Optimization of Simultaneous Delivery and Pickup Wagon Scheme on Hybrid Siding Network of Railway Terminal

Table 7

Performance for TSHOP, TPA-GA, and TPA-ABCA applied to the instance with 16 item tasks.

Parameter set			OFV			CPU time (s)			RAT1 (%)	RAT2 (%)
		φ	TSHOP	TPA-GA	TPA-ABCA	TSHOP	TPA-GA	TPA-ABCA
50	120	0.6	14246.94	16077.18	15268.66	240.07	106.13	199.92	0.13	0.07
50	160	0.6	14047.16	16380.32	15366.64	350.05	167.62	311.83	0.17	0.09
100	120	0.6	16978.24	19411.92	18526.36	212.26	96.50	165.30	0.14	0.09
100	160	0.6	16601.68	19522.2	18267.66	331.52	150.28	272.93	0.18	0.10
Average			15468.50	17847.9	16857.33	283.47	130.13	237.50	0.15	0.09