Research Article

Forest Pruning Based on Branch Importance

Table 2

The accuracy of FP, bagging, and random forest. represents that FP outperforms bagging in pairwise t-tests at 95% significance level and denotes that FP is outperformed by bagging.

Dataset Unpruned C4.5Pruned C4.5PFRF
PFBaggingPFBagging

Australian87.14 (2.0)86.09 86.80 (3.0)85.86 87.21 (1.0)86.14
Autos74.40 (2.0)73.30 74.20 (3.0)73.20 74.72 (1.0)73.10
Backache85.07 (3.0)83.17 85.89 (1.0)83.17 85.21 (2.0)83.22
Balance-scale78.89 (3.0)75.07 79.79 (1.0)76.64 79.65 (2.0)76.32
Breast-cancer69.98 (2.0)67.10 69.97 (3.0)66.58 70.11 (1.0)68.88
Cars86.51 (4.0)86.78 (2.0)86.88 (1.0)86.28 (5.0)86.55 (3.0)86.11 (6.0)
Credit-rating86.44 (2.0)85.54 86.34 (3.0)85.43 86.82 (1.0)85.42
German-credit75.33 (1.0)73.83 74.86 (3.0)73.11 75.22 (2.0)73.18
Ecoli84.47 (2.0)83.32 84.20 (3.0)83.40 84.52 (1.0)83.89
Hayes-roth78.75 (3.0)78.63 (5.0)78.77 (1.0)76.31 78.76 (2.0)77.77 (4.0)
Heart-c80.94 (2.0)80.34 (5.0)81.01 (1.0)80.27 (6.0)80.90 (3.0)80.87 (4.0)
Horse-colic84.52 (1.0)83.29 84.33 (2.0)83.42 84.31 (3.0)83.99 (4.0)
Ionosphere93.99 (1.0)93.93 (2.0)93.59 (6.0)93.71 (4.0)93.87 (3.0)93.56 (5.0)
Iris93.55 (6.0)94.24 (4.0)94.52 (3.0)94.53 (2.0)94.21 (5.0)94.62 (1.0)
Lymphography83.81 (5.0)83.43 (6.0)84.55 (2.0)84.53 (3.0)84.38 (4.0)84.82 (1.0)
Page-blocks97.03 (4.5)97.04 (2.5)97.04 (2.5)97.06 (1.0)97.03 (4.5)97.01 (6.0)
Pima75.09 (3.0)74.27 75.46 (1.0)74.06 75.43 (2.0)73.21
prnn-fglass78.14 (4.0)78.46 (1.0)77.62 (6.0)77.84 (5.0)78.18 (3.0)78.32 (2.0)
Vote95.77 (1.0)95.13 95.67 (3.0)95.33 (4.0)95.72 (2.0)95.31 (5.0)