Research Article
Joint Transfer Extreme Learning Machine with Cross-Domain Mean Approximation and Output Weight Alignment
Table 3
Accuracy of different algorithms on MSRC + VOC2007 and Reuters-21578 datasets.
| Methods\dataset | Nontransfer learning algorithm | Transfer learning algorithm | 1NN | SVM | ELM | SSELM | TCA1 | TCA2 | JDA1 | JDA2 | DAELM_S | DAELM_T | ARRLS | TELM-OWA | JTELM |
| MSRC vs. VOC | 35.95 | 35.10 | 38.56 | 37.52 | 27.52 | 27.12 | 35.82 | 37.52 | 38.34 | 33.60 | 34.64 | 41.37 | 40.32 | VOC vs. MSRC | 45.23 | 54.69 | 58.00 | 63.20 | 47.44 | 48.31 | 54.22 | 54.61 | 58.37 | 30.61 | 50.35 | 66.22 | 70.76 | Average | 40.59 | 44.90 | 48.28 | 50.36 | 37.48 | 37.71 | 45.02 | 46.06 | 48.35 | 32.10 | 42.50 | 53.79 | 55.54 | Orgs vs. people (1) | 72.85 | 75.25 | 77.24 | 80.30 | 74.09 | 73.76 | 75.99 | 80.63 | 76.64 | 48.71 | 80.55 | 63.74 | 83.28 | People vs. orgs (2) | 72.03 | 77.12 | 79.30 | 84.72 | 73.65 | 74.54 | 77.12 | 85.85 | 78.41 | 47.72 | 84.56 | 64.27 | 85.53 | Orgs vs. place (3) | 67.50 | 70.18 | 63.57 | 69.61 | 70.66 | 71.72 | 70.95 | 74.98 | 68.53 | 43.81 | 72.20 | 68.09 | 76.32 | Place vs. orgs (4) | 61.12 | 63.77 | 64.57 | 71.16 | 68.80 | 70.18 | 67.52 | 75.98 | 68.77 | 42.50 | 74.11 | 74.68 | 78.74 | People vs. place (5) | 52.65 | 60.63 | 57.01 | 66.02 | 61.84 | 62.58 | 59.89 | 64.07 | 59.14 | 42.46 | 65.18 | 59.04 | 67.5 | Place vs. people (6) | 53.39 | 57.94 | 58.68 | 61.65 | 60.82 | 60.82 | 54.60 | 57.38 | 58.77 | 39.93 | 58.56 | 60.45 | 64.34 | Average | 63.26 | 67.48 | 66.73 | 72.24 | 68.31 | 68.93 | 67.68 | 73.15 | 68.38 | 44.19 | 72.53 | 65.05 | 75.95 | Total average | 57.59 | 61.84 | 62.12 | 66.77 | 60.60 | 61.13 | 62.01 | 66.38 | 63.37 | 41.17 | 65.02 | 62.23 | 70.85 |
|
|
Bold values indicate that the value is the best result of the row in which it is located.
|