Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine / 2021 / Article / Tab 1 / Research Article
Jintiange Capsule May Have a Positive Effect on Pain Relief and Functional Activity in Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Trials Table 1 The basic characteristics of the included studies.
Trail Sample size (T/C) Man/woman Age (y), mean ± SD or median (range) T C Duration (weeks) Main outcomes Jian and Sheng [13 ] 78 (39/39) 30/48 55.39 ± 8.38 JTG capsules Alendronate 12 ①② Yi and Huan [14 ] 120 (60/60) 0/120 56 (48–60) JTG capsules Glucosamine hydrochloride 6 ①② Jianli [15 ] 102 (51/51) NR 66.58 ± 6.23 JTG capsules Glucosamine hydrochloride 6 ②③ Jiewei et al. [16 ] 60 (30/30) 19/41 53.46 ± 5.74 JTG capsules Etocoxib 12 ①③ Fang and Qing [17 ] 80 (40/40) NR 66.31 ± 5.67 JTG capsules Glucosamine sulfate 12 ②④ Cunzhu and Xiaodong [18 ] 120 (60/60) 61/59 61 (45–70) JTG capsules + C Sodium hyaluronate 5 ① Yuhong et al. [19 ] 60 (30/30) 27/33 54.96 ± 10.55 JTG capsules + C Sodium hyaluronate 24 ② Yiebi et al. [20 ] 80 (40/40) NR 52.0 ± 6.4 JTG capsules Loxoprofen sodium 12 ② Zhilin [21 ] 120 (60/60) NR 72.6 ± 10.2 JTG capsules Voltaren 4 ⑤ Fang et al. [22 ] 130 (65/65) 47/83 55.52 ± 5.43 JTG capsules Diclofenac sodium 8 ①③ Yun et al. [23 ] 83 (41/42) 31/52 44.9 ± 6.3 JTG capsules + C Meloxicam 12 ①② Junlian and Pengcheng [24 ] 90 (45/45) 25/65 68.63 (50–75) JTG capsules Aceclofenac 12 ①③ Dahua et al. [25 ] 90 (45/45) 42/48 59.8 ± 1.4 JTG capsules Glucosamine sulfate 4 ① Dongwei [26 ] 90 (45/45) 41/49 60.8 ± 7.1 JTG capsules Piroxicam 12 ①④ Jinping at al. [27 ] 98 (49/49) 48/50 56.9 ± 13.0 JTG capsules + C Naproxen 14 ④ Guoyu [28 ] 72 (36/36) 38/34 66 (60–86) JTG capsules Ibuprofen 12 ① Jiangang et al. [29 ] 60 (30/30) 14/46 61.57 ± 6.68 JTG capsules Aceclofenac 4 ①④ Jian et al. [30 ] 60 (30/30) 16/44 56.85 JTG capsules Voltaren 4 ③ Yunzhao and Lin [31 ] 100 (50/50) 43/57 62.2 (40–80) JTG capsules Glucosamine hydrochloride 12 ① Dongliang et al. [32 ] 72 (36/36) 23/49 58.25 (44–75) JTG capsules Glucosamine hydrochloride 12 ③④ Tao et al. [33 ] 61 (31/30) 26/35 51.3 JTG capsules Glucosamine hydrochloride 12 ① Shuangli et al. [34 ] 70 (35/35) 27/43 62.12 (42–71) JTG capsules Glucosamine hydrochloride 12 ①②
T: trial group; C: control group; NR: not reported; ①: the total effective rate; ②: the VAS score; ③: the WOMAC score; ④: the Lequesne score; ⑤: adverse events. Mean ± SD is mean, and median (range) is median.
