Research Article

Seismic Damage Analysis of Large-Span Tied-Arch Bridge with Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes Subjected to Near-Fault Ground Motion

Table 7

Damage probability of various failure states.

Type of earthquakeDirectionEarthquake intensity rating (g)Amount of damageCollapse
MinorModerateSevere

Near faultLongitudinalE1 (0.090)44.20%27.45%12.09%6.10%
E2 (0.150)53.22%35.48%17.27%9.34%
E3 (0.195)57.82%39.90%20.41%11.44%
E4 (0.255)62.41%44.55%23.94%13.91%
TransverseE1 (1.176)49.08%31.55%14.54%7.55%
E2 (1.960)57.31%39.24%19.79%10.96%
E3 (2.548)61.44%43.39%22.89%13.09%
E4 (3.332)65.54%47.71%26.31%15.55%
VerticalE1 (0.063)52.54%31.51%12.13%5.25%
E2 (0.105)58.18%36.74%15.26%6.97%
E3 (0.137)61.03%39.54%17.05%8.01%
E4 (0.179)63.87%42.46%19.02%9.18%

Non-near-faultLongitudinalE1 (0.090)43.56%23.68%7.86%3.04%
E2 (0.150)47.16%26.58%9.27%3.72%
E3 (0.195)49.01%28.13%10.07%4.12%
E4 (0.255)50.92%29.76%10.94%4.55%
TransverseE1 (1.176)44.20%24.41%8.34%3.31%
E2 (1.960)48.06%27.56%9.93%4.10%
E3 (2.548)50.05%29.25%10.83%4.56%
E4 (3.332)52.09%31.03%11.81%5.07%
VerticalE1 (0.063)45.33%25.30%8.77%3.52%
E2 (0.105)48.68%28.07%10.19%4.22%
E3 (0.137)50.40%29.54%10.98%4.63%
E4 (0.179)52.17%31.09%11.83%5.07%