|
Year | Author | Pathogenesis | Age (y) | Sex | Location on tongue | Size | Symptom | Duration | Course of discovered events | Diagnostic imaging | Preoperative diagnosis | Local recurrence | Follow-up | Reference number |
|
1950 | Breckenridge and Lukens | Developmental malformation theory | 23 | F | Right anterior 2/3 | 1 cmØ | None | Un. | Un. | None | Fibroma | Un. | Un. | 8 |
1956 | Peimer et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 27 | F | Left anterior 2/3 | | Gagging, foreign body sensation | 5 months | Un. | None | Fibroma | Un. | Un. | 9 |
1967 | Cataldo et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 39 | F | Posterior tongue | 1 cmØ | None | 4 months | Physical examination | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 10 |
1968 | Jahnke and Daly | Not trauma, developmental malformation theory | 22 | F | Posterior to CP | | Lump | 13 years | Asymptomatic | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 11 |
1968 | Begel et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 22 | F | Area of CP | | Dysphagia | 2 years | Slowly getting bigger | None | Fibroma | Un. | Un. | 12 |
1968 | Kaye | Un. | 26 | F | Base of the tongue | | Lump | Childwood | Slowly getting bigger | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | 13 |
1971 | Krolls et al. | Un. | 22 | F | Anterior to CP | 0.75 cmØ | None | 2 years | Un. | None | Papilloma | Un. | Un. | 1 |
1971 | Krolls et al. | Un. | 23 | M | Area of CP | | Un. | Un. | Un. | None | Hyperplast papilla | Un. | Un. | 1 |
1971 | Krolls et al. | Un. | 23 | M | Area of FC | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | None | Papilloma | Un. | Un. | 1 |
1971 | Krolls et al. | Un. | 25 | F | Posterior tongue | 0.5 cmØ | Un. | 4 months | Un. | None | Fibroma | Un. | Un. | 1 |
1971 | Krolls et al. | Un. | 39 | M | Area of CP | | None | Un. | Un. | None | Hyperplast papilla | Un. | Un. | 1 |
1971 | Krolls et al. | Un. | 73 | M | Posterior tongue | Un. | Gagging | Several years | Un. | None | Papilloma | Un. | Un. | 1 |
1971 | Goldberg et al. | Un. | 65 | M | Lateral border | 1 cmØ | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | 14 |
1975 | McClendon | Un. | 15 | F | Area of FC | | Lump | None | Physical examination | Thyroid scan: failed to show ectopic thyroid tissue, a thyroid scintigram: normal | Lingual thyroid | Un. | Un. | 15 |
1975 | McClendon | Un. | 20 | M | Posterior tongue | 0.7 cmØ | None | None | Physical examination | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 15 |
1976 | Engel and Cherrick | Developmental malformation theory | 31 | M | Mid third right border | 2 cmØ | Lump | 3 years | Oral cavity examination | Dental X-P | Un. | No | 2 years | 16 |
1979 | Sugita et al. | Un. | 29 | F | Area of FC | | None | 12 months | Slowly getting bigger | Dental X-P | Un. | No | 6 months | 17 |
1981 | Ohno et al. | Un. | 44 | M | Posterior to FC | | Un. | 6 years | Slowly getting bigger | Dental X-P | Benign tumor | Un. | Un. | 18 |
1981 | Sato et al. | Un. | 14 | F | Anterior to CP | 0.4 cmØ | Lump | 4 years | Slowly getting bigger | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 19 |
1982 | Esguep et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 63 | F | Right border | 0.5 cmØ | Lump | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | 20 |
1983 | Wasserstein et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 50 | F | Mid third | | Lump | 3 months | Oral cavity examination | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 21 |
1984 | Main | The posterior tongue: embryological development The anterior tongue: trauma or inflammation | 54 | F | Posterior to FC | 1.5 cmØ | Lump | Childwood | Un. | None | Un. | No | 1 month | 22 |
1984 | Sheridan | Un. | 20 | F | Anterior to CP | 1 cmØ | Lump | From birth | Un. | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 23 |
1984 | Shimono et al. | Not trauma, developmental malformation theory | 37 | F | Area of FC | | Lump | 8 years | Un. | None | Lingual thyroid | Un. | Un. | 24 |
1984 | Shimono et al. | Not trauma, developmental malformation theory | 47 | F | Posterior tongue | 1 cmØ | Lump | 12 months | Slowly getting bigger | Dental X-P | Benign tumor | Un. | Un. | 24 |
1985 | Weitzner | Developmental malformation theory | 25 | F | Posterior tongue | | Lump | None | Physical examination | None | Cyst | No | 6 weeks | 25 |
1985 | Weitzner | Developmental malformation theory | 27 | F | Posterior tongue | | Lump | None | Physical examination | None | Benign tumor | No | 7 weeks | 25 |
1985 | Weitzner | Developmental malformation theory | 52 | F | Mid third | | None | None | Physical examination | None | Benign tumor | No | 2 months | 25 |
1987 | Markaki et al. | Un. | 25 | F | Posterior to FC | | Lump | 5 months | Asymptomatic | The thyroid gland was normal to palpation | Un. | Un. | Un. | 26 |
1987 | Tohill et al. | Un. | 26 | F | Right anterior 2/3 | | None | None | Oral cavity examination | None | Fibroma | Un. | Un. | 27 |
1987 | Tohill et al. | Un. | 31 | F | Anterior to CP | | None | Un. | Examination | None | Lingual thyroid, fibroma, salivary gland neoplasm | Un. | Un. | 27 |
1987 | Tohill et al. | Un. | 68 | M | Left posterior 1/3 | | None | 2 years | Oral cavity examination | None | Papilloma | Un. | Un. | 27 |
1987 | Van Der Wal and van der Waal | Developmental malformation theory | 61 | F | Anterior to CP | 2 cmØ | None | 15 years | Slowly getting bigger | None | Un. | No | 2.5 years | 28 |
1988 | Cannon and Niparko | Un. | 51 | F | Posterior tongue | Un. | Lump | 20 years | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | 29 |
1989 | Bernard et al. | Un. | 21 | F | Area of FC | 2 cmØ | Lump | 12 years | Physical examination | CT: densely ossified mass | Un. | No | Un. | 30 |
1993 | Ishikawa et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 53 | F | Area of FC | 0.8 cmØ | Foreign body sensation | 3 days | Foreign body sensation | None | Benign tumor | No | Un. | 31 |
1996 | Wei Cheong et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 23 | F | Posterior to FC | 1.5 cmØ | Un. | 13 years | Slowly getting bigger | The thyroid gland was normal to palpation | Lingual thyroid, fibroma | No | 12 months | 32 |
1996 | Manganaro | Un. | 27 | M | Posterior tongue | | Gagging | Un. | Slowly getting bigger | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 33 |
1996 | Manganaro | Un. | 44 | M | Posterior tongue | | Gagging | Several months | Slowly getting bigger | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 33 |
1998 | Lin et al. | Not trauma, the posterior tongue: developmental malformation, other site: trauma | 21 | F | Posterior tongue | 1.2 cmØ | Lump | 5 years | Asymptomatic | None | Fibroma | No | 4 years | 34 |
1998 | Supiyaphun et al. | Un. | 19 | F | Area of FC | | None | 11 years | Un. | None | Un. | No | Un. | 6 |
1998 | Supiyaphun et al. | Un. | 21 | F | Area of FC | | Lump | 5 years | Un. | None | Un. | No | Un. | 6 |
1998 | Supiyaphun et al. | Un. | 22 | M | Area of FC | | None | Un. | Examination | None | Un. | No | Un. | 6 |
1998 | Supiyaphun et al. | Un. | 25 | F | Area of FC | | Lump | 12 months | Un. | None | Un. | No | Un. | 6 |
1998 | Supiyaphun et al. | Un. | 27 | F | Area of FC | | None | Un. | Examination | None | Un. | No | Un. | 6 |
1998 | Supiyaphun et al. | Un. | 28 | F | Area of FC | | Throat irritation | 4 years | Un. | None | Un. | No | Un. | 6 |
1998 | Supiyaphun et al. | Un. | 35 | F | Area of FC | | None | Un. | Examination | None | Un. | No | Un. | 6 |
1998 | Vered et al. | Un. | 27 | M | Posterior to CP | | Pain, gagging | None | Slowly getting bigger | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 35 |
1998 | Vered et al. | Un. | 44 | M | Posterior to CP | | Gagging, nausea, dysphagia | Several months | Un. | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 35 |
2007 | Benamer and Elmangoush | Un. | 14 | F | Midline posterior 1/3 | 1 cmØ | Gagging | More than ten years | Painless but slowly getting bigger | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 36 |
2007 | Demirseren and Aydin | Not trauma | 28 | M | Anterior 2/3 | | Gagging | 4 years | Slowly getting bigger | None | Pyogenic granuloma | No | 48 months | 37 |
2008 | Andressakis et al. | Local trauma from dentures | 72 | M | Area of CP | | Pain, dysphagia | Several years | Asymptomatic | None | Un. | Un. | Un. | 38 |
2009 | Naik et al. | Not trauma | 25 | F | Posterior tongue | | Lump | 5 years | Slowly getting bigger | Un. | Un. | Un. | Un. | 39 |
2011 | Liu et al. | Not trauma | 17 | M | Area of FC | | Lump | Several years | Asymptomatic | None | Un. | No | Un. | 40 |
2016 | Adhikari et al. | Not trauma | 15 | F | Area of FC | 0.5cmØ | Throat irritation | 12 months | Painless but gradually swelling | None | Fibroma | No | 5 months | 41 |
2016 | Adhikari et al. | Not trauma | 21 | F | Area of FC | 0.5 mØ | Pain | Un. | Oral cavity examination | None | Un. | No | 48 months | 41 |
2016 | Turan et al. | Un. | 41 | F | Posterior tongue | | Throat irritation | 6 months | Examination | Ultrasonographic evaluation: normal thyroid gland | Lingual thyroid, mucocele, lingual thyroglossal duct cyst | No | 4 months | 42 |
2017 | Heinz et al. | Not trauma | 21 | F | Base of the tongue | 0.5 cmØ | Lump | Un. | Asymptomatic | Fiberoptic examination | Un. | No | 3 months | 43 |
2020 | Sun et al. | Un. | 23 | M | Base of the tongue | | Lump | Un. | Un. | None | Benign tumor | Un. | Un. | 3 |
2020 | Sun et al. | Un. | 27 | M | Base of the tongue | | Lump | 3 months | Un. | None | Benign tumor | Un. | Un. | 3 |
2020 | Leigh et al. | Developmental malformation theory | 37 | F | Base of the tongue | | Gagging | 3 months | Physical examination | Ultrasonographic evaluation: normal thyroid gland | Un. | No | 26 months | 44 |
2020 | Hemmi et al. | Not trauma | 89 | M | Base of the tongue | 1 cmØ | Cough | Un. | Prolonged cough | Cervical spine CT: well-defined, rounded, high-density mass | Un. | No | 15 months | 45 |
|