Research Article

Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials of Fuke Qianjin Tablet

Table 2

Characteristics of the studies included in this meta-analysis.

AuthorNa/NbCourseExperimentalControlOutcome

Acute pelvic inflammatory
CCJ (2018) [27]35/3515FKQJP + CPenicillin①③
YML (2013) [28]24/2312FKQJP + CPenicillin
ZJ (2017) [29]48/4815FKQJP + CPenicillin①③
DY (2014) [30]68/6810∼15FKQJP + CPenicillin①②③④
SL (2015) [31]50/5010FKQJP + CPenicillin①②④
TSQ (2019) [32]50/5010FKQJP + CPenicillin
XQX (2014) [33]39/3915FKQJP + CPenicillin + metronidazole①②③
YFY (2013) [34]67/6810∼15FKQJP + CPenicillin + metronidazole①③
RS (2012) [35]36/3610FKQJP + CPenicillin + metronidazole①②
SFM (2015) [36]66/6610FKQJP + CPenicillin + metronidazole①②
ZY (2013) [37]43/4310FKQJP + CPenicillin + metronidazole①④
FXH (2018) [38]39/3914FKQJP + CPenicillin + metronidazole①②③④
SYQ (2015) [39]110/11015FKQJP + CPenicillin + metronidazole①③
ZHY (2012) [40]60/6010FKQJP + CRoxithromycin①②
ZYZ (2012) [41]30/3012FKQJP + CRoxithromycin①②
YCQ (2017) [42]60/607∼14FKQJP + CMoxifloxacin①②
LWR (2013) [43]43/4310FKQJP + CLevofloxacin hydrochloride①③④
WGJ (2011) [44]50/5014FKQJP + CCeftriaxone + tinidazole①②
HRM (2013) [45]60/607∼15FKQJP + CCeftriaxone + tinidazole①②
GSY (2012) [46]30/3010FKQJP + CLevofloxacin lactate + metronidazole①②
ZYH (2016) [47]40/407∼14FKQJP + CGatifloxacin + metronidazole①②
ZNN (2012) [48]30/3012FKQJP + CMetronidazole①②
LJ (2014) [49]36/3614FKQJP + CMetronidazole①④

Chronic pelvic inflammatory
LJX2 (2014) [50]40/4042FKQJPβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole
XZJ (2007) [51]102/10245/21FKQJPβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole
CXC (2019) [52]64/6421FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam①④
DJL (2014) [53]62/6221FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam①②
PGZ (2016) [54]40/4014FKQJP + Cβ -Lactam①②③
SXL (2015) [55]32/3221FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam①③
WQF (2013) [56]35/3520FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam
ZXJ (2015) [57]30/3014FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam①②
ZMY (2017) [58]50/5014FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam①②
LJX1 (2014) [50]40/4042FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole
LXX (2019) [59]43/4315FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole
LH (2019) [60]52/5214FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole①②
PJQ (2019) [61]75/7515FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole
SWA (2014) [62]36/3628FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole
SQB2 (2012) [63]50/5028FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole①②
ZY (2014) [64]54/5428FKQJP + Cβ-Lactam + nitroimidazole①②
SQB1 (2012) [63]50/5028FKQJP+β-lactam + nitroimidazoleFKQJP①②
SPF (2015) [65]75/7514FKQJP+β-lactam + nitroimidazoleFKQJP①②
CF (2018) [66]60/6042FKQJP + CMacrolide①②
DLL (2017) [67]81/8142FKQJP + CMacrolide①②
FJY (2010) [68]63/6315FKQJP + CMacrolide①②
FP (2013) [69]62/6214FKQJP + CMacrolide
KY (2018) [70]100/8614FKQJP + CMacrolide①③
LMY (2016) [71]50/5014FKQJP + CMacrolide
LYK (2016) [72]30/3015FKQJP + CMacrolide①②
LongH (2011) [73]90/9028FKQJP + CMacrolide
RDQ (2019) [74]40/4021FKQJP + CMacrolide
ShaoXL (2012) [75]87/8615FKQJP + CMacrolide
TXG (2015) [76]90/9015FKQJP + CMacrolide①②
WJP (2013) [77]52/4851FKQJP + CMacrolide
YM (2017) [78]50/5051FKQJP + CMacrolide
YQ (2014) [79]67/6715FKQJP + CMacrolide①②
ZYL (2017) [80]40/4020FKQJP + CMacrolide①②
DLH (2019) [81]45/4530FKQJP + CQuinolone
HJY (2019) [82]31/3130FKQJP + CQuinolone①④
LJ (2019) [83]22/2214FKQJP + CQuinolone①②
SJL (2016) [84]53/5330FKQJP + CQuinolone
WJ (2018) [85]40/4014FKQJP + CQuinolone
ZL (2015) [86]40/4021FKQJP + CQuinolone
ZT (2018) [87]160/16021FKQJP + CQuinolone①④
ZhaoJ (2017) [88]55/5528FKQJP + CQuinolone①④
ZengJ (2016) [89]40/4014FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
CXF (2018) [90]58/5842FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③
DCM (2016) [91]47/4728FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③
DQY (2015) [92]25/2528FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
HSX (2019) [93]65/6542FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
HHJ (2019) [94]60/6028FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole
HHM (2019) [95]63/6328FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②③④
HYL (2015) [96]60/6032FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
LML (2019) [97]29/2914FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③
LHR (2013) [98]45/4128FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②③
LXL (2018) [99]41/4114FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①④
LSY (2018) [100]587/58828FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③④
LYZ (2012) [101]35/3528FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③
MYQ (2019) [102]30/3028FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole
RC (2016) [103]60/6014FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole
RL (2017) [104]43/4328FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
SNY·HSY (2016) [105]40/4020FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
SQJ (2012) [106]30/3014FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
YLH (2012) [107]42/4228FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③④
WDD (2017) [108]35/3528FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole
WHL (2011) [109]90/9028FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③
WLY (2019) [110]50/5030FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
WSY (2011) [111]50/5090FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole
WY (2018) [112]36/3628∼42FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole
WDM (2019) [113]48/4828FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
XW (2015) [114]65/6328FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③
XRQ (2018) [115]37/3728FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①③
YDM (2015) [116]30/3028FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
YXH (2016) [117]53/5342FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②
ZhangJ (2017) [118]35/3514FKQJP + CQuinolone + nitroimidazole①②

Endometritis
SFF (2017) [119]44/4445FKQJP + CCefoxitin + doxycycline
SCP (2019) [120]46/4645FKQJP + CCefoxitin + doxycycline
DYY (2019) [121]174/17445FKQJP + CCefoxitin + doxycycline①③④
LY (2019) [122]34/3345FKQJP + CCefoxitin + doxycycline③④
HHF (2017) [123]60/6021FKQJP + CLevofloxacin①②③④
WJF (2019) [124]60/6021FKQJP + CLevofloxacin①③④
MTX (2016) [125]40/4014/42FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①③⑤
SXW (2018) [126]45/4542FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①②④
ZHH (2018) [127]52/5242FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①③⑤
ZL (2019) [128]34/3430FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①③④
DCL (2017) [129]20/2042FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone
DFY (2017) [130]80/8042FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①③⑤
GY (2015) [131]78/7814/42FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①④
LWP (2019) [132]39/3930FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone
MYJ (2018) [133]42/4242FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone
DFL (2017) [134]41/4142FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①③④
HXY (2018) [135]50/5014/42FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①④
ZQ (2019) [136]40/4042FKQJP + metronidazoleMetronidazole + norethisterone①③④
LXZ (2017) [137]64/6414FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①②③
CXH (2017) [138]30/3060FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone
FCF (2016) [139]90/9014/42FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①③④
LBY (2019) [140]30/3014/42FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①③④
LSQ (2017) [141]45/4442FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①②③④
YL (2018) [142]40/4014/42FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①④
ZQ (2016) [143]156/15614/60FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①④⑤
ZCY (2018) [144]14/1442FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone①④
ZGB (2017) [145]41/4142FKQJP + CMetronidazole + medroxyprogesterone
GLJNT (2017) [146]90/9042FKQJP + CMetronidazole + norethisterone①③
CJH (2016) [147]40/4042FKQJP + CMetronidazole + norethisterone①③
AYGL (2018) [148]40/4042FKQJP + CMetronidazole + norethisterone③④
SXX (2018) [149]70/7042FKQJP + CMetronidazole + norethisterone + vaginal douche①③④
XCY (2015) [150]75/7521FKQJP + CMetronidazole + norethisterone + vaginal douche①③④
HF (2016) [151]75/7521FKQJP + CMetronidazole + norethisterone + vaginal douche①④

Note. ①, total effective rate; ②, incidence of adverse reaction; ③, the time of clinical symptom remission/disappearance; ④, serum inflammatory factor concentration. FKQJP, Fuke Qianjin tablet; C, control group regimens.