Fuzzy Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) Applied to the Driving Mechanism of Total Factor Productivity Growth

Table 1

Total factor productivity index and its decomposition (mean value).

Region	Technical efficiency index	Technology progress index	The pure technical efficiency index	Scale efficiency index	Malmquist index of TFP
Beijing	1.024952	1.01281	1.010857	1.011857	1.002238
Tianjin	1.025333	1.014429	1.010952	1.010476	1.005095
Hebei	1.023	1.024286	1.007476	1.010762	1.00881
Shanxi	1.018952	1.026571	1.007238	1.010095	1.018762
Neimenggu	1.01781	0.977619	1.005286	1.007857	0.964952
Liaoning	1.015476	0.979429	1.006286	1.007286	0.971381
Jilin	1.014857	0.999286	1.005952	1.004524	0.998476
Heilongjiang	1.015286	1.001571	1.006667	1.004429	0.998333
Shanghai	1.014667	1.012286	1.008048	1.003095	1.013905
Jiangsu	1.005333	1.01419	1.000476	1.004333	1.011476
Zhejiang	1.007429	1.02481	1.003286	1.00319	1.021095
Anhui	1.006952	1.016952	1.00381	1.003524	1.014286
Fujian	1.003381	1.022	1.000333	1.004333	1.014571
Jiangxi	1.007095	1.013095	1.00381	1.002762	1.00881
Shandong	1.004381	1.021476	1.001952	1.002	1.018619
Henan	1.005381	1.01681	1.003619	1.001286	1.021048
Hubei	1.007905	1.023714	1.005476	1.001048	1.032476
Hunan	1.009286	1.019714	1.006952	1.000619	1.034
Guangdong	1.011952	0.985381	1.009	1.000952	1.002524
Guangxi	1.011571	0.98419	1.008143	1.000667	1.000476
Hainan	1.026524	0.970714	1.014381	1.010952	1.009238
Chongqing	1.019238	0.969095	1.009048	1.009667	0.99981
Sichuan	1.02719	0.978	1.011619	1.013952	1.018952
Guizhou	1.024143	0.982048	1.012286	1.011476	1.020286
Yunnan	1.02019	0.993619	1.005857	1.016905	1.026476
Shaanxi	1.017095	1.002952	0.998143	1.01719	1.033048
Gansu	1.019619	0.980571	0.997333	1.01919	0.999857
Qinghai	1.022238	0.986524	1.004667	1.017905	1.00519
Ningxia	1.031476	0.993714	1.007571	1.024667	1.014286
Xinjiang	1.038	1.005476	1.005714	1.027619	1.023143
Mean value	1.016557	1.001778	1.006075	1.008821	1.010387