Review Article

Auricular Acupressure Therapy for Patients with Cancer with Sleep Disturbance: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Table 1

Characteristics of included trials.

Author (year)CountrySample sizes (M/F)Mean age (I/C)DiagnosisCancer stageDiagnostic criteria of insomniaCriteria of auricular acupointsAnticancer treatmentIntervention materialControlAcupoint selectionCourse of treatmentOutcome measuresAdverse effectsDrop-out (I/C)Follow-up

Lei (2019)China96 (60/36)51.49 ± 8.40/52.49 ± 7.09Primary liver cancerI–IIIPSQI > 7GB/T13734-2008Surgery or other therapiesVaccaria seedsRoutine careShenmen, subcortex, heart, sympathetic nerve, endocrine, liver, and spleen3–5 min/time, 3 times/d, 28 dPSQI and SRSSNoneI2/C0Not reported
Lu (2017)China60 (42/18)Not reportedLung cancerNot reportedNot reportedNot reportedRadiotherapyVaccaria seedsRoutine careHeart, Shenmen, anterior lobe, occiput, and subcortex10 press/time, 5-6 times/d, 30 dAISNoneNoneNot reported
Kuo (2018)China4751.5 ± 13.23/54.7 ± 14.56Ovarian cancerI–IVPSQI > 5Not reportedChemotherapyVaccaria seedsRoutine careShenmen, heart, subcortex, and endocrine3 min/time, 3 times/d, 6 wPSQINoneI3/C4Not reported
Yoon (2019)Korea4645.05 ± 8.33/44.57 ± 8.34Breast cancerI–IIIISI  8Not reportedChemotherapyVaccaria seedsPlacebo auricular pressure (helix control points)Shenmen, heart, anterior lobe, and occiput1 min/time, once/d, 6 d/w, 6 wPSQI, IL-6, TNF-α, cortisol, C-reactive protein, and fit bit tracker deviceNoneI3/C2Not reported
Lin (2018)China6036.41 ± 9.13/37.27 ± 10.21Breast cancerIIThe Chinese Classification and the Diagnose Criterion of Mental DisorderNot reportedChemotherapyVaccaria seedsRoutine careShenmen, heart, kidney, subcortex, and sympathetic nerve3–5 min/time, 3–5 times/d, 11 dPSQINoneNoneNot reported
Hughes (2015)Britain6 (2/4)52.25 ± 12.31/54.00 ± 2.83Breast cancer 4 and colorectal cancer 2Not reportedPSQI  5Acupuncture/acupressure textbooks; consult an acupuncturistChemotherapy or radiotherapyVaccaria seedsNo treatmentBilateral Shenmen, any two from insomnia 1, insomnia 2, heart, liver, kidney, and subcortex1 min/time, once/d, 35 dPSQISlight, transient pain of the earNoneNot reported
Wei (2019)China148 (80/68)59.28 ± 9.41/59.14 ± 9.23Lung cancer 30, intestinal cancer 18, gastric cancer 8, breast cancer 8, and pancreatic cancer 10Not reportedGuidelines for diagnosis and treatment of insomnia in Chinese adultsNot reportedNot reportedVaccaria seedsRoutine careShenmen, heart, endocrine, and spleen1-2 min/time, 6 times/d, 14 dPSQINoneNoneNot reported
Song (2014)China100Not reportedGastric cancer 40, lung cancer 40, liver cancer 12, and gallbladder cancer 8Not reportedPSQINot reportedChemotherapyVaccaria seedsRoutine careSubcortex, heart, sympathetic nerve, Shenmen, sympathetic nerve, ear apex, and brain stem, combined with liver, gallbladder, lung, and stomach2-3 min/time, 10 dPSQINoneNoneNot reported
Fan (2015)China12560.0 ± 14.4/63.2 ± 13.5Not reportedNot reportedCAIS-8  8Not reportedChemotherapy, CCRT, or other therapiesMagnetic beadsRoutine careShenmen, heart, occiput, and subcortex20–30 press /time, 3 times/d, 28 dAISNoneI26/C10Not reported

Qualitative inclusion; M/F: male/female; I/C: invention/control; AIS: Athens Insomnia Scale; ISI: Insomnia Severity Index; SRSS: Self-Rating Scale of Sleep; PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index.