Parameter Improvement of the Soccer League Competition Algorithm by Introducing Stubborn Players: Application to Water Distribution Network

Table 12

Wilcoxon test of the experimental problems.

Proposed algorithm versus	Two-loop			Hanoi			New York
	GA [27]	210	88	0.001	—	—	—	—	—	—
SA [28]	120	36	0.012	—	—	—	—	—	—
SLA [13]	123	37	0.033	—	—	—	—	—	—
SCA [14]	144	41	0.002	—	—	—	—	—	—
Modified genetic algorithm [15]	101	29	0.011	—	—	—	—	—	—
PSO [16]	111	33	0.012	93	24	0.002	119	89	0.003
DE [17]	213	56	0.03	117	34	0.021	144	47	0.034
HS [19]	122	37	0.041	—	—	—	—	—	—
SS [18]	144	54	0.032	127	51	0.043	154	71	0.011
PSO + DE [16]	123	77	0.037	—	—	—	—	—	—
PSHS [19]	142	56	0.000	—	—	—	—	—	—
SLC [11]	13	6	0.049	43	6	0.39	33	8	0.042
MMAS [20]	—	—	—	134	67	0.001	89	23	0.003
HD-DDS [29]	—	—	—	129	66	0.037	65	29	0.016
GENOME [22]	—	—	—	178	50	0.045	—	—	—
GHEST [23]	—	—	—	280	67	0.001	90	34	0.019
SADE [24]	—	—	—	128	44	0.029	138	79	0.022