Research on Influencing Factors of Adoption Behavior of Mobile Readers Based on Meta-Analysis

Table 1

Literature review in the field of mobile reading acceptance.

Author (Year)	Subject	Participants	Number of samples	Literature source
∗Xiong (2010) [5]	The adoption behavior of mobile phone reading service	College students, masters, doctors, and other groups	451	Thesis
Pan (2011) [31]	Acceptance behavior of mobile reading users	Most of them are college students	411	Thesis
Lai and Chang (2011) [22]	Attitudes toward using e-book readers	High school students, college students, and graduate students	288	Online information review
Han et al. (2012) [15]	The adoption behavior of mobile readers	High school students, college students, and graduate students	392	Soft science
Chang (2013) [18]	Mobile reading efficiency	Undergraduate and graduate students	363	Library hi tech
Liu (2013) [6]	Influencing factors of children’s online reading behavior	8- to 12–year-old children and their parents	256	Thesis
Hao (2013) [7]	The adoption of e-books	College students, colleges, undergraduates, masters, doctors, etc.	1034	Thesis
∗Shen (2019) [32]	Research on mobile reading adoption model	Most of the users are undergraduates	426	Library science research
∗ Lao and Gao (2013) [16]	Factors influencing consumers’ adoption of mobile reading	Consumers in Shanghai	594	Consumer economy
Chiang and Chen (2014) [19]	r-book reading willingness	All users	352	The electronic library
∗Ge (2014) [23]	Behavioral intentions of cell phone reading	Students of Nankai university and Tianjin university using mobile phone libraries	328	Library work and research
∗Zheng (2014) [25]	Digital reading behavior	Undergraduates of Fudan university	977	Thesis
∗ Huang and Fan (2014) [26]	Digital reading behavior	Freshman	302	Publishing science
Ye (2014) [28]	Mobile reading adoption behavior	18- to 30-year-old youth	413	Thesis
Dong (2014) [24]	Mobile reading behavior	Zhejiang college students	425	Journal of Jiaxing university
Zhang (2014) [8]	The adoption behavior of mobile reading users	Cover users of all ages and education levels	311	Thesis
Williams et al. (2014) [17]	E-book consumption willingness	All users	234	Journal of computer information systems
Park et al. (2015) [33]	Reading intention of e-books	All users	219	The electronic library
Hsiao and Chen (2015) [10]	The efficiency of mobile readers	Third grade	60	Library hi tech
∗ Chen et al. (2015) [9]	Users’ adoption intention of mobile reading charge service	All users who have been in contact with mobile reading	190	Digital library forum
∗ Mao et al. (2016) [11]	Research on the adoption behavior of mobile readers	College students	382	New century library
∗ Xu et al. (2017) [12]	Research on the factors influencing the acceptance behavior of library mobile reading users	Public library users and university library users	425	Library and information work
Wang et al. (2017) [27]	Willingness to use mobile libraries	All users	201	Library hi tech
∗ Zhang et al. (2018) [13]	The adoption behavior of mobile reading APP users	All users	310	Digital library theory and practice
Zhao and Xie (2019) [30]	Chaoxing mobile reading platform APP use intention	University student	379	Library and information work
Ji et al. (2020) [34]	Influencing factors of social reading behavior	College students and teachers	195	Library forum
Chen and Zhu (2020) [35]	The influencing factors of the transfer behavior from paper-based reading to mobile reading	College students and teachers	298	Library science research
Liu et al. (2020) [20]	Digital reading intentions	Children aged 9–14	252	Library construction
Li and He (2020) [14]	The influence of perceived value of mobile reading	All groups, mainly undergraduates	335	Knowledge management forum
Zhang (2020) [21]	The influencing factors of mobile reading	All users	383	Thesis
∗ Zheng (2020) [29]	The influencing factors of digital reading	College students	308	Thesis

The documents marked with ∗ do not provide correlation coefficients between variables, so the calculation is based on the path coefficients provided by them.