Journal of Advanced Transportation

Review Article

A Review of Heuristics and Hybrid Methods for Green Vehicle Routing Problems considering Emissions

Table 3

Benchmarks used for the GVRPs.
Benchmark sourceBased on real-world dataArtificially generatedResearch works using this benchmark
Fatemi-Anaraki et al. [75] •Bio-bjective green delivery and pickup problem, Fatemi-Anaraki et al. [75]
Raeesi and Zografos [68] •EVRPTW-RS-SMBS, Raeesi and Zografos [68]
Anderluh et al. [46]••2E-VRPSyn, Anderluh et al. [46]
Camacho-Vallejo et al. [27] •Green logistics biobjective bilevel problem, Camacho-Vallejo et al. [27]
Cheaitou et al. [59] •STPPS, Cheaitou et al. [59]
Fernández et al. [38] •MDGVRP-PD, Fernández et al. [38]
Islam et al. [126] •MFGCLP, Islam et al. [126]
Islam and Gajpal [101] •Mixed-fleet logistics distribution problem under emission cap, Islam and Gajpal [101]
Jiang et al. [94]• MVOC, Jiang et al. [94]
Luo et al. [102] •HHC with synchronized visits and carbon emissions, Luo et al. [102]
Lyu and He [41]• MTHVRP-PCIC, Lyu and He [41]
Malekkhouyan et al. [121] •WCVRP, Malekkhouyan et al. [121]
Solano et al. [79]• VRPSPDTW, Solano et al. [79]
Srijaroon et al. [77] •G-VRPMSPDTW-RT, Srijaroon et al. [77]
Talouki et al. [26]• DGVRP, Talouki et al. [26]
Trachanatzi et al. [125] •E-PCVRP, Trachanatzi et al. [125]
Validi et al. [49]• Three-echelon distribution network, Validi et al. [49]
Alizadeh Foroutan et al. [88] •GVRSP, Alizadeh Foroutan et al. [88]
Alkaabneh et al. [30] •PIRP, Alkaabneh et al. [30]
Asghari and Mirzapour Al-e-hashem [78]• Green delivery-pickup problem for HHMs, Asghari and Mirzapour Al-e-hashem [78]
Arroyo et al. [69]• GVRP-MTPR, Arroyo et al. [69]
Eshtehadi et al. [107]••G-VRPTW, Eshtehadi et al. [107]
Leng et al. [33] •LRPLCCC, Leng et al. [33]
Liu et al. [28]• JD-GVRP, Liu et al. [28]
Wei et al. [21] •Green DRASS with time-varying speeds, Wei et al. [21]
Zhang et al. [109]••VRPTW in cold chain distribution, Zhang et al. [109]
Zhao et al. [84] •2L-MDCVRPB, Zhao et al. [84]
Zulvia et al. [115]• G-VRPTW and time dependency for perishable products, Zulvia et al. [115]
Eshtehadi et al. [133] •G-VRPTW, Eshtehadi et al. [107]
Eskandarpour et al. [65] •HeVRPMD, Eskandarpour et al. [65]
Hooshmand and MirHassani [114] •TDGVRP-AF, Hooshmand and MirHassani [114]
Koc et al.[55]• Variant of PRP, Koç et al. [55]
Meng et al. [110]• Customer-oriented routing problem with environment consideration, Meng et al. [110]
Molina et al. [123]• Eco-WCVRP, Molina et al. [123]
Rezaei et al. [98] •G-VRPTW, Rezaei et al. [98]
Wang et al. [37] •MD-GVRP, Wang et al. [37]
de Oliveira da Costa et al. [18]• GVRP, de Oliveira da Costa et al. [18]
Kargari Esfand Abad et al. [62] •Pickup and delivery PRP variant considering integration and consolidation shipments in cross-docking, Kargari Esfand Abad et al. [62]
Leng et al. [32] •RLCLRPRCC, Leng et al. [32]
Masmoudi et al. [99] •HF-VRPS, Masmoudi et al. [99]
Sousa Matos et al. [90] •GVRSP-split, Sousa Matos et al. [90]
Fang et al. [63] •PRPSPD, Fang et al. [63]
Guo and Liu [58] •TD-PRP, Guo and Liu [58]
Jabir et al. [35] •MD-GVRP, Jabir et al. [35]
Kaabachi et al. [36] •GMDVRPTW, Kaabachi et al. [36]
Liao [89]• Online VRP considers real-time demands, Liao [89]
Yavuz and Çapar [24]••MGVRP, Yavuz and Çapar [24]
Zhou et al. [91]• Green real-life field scheduling problem, Zhou et al. [91]
Gang et al. [87]• GVRSP of free picking up and delivering customers for airlines ticketing company, Gang et al. [87]
Li et al. [42]••2E-TVRP, Li et al. [42]
Goeke and Schneider, [134] •GMFVRPREC-PR, Yu et al. [71]
Kramer et al. [53] •Biobjective PRP, Costa et al. [61]; TD-PRP, Franceschetti et al. [57]; PRP, FCVRP, EMVRP, Kramer et al. [53]
Xiao and Konak [85] •GVRSP, Xiao and Konak [85]
Demir et al. [52] •BiPRP, Demir et al. [52]
Liu et al. [116] •MTHVRPP, Liu et al. [116]
Molina et al. [95]• HVRP-TW, Molina et al. [95]
Schneider et al. [135] •EVRPTW-RS-SMBS, Raeesi and Zografos [68]; GMFVRP-PRTW, Macrina et al. [72]
Demir et al. [51]• CIRP under a mixed fleet of electric and conventional vehicles, Soysal et al. [74]; GVRP, Soysal et al. [25]; CumVRP-TW, Fernández et al. [105]; GLRP, Dukkanci et al. [31]; Biobjective PRP, Costa et al. [61]; GSTDCVRP, Çimen and Soysal [113]; TD-PRP, Franceschetti et al. [57]; F-GVRPSPDTW, Majidi et al. [80]; GSTDCVRP, Soysal and Çimen [113]; MMPPRP-TW, Kumar et al. [60]; GVRSP, Xiao and Konak [86]; PRP, FCVRP, EMVRP, Kramer et al. [53]; BiPRP, Demir et al. [52]; FSMPRP, Koç et al. [54]; PRP, Demir et al. [51]
Omidvar and Tavakkoli-Moghaddam [20] •Congestion in VRP with AFVs, Omidvar and Tavakkoli-Moghaddam [20]
Perboli et al. [136] •2E-CVRPSC, Mühlbauer and Fontaine [47]; 2E-EVRP-BSS, Jie et al. [48]
Maden et al. [96]• VRPTW using time-varying data, Maden et al. [96]
Bredstrom et al.[137] •VRPTW-SPFC, Ettazi et al. [111]; HF-VRPS, Masmoudi et al. [99]
Iori et al. [138] •2L-MDCVRPB, Zhao et al. [84]
Li and Lim [139] •Green-PDPTW, Lu and Huang [82]
Dethloff et al. [140] •G-VRPSPD, Olgun et al. [76]
Gehring and Homberger [141] •G-VRPTW, Yu et al. [108]; G-VRPTW, Küçükoğlu et al. [117]
Salhi and Nagy [142] •G-VRPSPD, Olgun et al. [76]
Golden et al. [143] •HeVRPMD, Eskandarpour et al. [65]; PPRP, Suzuki [56]; PRP, FCVRP, EMVRP, Kramer et al. [53]; BSS–EV–LRP, Yang and Sun [67]
Cordeau et al. [144] •2E-CWCVRP, Liu and Liao [43]; MSW, Qiao et al. [119]; HC-MDVRP, Pérez-Bernabeu et al. [34]
Augerat et al. [145] •E-PCVRP, [125]; HeVRPMD, Eskandarpour et al. [65]; WCP-MDP, Wei et al. [120]; BSS–EV–LRP, Yang and Sun [67]
Chao et al. [146] •Bi-PVRP-SC, López-Sánchez et al. [50]
Taillard [147]••Eco-WCVRP, Molina et al. [123]; BSS–EV–LRP, Yang and Sun [67]
Solomon [73] •2E-VRPSyn, Anderluh et al. [46]; mixed-fleet logistics distribution problem under emission cap, Islam and Gajpal [101]; HHC with synchronized visits and carbon emissions, Luo et al. [102]; MTHVRP-PCIC, Lyu and He [41]; B-MFGVRPTW, Ren et al. [104]; G-VRPTW, Yu et al. [108]; cold chain logistics path optimization, Zhao et al. [100]; G-VRPTW, Sanchez et al. [103]; PRP, FCVRP, EMVRP, Kramer et al. [53]; G-VRPTW, Küçükoğlu et al. [117]; PRP, Demir et al. [51]; congestion in VRP with AFVs, Omidvar and Tavakkoli-Moghaddam [20]
Christofides et al. [148] •E-PCVRP, Trachanatzi et al. [125]; HeVRPMD, Eskandarpour et al. [65]; GVRP, de Oliveira da Costa et al. [18]; PPRP, Suzuki [56]; PRP, FCVRP, EMVRP, Kramer et al. [53]
Eilon et al. [149] •Bi-PVRP-SC, López-Sánchez et al. [50]
Christofides and Eilon [150] •GVRP, Dewi and Utama [22]; 2E-CVRPSC, Mühlbauer and Fontaine [47]; E-PCVRP, Trachanatzi et al. [125]; WCP-MDP, Wei et al. [120]; GVRP, de Oliveira da Costa et al. [18]
Gaskell [151] •GVRP, Dewi and Utama [22]