R Peak Detection Method Using Wavelet Transform and Modified Shannon Energy Envelope

Table 3

Comparison of the proposed WTSEE method with other methods for detecting R peaks using the MIT-BIH database.

Method	Total beats^a (TP + FN)	TP (beats)	FN (beats)	FP (beats)	Se (%)^b	+P (%)^b	DER (%)^b	Acc (%)^b
Proposed WTSEE	109,494	109,415	79	99	99.93	99.91	0.163	99.838
ISEE, 2016 [13]	109,532	109,474	58	116	99.95	99.89	0.159	99.841
PSEE, 2013 [23]	109,494	109,401	93	91	99.92	99.92	0.168	99.832
SEHT, 2012 [22]	109,496	109,417	79	140	99.93	99.87	0.200	99.800
DOM, 2008 [12]	109,809	109,751	58	166	99.95	99.85	0.204	99.796
STSE, 2014 [24]	108,494	108,323	171	97	99.84	99.91	0.247	99.753
WT, 2004 [16]	109,428	109,208	220	153	99.80	99.86	0.342	99.660
PT, 1985 [14]	109,809	109,302	507	277	99.54	99.75	0.717	99.288

^aTotal beats—the sum of total beats of all analyzed records in each study. ^bThese values are calculated by total beats.