Research and Application of Intelligent Layout Design Algorithm for 3D Pipeline of Nuclear Power Plant

Table 3

Results of different design methods.

Method	Length of pipelines	Number of bends	Time consumed (ms)	Achievement rate of objectives (%)	Achievement rate of constraints (%)
The proposed algorithm	439	16	2,918	95	100
The original A algorithm	392	31	4,953	60	20
Manual design	500	16	900,000	100	100