Research Article

Design and Performance Analysis of Compact Wearable Textile Antennas for IoT and Body-Centric Communication Applications

Table 2

Comparison of textile antennas with proposed antennas.

Textile antenna structureSubstrate material/conductive materialAntenna parametersBending effects (FS)Body effects
RF (GHz)S11 (dB)BW (MHz)G (dB)E (%)

[31]Wideband monopole:
D: 50 × 64.1 mm2;
F: 2.45 GHz
2 mm jeans cloth/
Copper tape
Simulated
2.45−17.26673.27

[32]E-shaped patch
CPW feed structure:
D: 32 × 30 mm2;
F: 2.45 GHz
2 mm denim cloth/
Copper foil
Simulated
2.45−341531.83

[33]Rectangular loop, CPW fed transmission line, and backside reflector:
D: 62 × 32 mm2;
F: 2.45 GHz
1.5 mm denim fabric/
Conductive fabric
MeasuredPresence of reflector reduces effect of human body
2.47−17285

[34]Centre-fed patch with a U-shape aperture:
D: 70 × 85 mm2;
F: 2.45 GHz
6 mm felt fabric/
Copper tape
MeasuredYesYes
2.4−12100

[26]Textile planar inverted F antenna (PIFA):
D: 80 × 140 mm2;
F: 433 MHz, 2.45 GHz
6 mm thick felt fabric/
Conductive textile sheet
MeasuredThe efficiency decreases by 10% as the radiated patch is shielded by ground
2.42−203096.1

[35]Patch antenna with slots:
D: 115 × 123 mm2;
F: 2.45 GHz
2 mm woven cotton cloth
Zari—silver metallic yarn wrapped in silk thread
Measured40, 60, and 80 mm radii significant changes for various body locationsSignificant changes in S11 and RF for various body locations
2.4−285007.1167

[36]Patch antenna with a full rear ground plane:
D: 80 × 100 mm2;
F: 2.45 GHz
1.7 mm felt fabric/
SieldIT superconductive textile
MeasuredChanges observed
2.44−15706.3361

[37]E-shape triband dipole antenna:
D: 80 × 80 mm2;
F: 2.4, 5.75, and 5.25 GHz
2 mm denim fabric/
Copper tape
Measured30, 50, and 70 mm radii prominent changes observedConsiderable degradation observed
2.45−181001.2640

Dipole antenna:
D: 20 × 60 mm2;
Loop antenna:
D: 75 × 80 mm2;
F: 2.4 GHz
0.44 mm jeans cloth/
Highly flexible copper e-threads
Measured25, 43, 54, and 57 radiiFive body locations
Dipole/loop antenna
2.43/2.5−21/−16.3130/452.3/4.395/98Prominent/minor variationsVariations observed