The Emergence of a Sustainable and Reliable Supply Chain Paradigm in Supply Chain Network Design

Table 9

Summary of research background.

Article code

Network structure

Multiconfiguration

Problem conditions

Sustainability

Emission policy

Reliability

Objective

Product

Period

Transport

Modeling

Uncertainty type

Economic

Environmental

Social

Index

Entity

Method

[R1]

OL

M

S

S

S

MILP

F, S

C

—

SD

—

PD

D

SB

[R2]

CL

M

M

S

S

MILP

D

π

Score

—

Max

PQ

P

FR

[R3]

OL

M

M

S

M

MILP

F, S

C

Score

Score

—

DR

S

SB

[R4]

CL

M

S

S

S

MILP

F, R, S

C

E

—

Min

DR

D

SB

[R5]

CL

M

M

S

S

MILP

F, R

C

—

DC

—

DT

D

Min

[R6]

OL

S

M

S

M

MILP

R

C

E

—

Cap

DR

M, D

SB

[R7]

OL

M

M

M

M

MILP

F, S

C

EC

JC

C&T

TD

M

FR

[R8]

CL

M

S

S

S

MILP

F

C

—

DC

—

TD

P

SB

[R9]

CL

M

S

S

M

MILP

R

C

—

DC

—

Re

TM

Max

[R10]

OL

S

S

M

M

MILP

F, S

C

EC

AT, JC, SA

Cap

CD

W

FR

[R11]

OL

M

S

S

S

MILP

F, S

C

Score

Score

—

CD

S, M

FR

[R12]

CL

M

S

S

S

MILP

R

C

—

DC

—

ST

P

Max

[R13]

CL

M

M

M

M

MILP

F

C

E

—

Min

DD

S

Max

[R14]

OL

M

S

S

S

MILP

D

C

E

—

Min

PD

S

FR

[R15]

OL

S

S

S

S

MILP

D

C

EC

—

Tax

DI, MB

M

FR

[R16]

CL

M

M

M

S

MILP

S

C

CE

JC

Min

DR

M, W, CC

SB

[R17]

OL

S

M

M

M

MINLP

D

C

E

—

C&T

DR

S

Min

[R18]

CL

M

S

S

S

MILP

F

C

E

—

Min

DD

W

Max

[R19]

OL

S

M

M

M

MILP

F, R, S

C

E

—

Cap

DR

S

SB

[R20]

OL

M

M

M

M

MILP

F, R

C

E

JC, SD

Min

DD

M, W

FR

[R21]

OL

M

S

M

S

MILP

F, R

C

EC

ED, JC

Min

FE

M, D, R

Min

[R22]

OL

S

M

S

M

MILP

D

C

E

—

C&T

DR

S

FR

[R23]

OL

M

M

S

M

MINLP

S

C

EC

—

C&T

Re

S, M, W, RE, TM

SR

[R24]

OL

M

M

M

S

MILP

F

C

Score

Score

Max

DD

S, W

FR

[R25]

OL

S

S

M

M

MILP

D

C

E

—

Min

DD

S, C

SB

[R26]

OL

M

M

M

M

MILP

D

C

—

JC, ED

—

DD

W, V

FR

[R27]

OL

M

S

M

S

MILP

F, R

C

EC

RE

Cap

DT

R

SB

[R28]

CL

M

M

M

S

MILP

R

π

Score

—

Min

DT

P

Max

[R29]

CL

M

S

S

S

MILP

F

C

E

JC, RE, IP, DP

Min

DD

M

FR

[R30]

OL

S

M

S

S

MILP

S

C

E

—

Cap

DD

R

SB

[R31]

CL

M

M

M

S

MILP

S

C

CE

JC

Min

DR

M, W, CC

SB

[R32]

CL

M

M

S

S

MILP

F

C

E

JC

Min

DR

S, IC

SB

[R33]

OL

M

M

S

S

MILP

R

C

Score

Score

Max

DR

S

SB

[R34]

OL

S

M

M

S

MILP

R

C

EC

JC, SD

Min

CD

M, CC, RE

Min

[R35]

OL

M

S

M

M

MILP

F, R

C

E

JC, DC

Min

DT, DD

M, W

Max

[R36]

CL

M

M

S

S

MILP

D

π

CE

IP

Min

DR

S

SB

[R37]

OL

M

M

M

M

MILP

S

C

E

DC, ED

Min

FE, PQ

D, W

Min

[R38]

OL

S

M

M

S

MILP

F, R

π

EC

JC

Min

DR

M

Min

[R39]

CL

M

S

S

S

MILP

D

π

E

DP

Min

DR

S, D

SB

[R40]

OL

M

S

S

S

MILP

F

C

E

—

Min

Re

S, P

Max

[R41]

CL

M

M

M

S

MILP

S

C

E

JC, SD, ED

C&T

Re

S

SR

[R42]

CL

M

M

M

M

MINLP

D

π

EC

JC, SD

C&T

DD

S, M, D, CC, RE, R, V

FR

Table guide. Network structure (OL: opened-loop, CL: closed-loop). Configuration (S: single, M: multi). Problem conditions uncertainty type (D: deterministic, F: fuzzy, R: robust, S: stochastic). Sustainability economic (C: cost, P: profit). Sustainability environmental (E: GHG emission, EC: emission cost). Sustainability social (AT: annual turnover, RD: responsiveness to demand, EG: economic growth, JC: job creation, SA: social acceptance, SD: sick leaves). Reliability index (DR: disruption risk/risk value, DeR: deresiliency, Re: reliability, DI: defective items, DT: delivery time, TD: technology disruption, CD: capacity disruption, DD: delivery demand/order, PD: potential downtime, PQ: products quality, MB: machine breakdown). Reliability entity (S: supplier, M: manufacture/power plant/production process, D: distribution/pole center/distributed generators, W: warehouse/storage center, C: customer/demand zone, CC: collection center, P: product/parts, RE: recycling center, R: route/line, TM: transportation mode, V: vehicle). Reliability model (SB: scenario-based, SR: structural reliability, FR: failure rate).