Research Article

[Retracted] Measurement of Coordination Degree between Economy and Logistics in Hebei Province, China, Based on Fractional Grey Model (1, 1)

Table 12

CCDs between economy and logistics in Hebei.

YearCoupling degree CCoupling stageComposite level of logisticsComposite level of economyComposite level TCCD DCCD level

20110.7740Running-in0.01510.06720.08230.2524Moderate incoordination
20120.7806Running-in0.01650.07160.08810.2623Moderate incoordination
20130.8068High0.02010.07800.09810.2813Moderate incoordination
20140.7923Running-in0.02060.08500.10550.2892Moderate incoordination
20150.8066High0.02220.08650.10870.2962Moderate incoordination
20160.8375High0.02670.09110.11780.3141Mild incoordination
20170.8138High0.02670.10070.12730.3219Mild incoordination
20180.8914High0.04060.10780.14830.3636Mild incoordination
20190.9338High0.05530.11690.17220.4010Weak incoordination
20200.9587High0.06690.12000.18690.4233Weak incoordination
20210.9794High0.08910.13410.22310.4675Weak incoordination
20220.9950High0.12130.14820.26960.5179Weak coordination
20230.9999High0.16830.16670.33500.5788Weak coordination
20240.9943High0.23700.19120.42820.6525Mild coordination
20250.9797High0.33760.22480.56230.7422Moderate coordination