Research on Effect and Mechanism of Xuefu Zhuyu Decoction on CHD Based on Meta-Analysis and Network Pharmacology

Table 1

The characteristics of all included studies.

Author and reference	Year	Total sample	Control/treatment	Period of treatment (day)	Drug		Evaluation standard
					C	T
Li Jiayun [12]	2019	108	54/54	60	(1), (4), (6)	(11)	1, 3, 9
Lu Jiansheng [13]	2018	64	32/32	60	(1), (3), (6)	(11)	1, 3, 7, 8, 11
Jiao Lixing [14]	2015	78	39/39	30	(1), (10)	(11)	1, 3, 8, 12
Zhao Dongkai [15]	2015	100	50/50	30	(14)	(11)	1, 2, 4
Huang Wenhua [16]	2018	71	35/36	30	(1), (2)	(11)	1, 4
Li Tingai [17]	2019	110	55/55	30	(1), (2), (3)③	(11)	1, 5
Fang Yuxiang [18]	2009	117	57/60	28	(1), (2)②	(11)	1, 7, 8, 13
Ying Ping [19]	2018	100	50/50	60	(1), (3), (4)	(11)	1, 6, 7
Wang Baoxin [20]	2010	58	29/29	30	(1), (8)	(11)	1, 4
Fang Jianjia [21]	2008	60	30/30	28	(2), (3)	(11)	1, 2, 14
Lin Zhijuan [22]	2015	70	30/40	30	(1), (2), (3), (9), (13)	(11)	2, 6, 15
Song Yuxin [23]	2013	82	40/42	28	(1), (6), (7), (9)	(11)	1, 2, 5, 7
Lv Xiqi [24]	2019	100	50/50	60	(1), (3), (5)	(11)	1, 7
Li Guangcheng [25]	2009	80	40/40	30	(1), (2)	(11)	1, 2, 5
Yang Suqing [26]	2015	96	48/48	28	(1), (2), (3)	(11)	1, 3, 5
Zhang Guangyu [27]	2018	92	46/46	28	(1), (3), (8)	(11)	1, 3, 4
Liang Lifeng [28]	2015	100	50/50	28	(6), (7), (9)	(11)	1, 2, 7
Cai Xiaoming [29]	2017	96	48/48	28	(6), (7), (9)	(11)	1
Zhou Fei [30]	2019	80	40/40	28	(6), (7)	(11)	1, 2, 6
Zhang Mingli [31]	2010	80	40/40	28	(2), (7), (9)	(11)	1, 2, 7
Cheng Lisheng [32]	2015	92	46/46	28	(3), (4), (10)	(11)	1, 2, 4, 7

Abbreviations: (1) aspirin; (2) nitroglycerin; (3) isosorbide dinitrate/isosorbide mononitrate; (4) metoprolol; (5) nifedipine; (6) nitrates; (7) β-blocker; (8) Betocloc; (9) calcium antagonist; (10) captopril; (11) Xuefu Zhuyu Decoction based on the control group; (12) lipid-lowering agents and pain relief drugs; (13) clopidogrel and atorvastatin; (14) Compound Salvia Tablets. 1 Total therapeutic effect; 2 ECG; 3 adverse reaction; 4 angina pectoris attack frequency and duration; 5 the total effective of TCM syndromes; 6 serum lipid index; 7 blood stream change; 8 the effect of electroacupuncturing acupoint; 9 vessel endothelial function and factors of vessel endothelium; 10 LVEF and PAF; 11 average hospital stay; 12 disappeared time of angina; 13 effects of decreased dose; 14 symptom improvement; 15 the total angina pectoris efficacy.