Mobile Information Systems

Research Article

Two-Factor Authentication and Key Agreement Schemes for Smart Home Fingerprint Characteristics

Table 3

Evaluation different schemes using a common metrics.
Evaluation metrics
ProtocolReferenceC1:No password verifier-tableC2: Password friendlyC3:No password exposureC4: No smart card loss attackC5: Resistance to known attacksC6: Sound repairabilityC7: Provision of key agreementC8: No clock synchronizationC9: Timely typo detectionC10: Mutual authenticationC11: User anonymityC12: Forward secrecy
Roy et al. (2018)[27]√√√××√√×√√√×
Islam et al. (2018)[31]√√√×××√√√√√√
Jia et al. (2019)[21]√×√√√×√√×√√×
Patonico et al. (2019)[22]×√√×××√√×√√√
Gupta et al. (2019)[8]√×××√×√××√√√
Gope et al. (2019)[40]√×√√××√××√√×
Li et al. (2020)[9]√×××××√√×√×√
Shabisha et al. (2020)[23]√√××√×√××√√×
Shin-Kwon (2020)[11]××√√√√√×√√√√
Ali et al. (2020)[12]×√√√××√××√√√
Chen-Chen (2021)[39]×√√√√×√√√√√√
Masud et al. (2022)[34]×√×××√√√√√×√
Ours√√√√√√√√√√√√