Revelation of Genotype × Environment Interaction in Linseed (Linum usitatissimum L.) Under Conventional and Natural Farming Production Systems in the North-Western Himalayas

Table 4

(a–d) Percent difference in the mean performance of the genotypes under conventional and ZBNF farming systems for seed yield and oil content.

Genotypes	Seed yield (g)		Difference in seed yield	% difference	Oil content (%)		Difference in oil content	% difference
	Conventional	ZBNF			Conventional	ZBNF
(a)	Location
	Palampur
KL-311	6.23	4.62	1.61	29.76	38.82	39.51	−0.69	−1.75
KL-315	7.35	3.48	3.86	71.33	39.3	41.48	−2.18	−5.41
KL-309	4.48	2.67	1.81	50.67	40.55	41.46	−0.91	−2.22
KL-314	3.49	2.04	1.45	52.45	41.22	41.65	−0.43	−1.04
KL-317	5.28	2.21	3.07	81.92	38.83	40.5	−1.67	−4.22
KL-236	8.85	1.64	7.21	137.6	40.71	41.41	−0.7	−1.7
KL-241	5.76	1.46	4.29	118.94	38.9	39.74	−0.84	−2.14
KL-244	6.5	3.92	2.58	49.45	36.9	40.46	−3.56	−9.2
KL-257	6.31	1.39	4.92	127.96	40.98	42.26	−1.28	−3.07
KL-263	8.11	2.65	5.45	101.34	40.13	38.28	1.84	4.7
KL-269	2.71	3.6	−0.89	−28.2	39.51	39.44	0.06	0.16
KL-278	4.23	2.93	1.3	36.35	39.33	40.53	−1.19	−2.99
KL-279	8.52	2.31	6.22	114.84	39.9	38.46	1.44	3.68
KL-280	7.42	3.83	3.59	63.78	38.67	41.41	−2.74	−6.83
KL-284	4.55	2.3	2.25	65.63	39.02	39.5	−0.48	−1.22
KL-285	7.33	2.43	4.9	100.4	39.36	41.63	−2.27	−5.59
Giza-8	6.72	2.73	3.99	84.42	40.42	39.69	0.73	1.84
Giza-7	8.36	2.17	6.19	117.66	38.82	40.16	−1.35	−3.41
Him Alsi-2	7.07	1.93	5.14	114.38	40.7	43.62	−2.93	−6.94
Nagarkot	8.5	3.38	5.12	86.29	40.58	42.53	−1.95	−4.69
Himani	7.08	1.95	5.13	113.56	40.65	40.29	0.35	0.88
Jeewan	4.24	1.98	2.26	72.75	38.49	39.25	−0.76	−1.95
Baner	9.09	2.48	6.6	114.16	41.4	40.73	0.68	1.65
Bhagsu	5.86	1.77	4.09	107.22	41.81	39.25	2.56	6.32
Himalini	7.08	2.59	4.49	92.77	38.88	41.29	−2.41	−6.01
Him Alsi-1	6.09	3.47	2.62	54.81	38.53	40.27	−1.75	−4.44
Janki	7.61	3.53	4.08	73.34	40.67	38.73	1.94	4.88
Surbhi	7.19	2.33	4.86	102.02	39.33	42.29	−2.96	−7.25
Canada	7.25	4.4	2.85	48.86	39.05	38.67	0.38	0.97
Binwa	4.78	4.1	0.68	15.28	43.95	44.14	−0.19	−0.44
Mean	6.47	2.74	3.72	80.88	39.85	40.62	−0.77	−1.92
(b)	Location
	Bajaura
KL-311	3.54	0.69	2.85	134.63	41.12	38.64	2.49	6.24
KL-315	3.55	0.96	2.58	114.66	40.23	37.2	3.03	7.81
KL-309	2.8	1.34	1.46	70.46	41.31	40.5	0.81	1.99
KL-314	2.73	1.57	1.16	54.24	41.33	39.72	1.61	3.97
KL-317	3.12	0.92	2.2	108.99	38.65	36.78	1.88	4.97
KL-236	3.26	0.89	2.37	114.48	42.14	37.77	4.37	10.94
KL-241	3.41	1.09	2.32	102.87	37.14	37.05	0.09	0.23
KL-244	3.76	0.89	2.86	123.26	39.17	39.01	0.16	0.41
KL-257	3.04	0.84	2.2	113.22	39.65	38.45	1.2	3.08
KL-263	3.57	0.71	2.87	133.95	41.6	40.31	1.29	3.15
KL-269	3.13	1.03	2.1	101.04	40.28	36.6	3.68	9.57
KL-278	2.53	0.95	1.58	90.96	39.59	36.51	3.08	8.1
KL-279	3.29	0.94	2.36	111.42	40.75	39.17	1.58	3.94
KL-280	2.85	1.15	1.7	84.85	37.65	37.01	0.63	1.7
KL-284	3.57	1.33	2.24	91.68	37.81	36.6	1.21	3.25
KL-285	2.87	1.13	1.75	87.45	43.05	40.15	2.9	6.98
Giza-8	4.19	1.25	2.94	107.98	38.4	37.22	1.18	3.13
Giza-7	2.8	0.93	1.87	100.23	40.05	38.66	1.39	3.52
Him Alsi-2	4.04	0.73	3.31	138.98	42.62	40.06	2.56	6.19
Nagarkot	4.04	1.47	2.57	93.18	41.98	39.53	2.44	6
Himani	3.14	0.8	2.33	118.55	39.26	38.65	0.61	1.57
Jeewan	3.57	1.36	2.21	89.62	40.99	39.45	1.54	3.82
Baner	3.32	1.07	2.25	102.66	41.5	39.23	2.26	5.6
Bhagsu	2.32	0.87	1.46	91.29	40.86	38.76	2.1	5.28
Himalini	3.95	1.33	2.63	99.48	40.78	39.53	1.25	3.11
Him Alsi-1	3.92	1.11	2.81	111.79	40.76	39.34	1.42	3.55
Janki	3.53	1.66	1.87	72.11	41.72	39.14	2.58	6.39
Surbhi	4.44	1.51	2.93	98.56	41.22	39	2.22	5.53
Canada	3.52	0.6	2.92	141.98	38.84	36.77	2.07	5.47
Binwa	4.22	1.05	3.18	120.48	44.1	42.56	1.54	3.56
Mean	3.4	1.07	2.33	104.17	40.48	38.65	1.84	4.65
(c)	Location
	Kangra
KL-311	8.6	5	3.6	52.98	38.23	36.61	1.61	4.31
KL-315	8.42	6.51	1.91	25.6	39.29	37.52	1.77	4.6
KL-309	7.97	6.98	0.99	13.32	38.83	37.41	1.42	3.72
KL-314	10.57	9.19	1.38	14	40	36.63	3.37	8.8
KL-317	12.4	6.11	6.29	68	37.85	38.71	−0.87	−2.26
KL-236	9.11	7.79	1.32	15.63	40.14	37.17	2.98	7.7
KL-241	10.8	6.13	4.67	55.15	37.98	35.99	1.99	5.37
KL-244	10.77	8.81	1.96	20.03	36.94	36.16	0.78	2.14
KL-257	9.62	9.16	0.46	4.86	39.49	36.79	2.7	7.08
KL-263	9.76	7.51	2.25	26.07	40.38	38.76	1.62	4.11
KL-269	6.96	5.5	1.46	23.42	39.28	37.75	1.53	3.97
KL-278	9.98	7.89	2.09	23.36	38.22	38.3	−0.09	−0.22
KL-279	6.33	6.98	−0.64	−9.64	38.3	35.39	2.9	7.88
KL-280	6.25	7.02	−0.77	−11.53	37.63	36.56	1.07	2.89
KL-284	6.39	7.86	−1.47	−20.67	37.97	36.88	1.09	2.91
KL-285	8.29	9.51	−1.22	−13.69	38.72	37.01	1.7	4.5
Giza-8	6.59	7.54	−0.95	−13.44	39.31	38.09	1.22	3.14
Giza-7	9.14	8.54	0.59	6.69	38.18	37.44	0.74	1.95
Him Alsi-2	6.45	6.54	−0.09	−1.36	40.32	39.48	0.84	2.11
Nagarkot	10.99	8.35	2.65	27.35	40.04	39.29	0.75	1.88
Himani	11.55	8.07	3.48	35.5	39.49	38.68	0.81	2.08
Jeewan	7.8	7.08	0.73	9.75	39.84	39	0.84	2.14
Baner	7.54	7.86	−0.32	−4.11	39.52	38.47	1.04	2.67
Bhagsu	8.45	5.56	2.89	41.3	41.57	39.68	1.89	4.64
Himalini	9.01	5.13	3.88	54.85	39.32	36.48	2.84	7.5
Him Alsi-1	6.41	5.91	0.51	8.23	39.26	37.51	1.75	4.55
Janki	6.33	4.91	1.42	25.18	41.04	39.13	1.91	4.76
Surbhi	8.54	8.52	0.02	0.23	38.63	38.46	0.17	0.44
Canada	5.44	6.62	−1.18	−19.48	39.83	37.63	2.2	5.67
Binwa	7.02	7.16	−0.14	−2	42.26	38.45	3.8	9.43
Mean	8.45	7.19	1.26	16.1	39.26	37.71	1.55	4.02
(d)	Location
	Dhaula Kuan
KL-311	10.14	4.51	5.63	76.81	37.9	39.46	−1.56	−4.03
KL-315	12.78	5.61	7.17	77.92	38.39	39.09	−0.7	−1.81
KL-309	8.32	3.55	4.77	80.44	38.41	39.45	−1.04	−2.67
KL-314	8.28	3.72	4.56	75.92	38.61	39.04	−0.43	−1.1
KL-317	10.38	4.57	5.81	77.68	36.24	37.03	−0.8	−2.17
KL-236	12.17	3.81	8.36	104.69	38.28	40.25	−1.98	−5.04
KL-241	11.55	4.83	6.72	82.05	37.43	36.65	0.77	2.09
KL-244	10.32	3.75	6.56	93.28	37.52	39.48	−1.96	−5.08
KL-257	7.57	3.13	4.45	83.07	39.7	39.17	0.53	1.35
KL-263	11.61	3.82	7.78	100.91	39.35	39.53	−0.18	−0.46
KL-269	6.98	2.71	4.27	88.06	38.14	40.49	−2.35	−5.98
KL-278	9.21	3.65	5.56	86.44	37.99	36.89	1.1	2.94
KL-279	9.22	3.11	6.1	99.03	38.36	38.04	0.31	0.82
KL-280	7.2	3.18	4.02	77.39	37.49	38.49	−1	−2.64
KL-284	8.27	2.98	5.29	93.97	37.35	38.4	−1.05	−2.77
KL-285	8.71	4.23	4.48	69.2	38.83	38.19	0.64	1.67
Giza-8	7.25	3.15	4.1	78.92	38.45	37.48	0.97	2.54
Giza-7	8.19	4.71	3.49	54.05	37.49	38	−0.51	−1.35
Him Alsi-2	9.93	4.33	5.6	78.62	39.51	39.87	−0.35	−0.89
Nagarkot	11.18	5.75	5.43	64.2	39.66	39.24	0.42	1.07
Himani	9.8	3.47	6.33	95.39	39.61	37.9	1.72	4.43
Jeewan	7.85	3.89	3.96	67.41	38.12	37.57	0.54	1.44
Baner	12.86	4.23	8.64	101.08	39.26	38.64	0.62	1.59
Bhagsu	10.94	4.64	6.3	80.88	42.52	37.82	4.7	11.69
Himalini	9.91	3.68	6.23	91.67	39.84	40.71	−0.87	−2.16
Him Alsi-1	8.84	4.77	4.07	59.77	37.87	37.27	0.6	1.6
Janki	9.85	2.97	6.87	107.21	39.61	40.53	−0.91	−2.28
Surbhi	8.76	2.41	6.35	113.74	38.38	41.45	−3.07	−7.69
Canada	7	2.41	4.59	97.57	37.8	38.02	−0.22	−0.58
Binwa	6.44	3.7	2.74	53.99	43.17	41.64	1.53	3.6
Mean	9.38	3.84	5.54	83.78	38.71	38.86	−0.15	−0.39

The negative values indicate high mean performance under the ZBNF system.