Cloud Particles Differential Evolution Algorithm: A Novel Optimization Method for Global Numerical Optimization

Table 7

The mean solutions, standard deviation, maximum, and minimum of the 30 trials obtained by various methods for CEC2013 problems.

	DE	CMAES	JADE	jDE	PSOcf	PSOwFIPS	UPSO	ABC	CPDE
	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)			(≈)	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
			(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
		(≈)	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)		(≈)	(≈)			(≈)
SD
Max
Min
SD
Max
Min
				(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)		(≈)	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
		(≈)
SD
Max
Min
SD
Max
Min
SD
Max
Min
SD
Max
Min
			(≈)
SD
Max
Min
SD
Max
Min
			(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
						(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)				(≈)
SD
Max
Min
			(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)	(≈)			(≈)
SD
Max
Min
SD
Max
Min
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)		(≈)			(≈)	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)		(≈)	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
		(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)		(≈)
SD
Max
Min
	(≈)			(≈)		(≈)	(≈)
SD
Max
Min
General merit over contender	10	17	2	8	18	19	10	7