Dynamic Measurement Analysis of Urban Innovation Ability and Ecological Efficiency in China

Table 5

Evaluation scores of the urban innovation level of 30 provinces and cities in China.

Year	2008	2009	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017	2018	2019
Beijing	52.20	53.19	47.92	50.31	46.11	50.73	50.11	50.45	52.61	52.56	54.30	53.22
Tianjin	37.24	37.44	35.89	38.29	34.09	36.13	36.61	36.49	34.15	33.71	32.14	28.83
Hebei	22.54	25.20	23.26	24.44	26.67	23.02	20.88	21.l4	20.89	24.23	21.97	21.86
Shanxi	23.01	24.69	23.83	23.16	20.68	21.68	21.20	20.61	18.17	17.93	19.14	19.82
Inner Mongolia	20.53	21.87	20.46	23.49	26.18	23.73	19.23	21.44	18.22	18.32	19.11	18.14
Liaoning	32.11	33.02	28.93	31.77	31.28	28.85	27.19	26.88	24.46	22.26	22.44	22.73
Jilin	26.61	24.37	22.20	27.14	20.76	22.64	20.69	18.95	18.53	19.00	20.48	18.80
Heilongjiang	25.28	27.67	22.84	24.05	24.61	23.55	21.22	20.65	21.16	19.51	19.19	18.53
Shanghai	52.99	52.44	46.23	49.38	42.28	47.18	46.59	45.62	46.04	44.81	46.00	45.63
Jiangsu	48.81	55.63	52.27	55.49	53.84	57.58	58.86	58.01	57.20	53.30	51.73	49.58
Zhejiang	41.09	44.61	41.23	42.83	38.48	42.40	41.46	42.05	37.94	37.66	38.88	38.80
Anhui	28.51	31.92	28.56	27.81	30.08	29.75	30.47	29.86	32.02	28.36	28.72	28.70
Fujian	28.16	29.86	24.16	28.62	26.48	29.33	28.80	29.25	27.20	25.77	26.30	26.56
Jiangxi	24.48	25.82	22.07	24.52	24.32	23.53	22.86	23.34	21.85	22.04	21.61	23.31
Shandong	37.96	40.41	37.34	39.04	36.71	37.73	37.93	37.49	36.29	33.77	33.64	33.12
Henan	26.80	28.40	25.96	27.05	25.26	26.21	24.33	25.90	26.44	20.50	24.91	25.07
Hubei	29.60	32.76	30.61	29.35	28.35	28.71	28.82	28.59	29.07	29.35	29.45	29.21
Hunan	27.67	28.94	29.79	29.81	28.45	28.25	28.59	29.01	27.77	26.63	26.59	26.82
Guangdong	52.65	53.65	51.89	54.88	49.38	53.00	52.44	52.71	53.62	55.24	59.55	59.49
Guangxi	20.87	22.70	22.56	23.41	22.67	23.06	22.30	23.62	22.81	21.19	21.87	21.17
Hainan	23.40	21.31	21.95	21.46	23.30	24.10	26.79	28.03	25.68	22.49	22.79	22.90
Chongqing	27.44	29.53	29.85	30.77	28.08	33.88	32.90	32.99	32.04	30.05	30.30	30.87
Sichuan	29.10	33.61	29.95	31.07	28.35	27.16	26.98	26.39	29.07	27.52	27.04	28.03
Guizhou	21.13	23.31	19.00	22.62	20.77	22.60	20.41	21.22	25.64	22.19	22.27	23.60
Yunnan	21.69	24.32	20.74	21.78	19.37	21.32	21.13	20.30	19.72	20.43	21.48	21.11
Shaanxi	28.21	29.12	27.79	29.80	27.48	27.68	26.86	27.14	29.29	26.05	26.49	27.34
Gansu	19.21	20.93	19.83	22.41	19.70	22.20	23.58	21.68	22.06	20.82	20.05	20.10
Qinghai	18.05	18.99	16.30	18.41	17.62	17.65	16.19	17.71	15.78	18.13	20.97	20.11
Ningxia	18.12	20.16	20.89	19.72	16.80	20.32	17.64	18.52	20.04	20.68	19.45	20.94
Xinjiang	19.17	22.93	20.38	20.81	20.32	20.39	18.49	18.04	19.86	20.04	19.93	18.19