Analysing the Vulnerability of Public Transport Networks

Table 19

Percentage of removed nodes with which the 80% of reduction in the GC is achieved.

Network	Method	% of removed elements	Network	Method	% of removed elements
Auckland	Pagerank centrality	4.98	EMT	Interactive betweenness centrality	8.35
	Degree	7.47		Pagerank centrality	12.62
	Interactive betweenness centrality	8.67		Degree	13.70
	Betweenness centrality	16.28		Betweenness centrality	24.38
	Random links	28.79		Random links	47.02
	Weighted links	56.85		Eigenvector centrality	51.02
	Random nodes	61.99		Random nodes	52.42
	Eigenvector centrality	64.66		Weighted links	60.22
BC Transit	Pagerank centrality	4.52	Kolumbus	Pagerank centrality	8.89
	Degree	5.79		Degree	12.29
	Interactive betweenness centrality	9.55		Interactive betweenness centrality	15.04
	Betweenness centrality	15.58		Betweenness centrality	19.74
	Random links	30.19		Random links	43
	Eigenvector centrality	59.55		Weighted links	49.75
	Weighted links	68.94		Random nodes	64.17
	Random nodes	86.50		Eigenvector centrality	73.86
STAR	Interactive betweenness centrality	4.53	AVL, CFL, RGTR, TICE	Interactive betweenness centrality	3.57
	Pagerank	14.18		pagerank	6.93
	Degree	15.60		Degree	9.85
	Betweenness centrality	17.73		Betweenness centrality	10.22
	Eigenvector centrality	45.74		Random links	53.51
	Random links	55.53		Eigenvector centrality	39.05
	Weighted links	64.07		Random nodes	64.25
	Random nodes	78.49		Weighted links	66.49
TransAntofagasta	Interactive betweenness centrality	6.63	Linja-Karjala Oy	Interactive betweenness centrality	5.27
	Pagerank	17.83		Pagerank	13.64
	Degree	22.48		Betweenness centrality	17.27
	Betweenness centrality	30.23		Degree	19.09
	Random links	45.31		Eigenvector centrality	37.27
	Weighted links	45.83		Random links	52.48
	Random nodes	65.12		Random nodes	63.51
	Eigenvector centrality	79.84		Weighted links	73.76
CIT	Interactive betweenness centrality	2.90	Thunder Bay Transit	Interactive betweenness centrality	2.31
	Pagerank	5.80		Pagerank	4.88
	Degree	8.70		Degree	7.93
	Betweenness centrality	13.04		Betweenness centrality	18.29
	Random links	38.96		Random links	18.99
	Random nodes	58.70		Random nodes	61.11
	Eigenvector centrality	62.32		Eigenvector centrality	64.63
	Weighted links	74.03		Weighted links	96.97