Parameter Improvement of the Soccer League Competition Algorithm by Introducing Stubborn Players: Application to Water Distribution Network

Table 4

Results obtained by different metaheuristics for two-loop network.

Algorithm	Mean evaluations	Cost ()
GA [14]	65 000	419 000
SA [15]	25 000	419 000
SLA [13]	11 155	419 000
SCA [16]	11 019	419 000
Modified genetic algorithm [17]	2440	419 000
PSO [18]	5138	419 000
DE [19]	4750	419 000
HS [20]	2891	419 000
SS [21]	3215	419 000
PSO + DE [18]	3080	419 000
PSHS [20]	233	419 000
SLC [11]	2051	419 000
Modified soccer league algorithm	1031	419 000