Parameter Improvement of the Soccer League Competition Algorithm by Introducing Stubborn Players: Application to Water Distribution Network

Table 10

Computational results of the New York Tunnels network.

Algorithm	Number of runs	Best cost ()	Mean evaluations
MMAS [22]	20	38.64	30 700
PSO [18]	2000	38.64	NA
HD-DDS [23]	50	38.64	47 000
GHEST [25]	60	38.64	11 464
SS [21]	100	38.64	57 583
DE [19]	50	38.64	5 494
SADE [26]	50	38.64	6 598
SLC [11]	100	38.64	15 764
Modified soccer league algorithm	100	38.64	15 311