Review Article

Circulating Nucleic Acids in Colorectal Cancer: Diagnostic and Prognostic Value

Table 5

Comparison of genetic methods for CRC diagnosis and screening.

MethodsAdvantagesLimitationsBioinformatics tools

ALU-based q-PCRAcceptable specificity, diagnoses CRC patients from healthy individuals [121] (screening and prognostic value for CRC disease)Low sensitivity for differential diagnosis of stage I/stage II CRC and adenomas [121]REST, pyQPCR, PrimerPy, GenEx, MultiD PowerNest, qBASE+ [122]

KRAS mutation analysisExists in 40% CRC cases mostly in codons 12 [36], negative predictive factor for metastatic CRC to treat with anti-EGFR antibodies [123], and correlates with the prognosis of the disease [124]Not declaredCOSMIC, TCGA, GSEA, GO enrichment, KEGG, STRING, CPTAC, [125127]

NGS assay:
(1) Safe-SeqS
(2) TEC-Seq
Detects somatic mutations in CRC early stages [8], prognosis and prediction to anti-EGFR antibodies or drug selection [8]Not declaredIon Torrent, Illumina, Read Filtering and Trimming, Burrows–Wheeler transform algorithm, Torrent Mapping Alignment Program, SAMtools Genome Analysis Toolkit (GATK), and Picard [128]

BRAF mutation analysisDifferentiating CRC from precancerous or state and distinctive histologic subtype of CRC [129], correlates with poor prognosis of the disease [130], and predictive biomarker for targeted therapy and prognosis [95]It exists in 5%–10% of CRC tumors and should be used with other markers [131]CBioportal, oncomine [132]

APC mutation analysisExists in 85% of colorectal tumors and 60% of stage I/II CRC patients, differentiating CRC from precancerous or lesions [133], and a potential screening and predictive marker to immunotherapy [134]The wide spread of the mutations over variable codons [134]CBioportal, oncomine [132]

RAS mutation analysisExcellent concordance with liver metastases in CRC patients who account for RAS mutations in exons 2 (codons 12 and 13), 3 (codons 59 and 61), and 4 (codons 117 and 146), predictive marker for monitoring the resistance to treatment with monoclonal antibodies (as monotherapy or combined with chemotherapy) [65]Not declaredCOSMIC, TCGA, GSEA, GO enrichment, KEGG, STRING, CPTAC, [125127]

OncoBEAMTM RASOne-step ultra-sensitive quantitative detection of plasma-derived KRAS and NRAS mutations for diagnosis, treatment, and immunotherapy monitoring of mCRC patients after surgery [84, 95], significant low threshold detection [67], kinetical assaying of the mutated haploid GE quantity [67], prognostic value of MAF indicator in mCRC patients [67]Not declaredMPprimer, Ultiplex [135, 136]

IdyllaTM RASAccuracy sensitivity rate of ≤1% and ≤5 for KRAS mutations in exons 2, 3, and 4, respectively (potential assay for highly individualized anti-EGFR therapy and chemotherapy treatment decisions) [84]Two-step assay of RAS mutational status with lower clinical sensitivity than OncoBEAM assay [84]Biocartis Idylla™ System [84]

SSCP methodHigh sensitivity, specificity, for rapid diagnosis of hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) families based on hMLH1 and hMSH2 mutations with a good limit of detection (10%) [137140]The longest turnaround time [137140]GenBank, MUSCLE alignment program [141]

Direct sequencingThe gold standard, highly sensitive, and cost-effective, the quantitative measuring of an individual mutant allele in ctDNA for distinguishing CRC histological type [35, 142, 143]Limited potency for low amount mutant sequences detection in full wild-type DNA sequence context [35, 142, 143]SnackVar, SangeR [144, 145]

Long cell-free DNA fragment/β-globin ratioBiomarker of early colorectal liver metastasis recurrence [146] (patient’s monitoring after CRC surgery)β-globin gene must also be analyzed in cfDNA as an index of overall impair [146]Twoddpcr [147, 148], REST [149]