Research Article

The Control Index for the Construction of Sponge City in the Residential Area: A Case Study of Nanjing Jiangbei New District

Table 8

Advantages and disadvantages of main low-impact development measures.

Technical measuresAdvantagesDisadvantages

Permeable pavingWide application area, convenient construction, can replenish groundwater and have a certain peak flow reduction and rainwater purification effectEasy to block, cold areas are at risk of being destroyed by freezing and thawing
Green roofCan effectively reduce the total amount of roof runoff and runoff pollution loadThere are strict requirements on roof load, waterproofing, slope, space conditions, etc.
Sunken green spaceWide application area, its construction cost and maintenance cost are lowEasily affected by terrain and other conditions, the actual regulation and storage volume is small
Biological retention facilityVarious forms, wide application area, easy to integrate with the landscape, good runoff control effect, low construction and maintenance costsIn areas with high groundwater levels and rock layers, poor soil permeability, and steep terrain, necessary measures such as soil replacement, seepage prevention, and ladder installation should be taken to avoid secondary disasters, which will increase construction costs.
Permeation pondCan effectively supplement groundwater, reduce peak flow, and lower construction costsStrict requirements for site conditions and high requirements for later maintenance and management
Seepage wellSmall footprint, low construction and maintenance costsThe water quality and quantity control effects are limited
Wet pondIt can effectively reduce the total amount of runoff, runoff pollution, and peak flow in a larger areaStrict requirements for on-site conditions, high construction and maintenance costs
Rainwater wetlandCan effectively reduce pollutants, has a certain runoff and peak flow control effectHigher construction and maintenance costs
ReservoirIt has the advantages of saving land, easy access to rainwater pipes, avoiding direct sunlight, preventing mosquitoes and flies, and storing large amounts of water. Rainwater can be reused for green irrigation, washing roads and vehicles, etc.The construction cost is high, and maintenance and management should be paid attention in the later period
Rainwater tankMostly molded products, convenient for construction and installation, and easy for maintenanceThe storage volume is small, and rainwater purification capacity is limited
Regulating pondCan effectively reduce peak traffic, lower construction and maintenance costsThe function is relatively simple
Regulating poolCan effectively reduce peak trafficThe function is simple, high construction and maintenance costs
Grassed swalesLow construction and maintenance costs, easy to integrate with the landscapeAreas such as built urban areas and newly built urban areas with greater development intensity are vulnerable to site conditions
Seepage pipe/drainSmall space requirements for the siteThe construction cost is high, it gets blocked easily, and is difficult to maintain
Vegetation buffer zoneLow construction and maintenance costsHigh requirements for site space, slope, and other conditions, and limited runoff control effects
Initial rainwater discarding facilitySmall footprint and low construction costs, which can reduce the maintenance and management costs of rainwater storage and rainwater purification facilitiesRunoff pollutants and discarded flow are generally not easy to control
Artificial soil infiltrationInfiltration rainwater purification effect is good, easy to integrate with the landscapeHigh construction costs