Review Article

Complex Brain Network Analysis and Its Applications to Brain Disorders: A Survey

Table 7

Overview of functional brain network studies in PD.

StudyModality SubjectsNode definition Edge definition Network type Main findings

Skidmore et al., 2011 [122]fMRI14 PD
15 HC
116 regions in AAL atlasWavelet correlationWeighted(1) Decreased global efficiency in PD.
(2) Decreased nodal efficiency the left supplementary motor cortex, contiguous precentral regions, the calcarine cortices, secondary visual regions, and the certain regions within the cerebellum in PD.

Göttlich et al., 2013 [123]fMRI37 PD
20 HC
343 regionsZero-lag Pearson correlationBinary(1) Lower global efficiency in PD in PD.
(2) Increased connectivity within the sensorimotor network and decreased interaction of the visual network with other brain modules in PD.
(3) Lower connectivity between the cuneus and the ventral caudate, medial orbitofrontal cortex, and the temporal lobe.
(4) Decreased degree in the occipital lobe and increased degree in the superior parietal cortex, posterior cingulate gyrus, supramarginal gyrus, and supplementary motor area.

Luo et al., 2015 [124]fMRI47 PD
47 HC
200 regions in [67]Pearson correlationBinary(1) Lower clustering coefficient and local efficiency in PD.
(2) Reduced node centralities and connectivity strength in temporal-occipital and sensorimotor regions in PD.

Koshimori et al., 2016 [125]fMRI42 PD
23 HC
120 regions in [61]Pearson correlationBinary(1) Higher nodal degree in the right and left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in PD.
(2) Reduced local efficiency the right mid-insula in PD.
(3) Reduced nodal betweenness centrality in the right presupplementary motor area in PD.

Olde Dubbelink et al., 2014 [126]MEG70 PD
21 HC
78 regions in AAL atlasPhase lag indexWeighted(1) Lower local clustering coefficient with preserved path length in the delta frequency band in PD.
(2) Decreased local clustering coefficient in multiple frequency bands with decreased path length in the alpha2 frequency band in PD.

Utianski et al., 2016 [127]EEG18
PD-D
57
PD-HC
57 HC
8 epochsPhase lag indexWeighted(1) Higher connectivity strength in the theta band in PD-HC compared with HC.
(2) higher gamma, lambda, and modularity in PD-HC compared with HC.
(3) lower functional connectivity in the alpha1 band in PD-D compared with PD-HC.
(4) Lower gamma and lambda in the alpha1 band and higher modularity in both alpha bands in PD-D compared with PD-HC.