidazole & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (-0.88, 2.08)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.435Metronidazole & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 2.08)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.664Metronidazole & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (-0.83, 2.08)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.361Metronidazole & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 2.08)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.240Metronidazole & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 2.08)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.101Amoxicillin+metronidazole & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.1.79 (0.00, 2.08)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.618Amoxicillin+metronidazole & Plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (-0.36, 2.08)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.132Amoxicillin+metronidazole & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.0.82 (0.00, 2.08)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.410Amoxicillin+metronidazole & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.0.12 (-0.24, 2.08)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.208Amoxicillin+metronidazole & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.1.79 (0.00, 2.08)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.088Amoxicillin+metronidazole & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.1.79 (0.00, 2.08)
3 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0163.49 (2.30, 4.34)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0173.34 (1.99, 4.34)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0124.25 (3.60, 4.70)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.93 (2.39, 4.34)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0124.25 (3.60, 4.70)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0124.25 (3.60, 4.70)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.238 n.s.1.08 (-1.32, 2.64)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.340 n.s.0.65 (-1.61, 2.64)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.2.11 (0.00, 2.64)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.174Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.1.30 (0.00, 2.64)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.2.11 (0.00, 2.64)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.2.11 (0.00, 2.64)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0162.76 (1.77, 3.72)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0172.62 (1.39, 3.72)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.69 (3.00, 3.85)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.48 (1.79, 3.72)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.69 (3.00, 3.85)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.69 (3.00, 3.85)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0162.58 (1.47, 3.75)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0162.43 (1.09, 3.75)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.62 (2.70, 3.78)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.79 (1.71, 3.75)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.62 (2.70, 3.78)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.62 (2.70, 3.78)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.016 1 min2.59 (1.39, 3.70)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.016 1 min2.44 (1.00, 3.70)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.012 3 min3.50 (2.70, 3.79)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.016 3 min2.72 (1.39, 3.70)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.50 (2.70, 3.79)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.012 5 min3.50 (2.70, 3.79)
7 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0124.12 (3.53, 4.89)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0163.99 (2.62, 4.38)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0124.12 (3.53, 4.89)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.99 (2.62, 4.38)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.014No treatment > plasma 5 min/3 mm4.00 (3.53, 4.38)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0124.12 (3.53, 4.89)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.2.05 (0.00, 2.92)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.198Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.1.32 (0.00, 2.92)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.2.05 (0.00, 2.92)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.198Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.1.32 (0.00, 2.92)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.101Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.1.39 (0.00, 2.92)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.2.05 (0.00, 2.92)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.80 (2.64, 3.48)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0162.66 (1.32, 3.26)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.80 (2.64, 3.48)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.66 (1.32, 3.26)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.68 (2.16, 3.26)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.80 (2.64, 3.48)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0252.84 (2.08, 3.38)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0472.18 (0.00, 3.38)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0252.84 (2.08, 3.38)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0472.18 (0.00, 3.38)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0362.82 (0.00, 3.38)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.84 (2.08, 3.38)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.81 (2.60, 3.88)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0162.68 (1.30, 3.34)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.81 (2.60, 3.88)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.68 (1.30, 3.34)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.70 (2.56, 3.34)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.81 (2.60, 3.88)
P. gingivalis24 hNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0144.72 (3.81, 5.09)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0164.60 (1.82, 5.09)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0144.72 (3.52, 5.09)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0164.60 (1.89, 5.09)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0144.72 (3.13, 5.09)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0124.84 (4.60, 5.13)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0362.15 (0.00, 3.07)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.210Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.1.79 (-0.63, 3.07)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0362.15 (0.00, 3.07)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.186Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.1.79 (-0.57, 3.07)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0482.15 (0.00, 3.07)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.46 (1.79, 3.07)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0143.45 (2.75, 3.98)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0213.38 (0.61, 3.98)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0143.45 (2.46, 3.98)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0213.38 (0.67, 3.98)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0143.45 (2.07, 3.98)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.66 (2.99, 4.07)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0143.23 (2.91, 3.42)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0163.18 (0.34, 3.42)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0143.23 (2.62, 3.42)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.18 (0.36, 3.42)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0143.23 (2.23, 3.42)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.30 (3.07, 4.23)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0143.47 (3.11, 4.26)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0163.28 (0.50, 4.26)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0143.47 (2.82, 4.26)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.28 (0.56, 4.26)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0143.47 (2.42, 4.26)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.67 (3.20, 4.43)
3 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0163.29 (2.16, 4.07)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0172.46 (1.77, 3.93)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.98 (3.78, 4.13)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.29 (2.61, 4.07)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.98 (3.78, 4.13)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.98 (3.78, 4.13)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.129Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.1.32 (0.00, 2.97)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.392Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.68 (-1.32, 1.68)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.025Chlorhexidine > plasma 3 min/3 mm2.07 (1.32, 2.97)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.083Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.1.47 (0.00, 2.97)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0252.07 (1.32, 2.97)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.07 (1.32, 2.97)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0162.78 (1.51, 3.42)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0171.76 (1.07, 3.09)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.14 (2.86, 4.02)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.78 (1.76, 3.42)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.14 (2.86, 4.02)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.14 (2.86, 4.02)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0162.48 (1.19, 3.58)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0171.77 (0.87, 3.01)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.30 (2.48, 3.85)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.50 (1.69, 3.58)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.30 (2.48, 3.85)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.30 (2.48, 3.85)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0162.45 (1.28, 3.20)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0171.38 (0.82, 2.60)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.92 (2.60, 3.62)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.45 (1.28, 3.20)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0122.92 (2.60, 3.62)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.92 (2.60, 3.62)
7 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.96 (3.58, 4.28)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.014No treatment > plasma 1 min/10 mm3.91 (2.96, 4.16)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0143.91 (2.96, 4.16)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.27 (2.08, 4.16)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0143.91 (2.96, 4.16)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.012No treatment > plasma 5 min/10 mm3.96 (3.58, 4.28)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.2.38 (0.00, 2.87)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.088Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.2.15 (0.00, 2.87)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.088Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.2.15 (0.00, 2.87)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.185Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.1.26 (-1.32, 2.87)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.088Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.2.15 (0.00, 2.87)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.051Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.2.38 (0.00, 2.87)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.93 (2.30, 4.02)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0142.78 (2.30, 3.89)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0142.78 (2.30, 3.89)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.53 (0.98, 3.89)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.78 (2.30, 3.89)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.93 (2.30, 4.02)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.03 (2.78, 3.81)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0142.88 (2.48, 3.66)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0142.88 (2.48, 3.66)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.63 (1.46, 3.66)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.88 (2.48, 3.66)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.03 (2.78, 3.81)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.02 (2.30, 3.83)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0142.98 (2.30, 3.76)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0142.98 (2.30, 3.76)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.30 (0.98, 3.76)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.98 (2.30, 3.76)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.02 (2.30, 3.83)
S. oralis24 hNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0124.63 (4.46, 4.94)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0164.60 (1.85, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0124.63 (4.46, 4.94)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0164.60 (2.20, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0144.60 (2.74, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0144.60 (3.33, 4.81)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.0.66 (0.00, 3.42)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.545Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (-1.63, 3.42)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.0.66 (0.00, 3.42)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.545Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (-1.28, 3.42)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.277Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.42)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.277Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.42)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.83 (2.62, 4.35)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0213.01 (1.15, 4.21)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.83 (2.62, 4.35)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.01 (1.00, 4.21)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0143.55 (2.14, 4.21)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0143.55 (2.62, 4.21)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.24 (3.05, 4.26)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0163.18 (0.45, 3.41)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.24 (3.05, 4.26)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.18 (0.81, 3.41)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0143.22 (2.05, 3.41)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0143.22 (2.65, 3.41)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.83 (3.20, 4.39)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0163.58 (0.93, 3.88)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.83 (3.20, 4.39)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.58 (1.24, 3.88)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0143.82 (2.18, 3.88)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0143.82 (2.77, 3.88)
3 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.012No treatment > plasma 1 min/3 mm3.95 (3.79, 4.48)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0172.61 (1.71, 3.96)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.95 (3.79, 4.48)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.48 (2.10, 4.01)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.95 (3.79, 4.48)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.95 (3.79, 4.48)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0252.26 (1.32, 2.99)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.315Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.1.16 (-0.98, 2.90)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0252.26 (1.32, 2.99)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.1291.46 (0.00, 2.99)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0252.26 (1.32, 2.99)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.26 (1.32, 2.99)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.42 (3.10, 3.92)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0172.03 (1.27, 3.42)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.42 (3.10, 3.92)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.85 (1.66, 3.57)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.42 (3.10, 3.92)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.42 (3.10, 3.92)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.36 (2.48, 3.66)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0171.95 (1.04, 3.37)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.36 (2.48, 3.66)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.41 (1.43, 3.64)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.36 (2.48, 3.66)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.36 (2.48, 3.66)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.31 (2.60, 4.34)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0172.02 (0.99, 3.49)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.31 (2.60, 4.34)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.60 (1.28, 3.62)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.31 (2.60, 4.34)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.31 (2.60, 4.34)
7 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0124.23 (3.32, 5.31)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0143.95 (2.56, 4.67)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0124.23 (3.32, 5.31)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0143.95 (3.32, 4.67)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0124.23 (3.32, 5.31)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0124.23 (3.32, 5.31)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.203Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.31)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.477Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.31)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.203Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.31)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.477Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.31)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.203Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.31)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.203Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (0.00, 3.31)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0252.31 (1.91, 3.78)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.087Amoxicillin & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.2.15 (0.00, 3.78)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0252.31 (1.91, 3.78)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0362.15 (0.00, 3.78)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0252.31 (1.91, 3.78)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.31 (1.91, 3.78)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.051Metronidazole & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.3.25 (0.00, 3.37)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.088Metronidazole & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.3.16 (0.00, 3.37)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.051Metronidazole & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.3.25 (0.00, 3.37)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.088Metronidazole & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.3.16 (0.00, 3.37)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.051Metronidazole & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.3.25 (0.00, 3.37)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.051Metronidazole & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.3.25 (0.00, 3.37)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0252.64 (2.58, 3.51)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0862.58 (0.00, 3.51)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0252.64 (2.58, 3.51)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0352.58 (0.00, 3.51)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0252.64 (2.58, 3.51)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.64 (2.58, 3.51)
V. dispar24 hNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0124.58 (4.00, 5.00)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0164.32 (2.64, 4.85)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0124.58 (4.00, 5.00)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0164.32 (2.35, 4.85)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0144.56 (3.68, 4.85)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0124.58 (4.00, 5.00)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.61 (2.21, 2.86)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0182.26 (0.65, 2.68)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.61 (2.21, 2.86)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0182.26 (0.48, 2.68)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.53 (1.54, 2.68)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.61 (2.21, 2.86)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.53 (2.08, 4.56)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0212.38 (0.76, 3.75)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.53 (2.08, 4.56)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0212.33 (0.30, 3.75)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.42 (2.08, 3.75)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.53 (2.08, 4.56)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.60 (2.30, 4.82)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0162.48 (0.98, 3.72)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.60 (2.30, 4.82)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.48 (0.44, 3.72)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.51 (2.30, 3.72)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.60 (2.30, 4.82)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.58 (1.79, 4.06)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0212.38 (0.46, 3.93)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.58 (1.79, 4.06)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0282.26 (0.30, 3.93)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0142.51 (1.79, 3.93)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.58 (1.79, 4.06)
3 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.92 (3.15, 4.41)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0172.97 (2.01, 4.02)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.92 (3.15, 4.41)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0163.79 (2.59, 4.02)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.92 (3.15, 4.41)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.92 (3.15, 4.41)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.00)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.802Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.00 (-1.79, 2.00)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.00)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.346Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.0.15 (0.00, 2.00)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.00)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.00)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.84 (2.15, 3.42)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0171.98 (0.54, 3.34)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.84 (2.15, 3.42)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.26 (1.28, 3.34)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0122.84 (2.15, 3.42)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.84 (2.15, 3.42)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.57 (1.61, 2.89)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0341.45 (0.22, 2.78)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.57 (1.61, 2.89)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0162.00 (1.13, 2.78)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0122.57 (1.61, 2.89)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.57 (1.61, 2.89)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0122.90 (2.38, 3.85)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0162.31 (0.77, 3.00)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0122.90 (2.38, 3.85)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0152.51 (1.58, 3.00)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0122.90 (2.38, 3.85)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0122.90 (2.38, 3.85)
7 dNo treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0123.89 (2.90, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0123.89 (2.90, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0123.89 (2.90, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0123.89 (2.90, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0123.89 (2.90, 4.81)
No treatmentvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0123.89 (2.90, 4.81)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/3 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.08)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 1 min/10 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.08)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/3 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.08)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 3 min/10 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.08)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/3 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.08)
Chlorhexidinevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.102Chlorhexidine & plasma 5 min/10 mm n.s.0.81 (0.00, 2.08)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0252.54 (1.32, 3.01)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0252.54 (1.32, 3.01)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0252.54 (1.32, 3.01)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0252.54 (1.32, 3.01)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0252.54 (1.32, 3.01)
Amoxicillinvs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.54 (1.32, 3.01)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0252.23 (1.91, 2.60)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0252.23 (1.91, 2.60)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0252.23 (1.91, 2.60)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0252.23 (1.91, 2.60)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0252.23 (1.91, 2.60)
Metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.23 (1.91, 2.60)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/3 mm0.0252.38 (1.32, 2.64)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 1 min/10 mm0.0252.38 (1.32, 2.64)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/3 mm0.0252.38 (1.32, 2.64)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 3 min/10 mm0.0252.38 (1.32, 2.64)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/3 mm0.0252.38 (1.32, 2.64)
Amoxicillin+metronidazolevs.Plasma 5 min/10 mm0.0252.38 (1.32, 2.64)