[Retracted] Efficacy of the Integration of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Western Medicine in Coronary Heart Disease Comorbid with Anxiety and Depression: A Meta-Analysis

Table 1

Characteristics of included studies (x ± s).

Author	Publication year	Study type	Cases (E/C)	Age (E/C)	Intervention		Cure (W)	Outcome indicators
					E	C
Bao, [14]	2016	RCT	58/58	NA	Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San plus Western medicine	Western medicine	3	1; 2; 3
Dong, [15]	2014	RCT	75/78	(61.25  238)/(62.05  3.41)	Free wanderer pill and spiny jujube decoction, plus Western medicine	Western medicine	4	2; 3
Li [16]	2018	RCT	40/40	63.35  4 40/63.09  4.38	Bupleurum decoction plus dragon bone and oyster shell, plus Western medicine	Western medicine	3	1; 2; 4; 5; 6; 7
Li [17]	2018	RCT	30/30	55.7  7.9/55.4  7.2	Dan Qi San and counterflow cold powder, plus Western medicine	Western medicine	12	8; 9; 10; 11
Liu [18]	2013	RCT	56/48	53  10/58  10	Xin Ke Shu plus Western medicine	Western medicine	2-8	4; 5
Liu [19]	2014	RCT	25/24	60.7  13.6/56.8  10.2	Bupleurum liver-coursing powder plus Western medicine	Western medicine	4	2; 12
Lu [20]	2018	RCT	46/46	61.03  9.44/62.11  8.93	Gallbladder-warming decoction with ten herbs, plus Western medicine	Western medicine	4	3; 9; 13
Peng [21]	2017	RCT	110/110	NA	Bupleurum liver-coursing powder plus Western medicine	Western medicine	4	12; 14
Tan [22]	2015	RCT	100/80	NA	Bupleurum liver-coursing powder plus Western medicine	Western medicine	8	7; 15
Tao [23]	2013	RCT	57/49	NA	Gallbladder-warming decoction with ten herbs, plus Western medicine	Western medicine	4	2; 4; 5; 14
Wang [24]	2018	RCT	40/40	52.5  5.5/51.3  6.1	Bupleurum liver-coursing powder, plus Western medicine	Western medicine	4	2; 1; 9; 5
Zhang [25]	2017	RCT	50/50	56.0  10.2/55.3  9.2	Decoction for quickening blood and transforming stasis combined with gallbladder-warming decoction with ten herbs, plus Western medicine	Western medicine	8	7; 15; 9; 3
Zong [26]	2015	RCT	60/60	37.6  7.9/36.8  8.9	Supplemented free wanderer powder plus fluoxetine	Western medicine	2-8	3; 2; 14

C: the control group; E: the experimental group; W: week; RCT: randomized controlled trial; NA: not available; 1: efficacy for TCM syndromes; 2: efficacy for angina pectoris; 3: HAMD score; 4: SAS score; 5: SDS score; 6: WHOQOL score; 7: clinical effectiveness; 8: angina pectoris score; 9: HAMA score; 10: MADRS score; 11: the number of EPCs; 12: efficacy for depression; 13: SF-36 score; 14: adverse events; and 15: the effectiveness of electrocardiogram.