Competitiveness Evaluation and Obstacle Factor Analysis of Urban Green and Low-Carbon Development in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Cities

Table 5

Obstacle degree of the urban green and low-carbon development competitiveness index.

City	Item	2013 year			2016 year			2019 year
		1	2	3	1	2	3	1	2	3
BJ	Obstacle index	S2	P3	P1	P3	S2	P1	P3	P1	S1
	Obstacle degree	14.2	13.8	12.2	12.2	12.1	11.4	11.8	10.9	9.7
TJ	Obstacle index	P7	P4	R2	P7	P4	S2	P4	P7	S1
	Obstacle degree	17.3	12.7	9.7	13.5	10.7	8.5	9.7	9.5	7.8
SJZ	Obstacle index	S2	S1	R2	S2	S1	R2	R2	S2	S1
	Obstacle degree	13.0	9.8	9.4	12.3	8.9	8.2	10.8	10.4	7.3
CD	Obstacle index	R2	P3	P7	R2	P7	P4	R2	P4	P7
	Obstacle degree	21.7	18.8	15.8	19.8	14.9	13.4	16.4	12.7	9.8
ZJK	Obstacle index	P3	R2	P7	P4	R2	P7	R2	P7	P3
	Obstacle degree	22.5	20.8	18.3	21.5	19.3	18.6	16.9	13.5	11.3
QHD	Obstacle index	P7	R2	P3	P7	R2	S4	R2	P7	S4
	Obstacle degree	18.4	14.2	11.7	16.7	12.9	10.6	11.4	11.2	9.5
TS	Obstacle index	P3	R2	S2	R2	P2	S2	R2	P3	S4
	Obstacle degree	15.3	13.8	9.7	12.4	11.8	8.7	10.3	9.5	8.5
LF	Obstacle index	P3	S2	P7	R2	S2	P2	R2	P7	P2
	Obstacle degree	11.9	11.6	10.3	16.7	10.6	10.3	14.4	10.1	10.1
BD	Obstacle index	R2	S2	S7	S2	R2	S1	R2	S2	S1
	Obstacle degree	13.9	12.4	8.7	11.4	11.0	10.3	9.5	9.5	8.7
CZ	Obstacle index	R2	P3	P2	R2	S2	P2	R2	S2	P3
	Obstacle degree	15.7	12.5	11.7	12.6	12.4	10.6	11.5	10.8	10.6
HS	Obstacle index	P7	R2	S2	P7	S2	R2	P7	R2	S3
	Obstacle degree	17.6	11.8	10.4	15.5	10.1	10.0	12.2	11.2	10.3
XT	Obstacle index	P7	S2	R2	P7	S2	R2	P7	R2	S2
	Obstacle degree	16.3	11.2	11.0	15.5	11.1	10.4	14.3	11.3	10.7
HD	Obstacle index	P7	P3	R2	P7	S2	R2	P7	P3	R2
	Obstacle degree	19.7	16.8	9.9	16.3	12.8	9.1	11.4	10.4	8.9