Analytical Solutions of Heat Transfer and Film Thickness with Slip Condition Effect in Thin-Film Evaporation for Two-Phase Flow in Microchannel

Table 2

Comparison of previous studies on evaporating extended meniscus.

Authors	Numerical solution	analytical solution	Finding analytical equation for δ	Slip condition
Potash and Wayner [5]	ο	x	x	x
Moosman and Homsy [15]	ο	ο	x	x
Schonberg and Wayner [9]	ο	ο	x	x
Stephan and Busse [7]	ο	x	x	x
Schonberg et al. [16]	ο	ο	x	x
Shikhmurzaev [17]	x	ο	x	x
Ma and Peterson [10]	ο	x	x	x
Pismen and Pomeau [18]	x	ο	x	x
Catton and Stroes [19]	ο	ο	x	x
Choi et al. [20]	ο	x	x	ο
Qu and Ma [21]	ο	ο	x	x
Choi et al. [22]	ο	x	x	ο
Park and Lee [23]	ο	x	x	x
By Morris [24]	x	ο	x	x
Demsky and Ma [25]	ο	x	x	x
Jiao et al. [26]	x	ο	x	x
Na et al. [27]	ο	ο	x	x
Sultan et al. [28]	x	ο	x	x
Wang et al. [14]	ο	x	x	x
Ma et al. [29]	ο	x	x	x
Wang et al. [13]	ο	ο	x	x
Zhao et al. [30]	ο	x	x	ο
Zhao et al. [31]	ο	x	x	ο
Benselama et al. [32]	x	ο	x	x
Biswal et al. [33]	ο	x	x	ο
Liu et al. [34]	x	ο	x	x
Bai et al. [35]	ο	ο	x	x
Biswal et al. [36]	ο	x	x	x
Thokchom et al. [37]	ο	x	x	x
Yang et al. [38]	ο	x	x	x
Current study	ο	ο	ο	ο